Playing the saxophone Worst sax playing on a classic rock song?

@thomsax , you lovely man!

These were moments when your meaning was lost and refound

Your first post says*, "Bad sax playing is called, 'English saxophone'"

Your second post shows your actual meaning, that 'English Saxophone', is a snobbish view of saxophone playing†



*On this side of the North Sea

†Or have I got that wrong too?

Now you make me confused! Did I write that?

Quoted from the text.

"Det händer ibland att jag tänker på det här med de engelska popsaxofonisterna. Hur kunde det gå så illa att när man i jazzkretsar använder uttrycket engelsk saxofon, så vet alla vad man menar, och det är inte en komplimang."

Google translated.

"Sometimes I think about this thing with the English pop saxophonists. How could it get so bad that when you use the term English saxophone in jazz circles, everyone knows what you mean, and it's not a compliment."

Quoted from the text.

"För oss jazzmusiker däremot är det han (Stuart Matthewman) spelar ett skämt, ett riktigt amatörtutande av någon som spelar blues som djävulen läser bibeln, ja det finns bara ett sätt att förklara hur illa det låter, det låter "engelsk saxofon" helt enkelt."

Google translated.

"For us jazz musicians, on the other hand, what he's playing is a joke, a real amateur blaring of someone who plays the blues like the devil reads the Bible, well there's only one way to explain how bad it sounds, it sounds "English saxophone" simply."

This is snobbish. The bad saxophone is all-around. And he also think that the sax in blues, Rock & Roll, Rock was a result of jazz saxophonists that started to play R&B, Rock & Roll, Soul, Rock ... songs. I think the secret is that there were guys in the studios that knew what the wanted from the jazz men. A short solo 4 or 8 bars maybe a riff. Norbert's chronicle is provocative. And that is ok. He wanted that listeners should start to talk about his thoughts/chronicle.. And he succeed?

I still think the saxophone sounds and comes out bad as well on Mott The Hoople's "All the Way to Memphis". I don't blame the saxophonist. I also wrote "There are some really bad saxes in Rock and Pop!" In Sweden, Germany,, UK, USA .... Not only UK.
Back in in the late 60's and early 60's they started to use horns in Rock and Pop. Bands Chicago, Blood Sweat and Tears, The Rolling Stones, Bruce Springsteen and The E Street Band .... and the listeners liked it. In USA they had long tradition in having horns when they recorded. Many good producers, A&R persons in USA like Buddy Lucas, Jesse Powell, Maxwell Davis, Gene Barge, Allen Toussaint, Rick Hall, Cosimo Matassa ... that influenced other to work in the same direction. We don't have this tradition in Sweden. Maybe in UK?

I've listened to lots of UK music with some saxes/horns. Ian Dury, Graham Parker, Nick Love, Mickey Jupp .... . And I like it.
 
I thought that I was familiar with this song. I heard it today and perhaps I am listening with a different ear. It sure sounds like a sax on Mott The Hoople's 1973, All The Way To Memphis. The sax starts out pretty good but as the song goes on the thing goes off of the rails. I looked at live videos and there is no sax or anything that sounds like a sax Maybe folks here can tell me what you think. The solo starts at 3:13, I assume that the player is trying for altissimo notes but is getting only squeals?

All The Way From Memphis/Mott The Hoople​

Sounds like he has his lower teeth on the reed rather than failed altissimo.
 
A sax solo that been played live is one thing but we are talking about saxes that are recorded. An improvised sax solo live or sax solo that's been recorded and mixing.

When I hear a "bad" solo (badly produced, a cliché solo, a solo that is not in the right genre, a "tourettes" solo .... ) I ask myself what's wrong with a grounded horn/sax soli?
 
Last edited:
A sax solo that been played live is one thing but we are talking about saxes that are recorded. An improvised sax solo live or sax solo that's been recorded and mixing.

When I hear a "bad" solo (badly produced, a cliché solo, a solo that is not in the right genre, a "tourettes" solo .... ) I ask myself what's wrong with a grounded horn/sax soli?

Ever heard the adage “If someone says they remember the ‘70s, they are lying.”?

Ever hear someone play music that they perceived as really good, but you were a bit more sober then them and heard it differently??? Or maybe you thought that you really killed a solo, but the sober person in the back of the audience didn’t feel the same way?

Yeah, it happens…
 
Definitely intentional. Colin is actually a phenomenal player. But his avant-garde style is not my cup of tea. This particular one just makes me laugh.
A classic case of applying the wrong genre in a song. Colin Stetson is an amazing player- but avant garde over pop-rock seems a strange thing. I've come across, and experienced, a fair few instances of sax players applying bebop techniques over blues or rock and roll- often to pretty dire effect....
 
A classic case of applying the wrong genre in a song. Colin Stetson is an amazing player- but avant garde over pop-rock seems a strange thing. I've come across, and experienced, a fair few instances of sax players applying bebop techniques over blues or rock and roll- often to pretty dire effect....
I can only assume the band knew exactly what they were getting when they hired Colin and probably heard variations of that same solo in the studio and on the road many, many times. If they thought it was wrong, surely they'd have gotten somebody else for the job eventually. But I agree with you that it's out of place according to my sensibilities. This particular one is both funny and sad since the bass sax is such a cool instrument. It can do a lot more than sound like a moose in pain.

What's more interesting to me is that some of the greatest solos in pop history are considered to be the worst by some in this thread. I'd like to hear the reasoning behind that. Personally, I grew up in the 70s and 80s, which was a great period for sax in pop music. As a kid, I learned every pop sax solo I heard, including Baker Street and thought those hooks sounded great, as did millions of others. I was thrilled to hear the instrument I played on the radio all day, every day.

Also, are we talking about an "improvised" solo, or just a riff like in Baker Street?
 
I can only assume the band knew exactly what they were getting when they hired Colin and probably heard variations of that same solo in the studio and on the road many, many times. If they thought it was wrong, surely they'd have gotten somebody else for the job eventually. But I agree with you that it's out of place according to my sensibilities. This particular one is both funny and sad since the bass sax is such a cool instrument. It can do a lot more than sound like a moose in pain.

What's more interesting to me is that some of the greatest solos in pop history are considered to be the worst by some in this thread. I'd like to hear the reasoning behind that. Personally, I grew up in the 70s and 80s, which was a great period for sax in pop music. As a kid, I learned every pop sax solo I heard, including Baker Street and thought those hooks sounded great, as did millions of others. I was thrilled to hear the instrument I played on the radio all day, every day.

Also, are we talking about an "improvised" solo, or just a riff like in Baker Street?
I think that I understand what you are talking about. I was listening to some different interpretations of, Back Home Again in Indiana on Youtube. They pretty much shared the same super fast sax solos that to me sound like mush. When I hear a great guitarist do that it sounds crisp and clean to me. I am sorry but when performed on a sax it sounds like mushy nonsense notes. Baker Street, Turn the Page, Tequila, Just a Giglio, and Yakety Sax, the notes are clean and make sense. To me these musicians were playing to their audience, not to impress other musicians.
 
Clarence Clemons was the best sax player to play Springsteen songs. Live and in the studio. Bobby Keys was the best sax player to play Jagger/Richard songs. Without John Fogerty's and Van Morrison's stubbornness to play sax, their music wouldn't be the same, Without the cluster of recording sax players that worked close to recording artist and the recording companies the music wouldn't be the same. There is some kind of "nearness and relationship". They were present.

Sonny Rollin ("Waiting For A Friend"), Joel Peskin ("Kokomo"), Chris Mercer ("Let's Stick Together"), Raphael Ravenscroft "(Baker Street"), Andy Mackay ("All The Way From Memphis"), Stuart Matthewman ("Smith Operator") ...... Needless to write, all theses sax men did good jobs with their saxes and are fine players (..... Ravenscroft was not so happy with the result on Baker Street according to Wikipedia) .... . But I can't help, the saxes in these song are chafing like new football shoes did to me. Not much but enough to change to the old ones... . A woodshed honker like me is not the right person to judge? I played "Let's Stick Together" but I played this Wayonne Harrison song with a more "juicy and dirty" way ( tbf it's just the way I can play😉) . Not so clean and dry!
 
Last edited:
While the frankly baffling noodlings of Colin Stetson my well be a step to far may I salute another Kings of applying avant garde tendencies in rock .- Davey Payne. Especially the solo from Hit me with your hythm Stick.... the fact he even came up with the idea of that double sax riff borders on genius
 
Last edited:
Clarence Clemons was the best sax player to play Springsteen songs. Live and in the studio. Bobby Keys was the best sax player to play Jagger/Richard songs. Without John Fogerty's and Van Morrison's stubbornness to play sax, their music wouldn't be the same, Without the cluster of recording sax players that worked close to recording artist and the recording companies the music wouldn't be the same. There is some kind of "nearness and relationship". They were present.

Sonny Rollin ("Waiting For A Friend"), Joel Peskin ("Kokomo"), Chris Mercer ("Let's Stick Together"), Raphael Ravenscroft "(Baker Street"), Andy Mackay ("All The Way From Memphis"), Stuart Matthewman ("Smith Operator") ...... Needless to write, all theses sax men did good jobs with their saxes and are fine players (..... Ravenscroft was not so happy with the result on Baker Street according to Wikipedia) .... . But I can't help, the saxes in these song are chafing like new football shoes did to me. Not much but enough to change to the old ones... . A woodshed honker like me is not the right person to judge? I played "Let's Stick Together" but I played this Wayonne Harrison song with a more "juicy and dirty" way ( tbf it's just the way I can play😉) . Not so clean and dry!

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jwO0Mgzlg3I


Greg S.
 
My own theory why they started to record saxes with overdub and other effects to make it bigger was that they wanted repeat the big success that Springsteen E Street Band had with songs with a sax. Clarence Clemons a had a big sound. To play an easy Clarence Clemons solo live they had to play with two saxes in unison.? Mindi Abair and Tom Saviano both tenor saxes are playing the solo together.
View: https://youtu.be/p0df2zTviqI


I learn "Baker Street" on tenor. I was not easy to "crib". In my opinion a song that was written without a saxophone in mind. But it became a big success.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,576
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom