Tech/maintenance Why so many spring cradles?...

DavidUK

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,133
Location
Near Evesham, Worcestershire
Just rebuilding a vintage Beaugnier tenor, and struggling with the upper stack.

Why three spring hooks in a row (far one a bit fuzzy)? The far one also seems rather distant from the far post.

20230822_163432.jpg


Here's a view from the other direction with the same fuzzy foot in the distance. And again two hooks "sharing" a spring hole. Perhaps the French just put holes and hooks on everything, just in case?

20230822_163357.jpg


Anyhow, I'll go look at a similar one to see where I'm getting confused... doesn't help that there were a few loose springs in the case when I got it!

NB. Apologies in advance to all our esteemed techs for my ignorance.
 
Last edited:
"Spring Hooks" are the tools you use to unhook the springs and re-hook them 😉

You mean "spring cradles"....and all I can figure is...Beaugnier had a reputation for mixing and matching their parts....whoever made that one probabaly just grabbed the feet portions with cradles when they were silver soldering those keys. Or maybe they were temporarily out of the non-cradled foot version....

First one is the C cup and upper stack bench, of course. The second one is the Front F, and there's no need for a cradle on the front F...the third I'd guess is the B, which would have a cradle...Fourth one is correct, it is on the A key...


....the FIFTH one, funniest of all to me...is on the lower key foot of the C key bench, absolutely pointless 😛
 
Thanks George.

Yes, spring cradles, of course!

So I need missing needle springs on the B and A, coming from the posts to each cradle's right, that's fine. Three other springs missing from elsewhere too (so far) but I have these sussed (he said confidently - I'll be back if not!).

What annoyed me is that the B spring is 0.9mm as I found one too short of that gauge which fits. I pulled out my supply of springs and opened the 0.9mm packet, only to find they're 0.85mm, mis-labelled.
If I flattened the end of a 0.85mm spring will it be OK to use instead of 0.9mm until I get the correct one? One way to find out I guess...

By the way, when flattening a needle spring it's intuitive to have the flat in line with the direction of push, or pull, but is it correct?
 
Why not just test the questionable keys to see if they operate normally without springs?

Flat alignment doesn’t matter, but I’ve always done it parallel with travel.
 
Perhaps the French just put holes and hooks on everything, just in case?

Yep. I've been working on a Beauginer bari, and most posts have at least 2 holes,
while there are cradles here, there, and somewhere else.
I wish I'd made notes on which cradles weren't used, because I didn't notice
it when I took it apart. And I keep getting distracted trying to figure out if I've
misplaced a spring, got it back together wrong, or it's just... extra.

t
 
They had one stamping tool for several different key feet, so they all got the notch. You can see the contour is the same for all the feet. Some they cut short to braze to the bar, others they left long to be actual feet with cork on.

Fewer part numbers to manage, less tooling cost, higher volumes ordered from the stamping house.
 
What annoyed me is that the B spring is 0.9mm as I found one too short of that gauge which fits. I pulled out my supply of springs and opened the 0.9mm packet, only to find they're 0.85mm, mis-labelled.
If I flattened the end of a 0.85mm spring will it be OK to use instead of 0.9mm until I get the correct one? One way to find out I guess...
Worth getting are those very thin reamers which can actually ream out existing spring holes to make them slightly larger...they aren't expensive, and very handy. Makes one not have to go nuts with exact matching of replacement spring....
 
All back together now. A key didn't need a spring but there were half a dozen more missing. What fun.
Playing it today I noticed if I'm playing Bb, B bis key touch down, the A key touch does flap about as it has no spring to hold it open.

I checked two other tenors and both have a needle spring acting on the A key's hinge tub to keep A open when the B bis touch is depressed, as Jaye/George had said above.

The Beaugnier does have an empty spring cradle on the A hinge tube and there's a post with an empty hole in it lower down but it's about 1 1/2 spring lengths between cradle and post. Anyone ever had to use an extra long spring for this kind of thing?
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,565
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom