Playing the saxophone Why so expensive

I was happy paying £22/hr when I had lessons, but that was maybe five years ago in Leicestershire.

Everything is more expensive now, especially in London. I too would baulk at £50/hr and perhaps look online. But there's nothing like 1:2:1 teaching to get you to a certain competency, whether that's technique, theory, or just being able to play a dozen tunes well.
 
I was happy paying £22/hr when I had lessons, but that was maybe five years ago in Leicestershire.

Everything is more expensive now, especially in London. I too would baulk at £50/hr and perhaps look online. But there's nothing like 1:2:1 teaching to get you to a certain competency, whether that's technique, theory, or just being able to play a dozen tunes well.
I really don't mind paying that if a need a lesson a month...At the mo its playing to scores and rhythm need some intensity..no way can i go to 200 a month its pointing counting at the mo.. again not criticising a teachers value...ill find a way..
 
Hi for me tho theory side i can do but playing the theory side....help required..lol
Perhaps the problem is right there.

Your expensive hobby is someone else's profession and livelihood. Qualifications don't come cheap.

How to get from where you are to where you want to be is difficult. What you want and what you need may be quite different. A specialist instrument teacher may not give you what you want but what you need.
Adult education classes is a cheaper route to take.
A quick google reveals an hour piano lesson costs £35 in London and £24 in Manchester.
So maybe the problem is London. I'm still paying £1.59 for a pint of beer up here in the wilds of the North.

The cheapest route is to buy a book and study it. Meanwhile...scales and arpeggios and daily practice.
4 hours a day for a decade and it starts to come.
 
Perhaps the problem is right there.

Your expensive hobby is someone else's profession and livelihood. Qualifications don't come cheap.

How to get from where you are to where you want to be is difficult. What you want and what you need may be quite different. A specialist instrument teacher may not give you what you want but what you need.
Adult education classes is a cheaper route to take.
A quick google reveals an hour piano lesson costs £35 in London and £24 in Manchester.
So maybe the problem is London. I'm still paying £1.59 for a pint of beer up here in the wilds of the North.

The cheapest route is to buy a book and study it. Meanwhile...scales and arpeggios and daily practice.
4 hours a day for a decade and it starts to come.
Tbf @colinthebear Given time you can study from books re theory but putting theory into playing practice takes an element of support...i have no issues carrying on the way i do things...i can play for fun... lots of folk on here talk about dwindling intetest in the saxophone maybe the affordability of learning and the lack of a different way promotes the exclusion of a large % of people..no one is saying that qualifications come cheap, but many dont become musicians to teach but to play professionally...i wouldnt charge an apprentice the going gas rate to learn..it would be unaffordble and where would future gas engineers come from if that was the only way...
 
Last edited:
many dont become musicians to teach but to play professionally
I don't think you are right with this, unless you are one of the elite few most pro musicians would struggle to make a good living out of playing professionally, the higher paid gigs are simply few and far between, lots of venues have closed over the last 5/7 years so teaching is one way to make a living, as I have said you are unfortunate to live in London where prices are high, perhaps online might be cheaper but nothing beats a 1-2-1 lesson to help with your progress.
 
I don't think you are right with this, unless you are one of the elite few most pro musicians would struggle to make a good living out of playing professionally, the higher paid gigs are simply few and far between, lots of venues have closed over the last 5/7 years so teaching is one way to make a living, as I have said you are unfortunate to live in London where prices are high, perhaps online might be cheaper but nothing beats a 1-2-1 lesson to help with your progress.
yes London is getting ridiculous price wise...i genuinely thought that the main aim of going to the guildhall or studying jazz / music was to make a living out of playing regardless of whether its high paying gigs or weddings, pubs etc. I thought teaching would be subsidiary to playing. it can't be cheap to pay your way through and i respect anyone who has taken that path. Lessons for me have to be 1-2-1 it is a worry not just for me that there aren't resources available at a reasonable price..I know as @Colin the Bear says time and practice but guidance is required. so without being able to afford lessons and joining a group...wheres the fun...there seems to be know group lesson's teacher's could earn more, no weekly saxnight classes, it will vanish if things don't change..
 
It may not be a consolation but from the perspective where I live, greater Munich area, your prices are kind of cheap.
Iam taking lessons in a music school where the wages of the teachers are subsidized. It is still 75 € per month for 4 x 30 min and you pay even during holidays. It calculates roughly to 46 €/h based on 37 lessons of 30 min over the year. It would probably be 60 to 80 € per hour without subsidy. A tech will take between 70 - 80 €/h if you hand in your sax for a service.

Actually I would have expected higher rates especially in the London area. London is known to be one of the most expensive cities in Europe. Consider your teacher wants to make a living from his teaching. You are paying for his time not for your personal level of competence. The music schools I know all offer group lesson of 2 - 4 students at the beginner level. That saves some money.

Alphorn
 
Lessons in major metro areas are usually much more expensive than other areas. None of my business but OP might want to look around at what his job is paying other people in that area.

It is quite easy to access cheaper lessons online, either one-on-one by video, or the many pre-recorded lessons series packages with various types of forum or other support for questions.
 
It may not be a consolation but from the perspective where I live, greater Munich area, your prices are kind of cheap.
Iam taking lessons in a music school where the wages of the teachers are subsidized. It is still 75 € per month for 4 x 30 min and you pay even during holidays. It calculates roughly to 46 €/h based on 37 lessons of 30 min over the year. It would probably be 60 to 80 € per hour without subsidy. A tech will take between 70 - 80 €/h if you hand in your sax for a service.

Actually I would have expected higher rates especially in the London area. London is know to be one of the most expensive cities in Europe. Consider your teach wants to make a living from his teaching. You are paying for his time not for your personal level of competence

Alphorn
Hi @Alphorn I really didn't want to start a debate on the value of a teacher that's a given, and I would hate it if anyone on here who teaches is insulted by the post...I am not saying that at a point lessons are not value for money but sometimes what you need is a workshop or night class to get over the hurdles...I.e. I was gladly paying £35 per month but ten lessons on I was still going playing whilst the teacher counted the rhythm... I do realise that I have some responsibility in my own learning but need 2 lessons a week for 3 months to get that intensity...As colin said it can be an expensive hobby but that is all it will ever be...I understand what you say about someone who want's to make a living at teaching and paying for time...The issue is that if a majority of the country can't afford his time what happens??? we have a pub chain in England called Wetherspoons their beer is half the price of anywhere else and the pubs are always full whilst the ones charging twice as much aren't...Again I apologise and don't mean that lessons aren't VFM but there are no alternative options available....
 
Lessons in major metro areas are usually much more expensive than other areas. None of my business but OP might want to look around at what his job is paying other people in that area.

It is quite easy to access cheaper lessons online, either one-on-one by video, or the many pre-recorded lessons series packages with various types of forum or other support for questions.
Hi @Yansalis I live in middlesex technically....pre recorded and on-line lessons not suitable for where I am at..I hope I haven't offended anyone never meant to...In the current climate there are a LTD few roles that pay £40 per hour or an annual salary of £73000, most earn £10 per hour a yearly salary of £18,200 based on a 35 hour week...I do ok on 35k but there is defo not enough left after bills for an intense period of lessons...This is no-ones fault I have chosen my life style and path...I was merely saying with LTD alternative options re learning most of the population can't afford it...I find this sad...
 
@eb424 Most of us are coming from the perspective, or the hope at least that problems like this can be solved--somehow.

Maybe there are less expensive areas within driving distance, or maybe you might pay for intense lessons for a time by getting a 2nd job. As I've demonstrated, I don't know enough about your situation to make good targeted suggestions. All we can do is fling random ideas at you and hope one of them is both new and relevant. 🙂
 
i don't understand the question sorry....

What I am trying to bring to your attention is to consider the actual worth of the lessons. If you spend some money now to overcome whatever obstacles you are encountering, then you are that much more able to enjoy playing the horn without frustration. Look just at the time spent - yours and responders - asking questions, and trying to pick through the responses to see what works for you. Working with a good teacher will get you past those issues and on to actually playing and enjoying the sax. So my question/observation comes down to - especially for the adult learner - getting to the point where you know enough to proceed on your own and make good progress.

Five more years of fumbling or 10 lessons - which do you prefer? If fumbling meets your needs, at least it's an informed choice.
 
Hi @Yansalis I live in middlesex technically....pre recorded and on-line lessons not suitable for where I am at..I hope I haven't offended anyone never meant to...In the current climate there are a LTD few roles that pay £40 per hour or an annual salary of £73000, most earn £10 per hour a yearly salary of £18,200 based on a 35 hour week...I do ok on 35k but there is defo not enough left after bills for an intense period of lessons...This is no-ones fault I have chosen my life style and path...I was merely saying with LTD alternative options re learning most of the population can't afford it...I find this sad...
I doubt that any music teacher earns £73000 a year, they’re not doing it for 40 hours a week, if they are you probably don’t want to go to them. It’s expensive because you are, in theory, getting good quality professional assistance. Most of the work has to be done on your time and they should be setting goals that are testing and achievable.

I really can’t see the need for weekly sessions as it isn’t enough time for you to do the work and absorb what you’ve done. Even 2 weeks seems a bit short but I think it’s not unusual. To me a good teacher will give you something challenging, according to your needs and level, and say come back when you’ve done it and you’re ready to move on. Again I think it’s common for teachers to want to set up a regular visit and to me this is just because they are trying to set up a regular income.

I agree that £40 is a lot and if you are spending that every week it will soon become unaffordable but once a month it seems reasonable but only if you are getting the direction you need and feeling the benefit, I just don’t think that’s possible in weekly lessons when you have earn a living, great if you’re a kid bad news when your time is limited.
 
One of my favorite repair stories is the player who took his sax into the repair shop because it wasn't playing right. He handed it to the old tech who looked it over for a few seconds and then picked up a large rubber mallet and gave it a wack. He then handed it back to the player to test how it played. The player played the sax and was overjoyed because it played perfect again. He asked the tech, "what is the charge"? The tech replied "fifty dollars and twenty five cents." The customer said, "but it took just a few seconds to fix, why is it so much?" The old tech replied, "it was twenty five cents to hit the sax with the mallet, and fifty dollars for knowing where to hit it, and how hard."

The point in this thread is that the student is not playing the teacher for 30 or 45 minutes of his time. The student is paying for the lessons and classes the teacher has taken over the years, the hours and hours of practice, and the years of teaching and playing experience. That said, a beginning player who is still learning to read music and the notes and fingerings certainly doesn't need a "master teacher" at that stage of progress. It is after most of the fundamentals have been mastered that the "master teacher" can take the student to the next level and beyond.
 
What I am trying to bring to your attention is to consider the actual worth of the lessons. If you spend some money now to overcome whatever obstacles you are encountering, then you are that much more able to enjoy playing the horn without frustration. Look just at the time spent - yours and responders - asking questions, and trying to pick through the responses to see what works for you. Working with a good teacher will get you past those issues and on to actually playing and enjoying the sax. So my question/observation comes down to - especially for the adult learner - getting to the point where you know enough to proceed on your own and make good progress.

Five more years of fumbling or 10 lessons - which do you prefer? If fumbling meets your needs, at least it's an informed choice.
Trouble is i have aready had 20 lessons..issue is having them monthly is not enough i just go round in circles counting and clapping. .i need 2 a week for a few months for them to have value ..who can afford a oner a week for 3 months... I completely agree lessons are a valuable commodity playing wise...just out of reach financially for most people...
 
Last edited:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,702
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom