Playing the saxophone Why so expensive

Trouble is i have aready had 20 lessons..issue is having them monthly is not enough i need 2 a week for a few months ..who can afford a oner a week for 3 months...
At least half the value of lessons is what you do between lessons: practice. If you have two a week, you won't have much time to practice in between.
 
I doubt that any music teacher earns £73000 a year, they’re not doing it for 40 hours a week, if they are you probably don’t want to go to them. It’s expensive because you are, in theory, getting good quality professional assistance. Most of the work has to be done on your time and they should be setting goals that are testing and achievable.

I really can’t see the need for weekly sessions as it isn’t enough time for you to do the work and absorb what you’ve done. Even 2 weeks seems a bit short but I think it’s not unusual. To me a good teacher will give you something challenging, according to your needs and level, and say come back when you’ve done it and you’re ready to move on. Again I think it’s common for teachers to want to set up a regular visit and to me this is just because they are trying to set up a regular income.

I agree that £40 is a lot and if you are spending that every week it will soon become unaffordable but once a month it seems reasonable but only if you are getting the direction you need and feeling the benefit, I just don’t think that’s possible in weekly lessons when you have earn a living, great if you’re a kid bad news when your time is limited.
Hi thanks @Jimmymack ... At the mo its just rhythm and note recognition I think thats why I thought 1 or 2 a week it keeps me focused . ..id gladly pay £40 a month after this but i need the intensity and focus...
 
At least half the value of lessons is what you do between lessons: practice. If you have two a week, you won't have much time to practice in between.
Lol but i can just play..Lessons would be most of my practice and at least with a teacher there id no id be getting my timing right...its easy with backing track but defeats the object as id like to join a group...
 
One of my favorite repair stories is the player who took his sax into the repair shop because it wasn't playing right. He handed it to the old tech who looked it over for a few seconds and then picked up a large rubber mallet and gave it a wack. He then handed it back to the player to test how it played. The player played the sax and was overjoyed because it played perfect again. He asked the tech, "what is the charge"? The tech replied "fifty dollars and twenty five cents." The customer said, "but it took just a few seconds to fix, why is it so much?" The old tech replied, "it was twenty five cents to hit the sax with the mallet, and fifty dollars for knowing where to hit it, and how hard."

The point in this thread is that the student is not playing the teacher for 30 or 45 minutes of his time. The student is paying for the lessons and classes the teacher has taken over the years, the hours and hours of practice, and the years of teaching and playing experience. That said, a beginning player who is still learning to read music and the notes and fingerings certainly doesn't need a "master teacher" at that stage of progress. It is after most of the fundamentals have been mastered that the "master teacher" can take the student to the next level and beyond.
Thanks @jbtsax think youve hit the nail on the head or the sax on the bell...my fingering and time keeping to backing tracks is ok....new direction and goals re playing from scores...I do the note recognition stuff at home but need guidance on rhythm...Once over this bit I will have monthly lessons...just think that rhythm and timing is important to focus on....
 
Lol but i can just play..Lessons would be most of my practice and at least with a teacher there id no id be getting my timing right...its easy with backing track but defeats the object as id like to join a group...
OK, I've been following this thread. Let's if I understand your plan. If you could find a teacher who could give you two affordable lessons a week, those lessons would be the bulk of your practice time each week. In between, you would just play. The teacher will provide intensity and focus, and be responsible for your timing to be correct. Is that about it?
 
OK, I've been following this thread. Let's if I understand your plan. If you could find a teacher who could give you two affordable lessons a week, those lessons would be the bulk of your practice time each week. In between, you would just play. The teacher will provide intensity and focus, and be responsible for your timing to be correct. Is that about it?
No not really...i can carry on the work. I usually practice in the caravanv for a few hours on a Sat and Sunvand rent the church hall for 3 hours on a Thursday where i play to backing tracks. Id have to do a bit 2 hours a week is not enough..id have to provide the focus and be responsible for my playing. Think it may give me a bit more structure tho..
 
Thanks @jbtsax think youve hit the nail on the head or the sax on the bell...my fingering and time keeping to backing tracks is ok....new direction and goals re playing from scores...I do the note recognition stuff at home but need guidance on rhythm...Once over this bit I will have monthly lessons...just think that rhythm and timing is important to focus on....
You might be interested in the Jazz Conception for Saxophone books by Lennie Niehaus. They now come with an accompaniment CD so you can play along with a professional player, or play along with just the backing tracks. They are a great resource to learn to read jazz rhythms and learn jazz articulations and style.
 
I was going to stay quiet, but... I have four music teachers, they are all music conservatoire graduates, three with a masters degree in performance as well. I have fortnightly lessons with all of them. I live in rural Shropshire. The bass and cello teachers come to me, I go to the singing and sax teachers. Bass is the odd one out as it’s tied in with the local branch of Rock School, which is a franchise with the examining body and in the non lesson weeks I go to the jam session.

The other lessons are £32, £35, and £40 p/h. The cello teacher teaches part time at a school, and performs professionally. He doesn’t have many private pupils. The singing teacher is a professional opera singer and again teaching is an extra income stream. The sax teacher is a full time private teacher, and is the most expensive of the three. They teach piano, flute, clarinet, sax, and theory.
 
Why saxophone? Why music? Saxophone isn't for everyone. It doesn't matter how pretty it is. Instruments pick the player imo. After five years it's telling you to try something else. You seem to like Country. How about a jug?
I know what I don't like andnever know @Colin the Bear whether your joking...So I will give you the benefit of the doubt and not write the reply that I was going to 😉.....Hmm positive thoughts changing behaviour how very novel.... 🙂
 
There are a few apps that might bei helpful. I use Anytune for practice on my Ipad. It allows to slow down your backing tracks. The free version is ok the pro version will cost you 15 €(?) but sounds decent even at 50 % of original bpm. Equivalent on microsoft devices would be the amazing slow downer.

If it comes to rhythm Read Rythm might be really the right app for your problem. Trains your precision on rhythm starting simple but can be set to increasingly difficult patterns. You can vary the bpm to your liking and it will analyze your precision giving your deviation from perfect timing. It is 4 € but worth it. No idea if there is an alternative on windows devices.

A tuner that I recently switched to is Tonal Energy. The graphic presentation of your tuning as a red or green spot with a smiling or disapointed face is fun and to me much more recognicable than a needle that flips around. I use it from time to time to check my tuning during long tones or sometimes when playing a slow track. I know, the standard advice is use your ears but your ears may deceive you.

I did not mean to offend you in my previous post. Just wanted to say some things come at a cost and there is a reason for it.

Alphorn
 
I was going to stay quiet, but... I have four music teachers, they are all music conservatoire graduates, three with a masters degree in performance as well. I have fortnightly lessons with all of them. I live in rural Shropshire. The bass and cello teachers come to me, I go to the singing and sax teachers. Bass is the odd one out as it’s tied in with the local branch of Rock School, which is a franchise with the examining body and in the non lesson weeks I go to the jam session.

The other lessons are £32, £35, and £40 p/h. The cello teacher teaches part time at a school, and performs professionally. He doesn’t have many private pupils. The singing teacher is a professional opera singer and again teaching is an extra income stream. The sax teacher is a full time private teacher, and is the most expensive of the three. They teach piano, flute, clarinet, sax, and theory.
I'm glad you didn't stay quiet @Tenor Viol ...Why should you?...My understanding of the cafe (which may well of course be wrong) is that it is a place that you can talk about things relating to a saxophone...Of course I don't have to lay myself Bear (very much pun intended @colin) but choose to as it is a topic of interest for me...I always assume those with nothing to say or who are fed up with my posts need not participate so I am glad that you replied...The issue intended in my thread was never the value of lessons again that is a given; I have never meant to question their value..we all need guidance (particularly me with my talking saxophone telling me to give up... 😉 )....I understand that it may be a topic that could be provocative but to some degree I had to ask the question...@Colinthebear its not about my playing, I am quite happy with that side of things thank you, I was merely questioning whether the cost of lessons puts learning out of reach for a majority of the population....Value is a funny thing we all need to make life work, there are 1000s of items on e bay whose value is greater than their selling price, if there is no flexibility they don't sell.....I realise that to get a music degree and to go on to be a professional musician is very expensive and I can appreciate that there has to be some reward.....I was merely saying that perhaps the perceived opinion of lack of new people playing the sax is based on the expense....A majority of the population earn £10 per hour who can afford to work 4 hours to have a lesson...The whole structure seems very class orientated.....the second point was that I have had sparodic lessons I would say 25 with 3 different teachers....I realise that rhythm and note recognition is essential to theory but how long does it take to move on??? From this I realise that monthly lessons aren't enough for now but can't afford to go xs 2 weekly to get over this hurdle...I will continue to learn and play my own way which I am happy with but wanted more...it just seems that more is priced out of reach......
 
Most music teachers are very concerned that music is moving out of the reach of many. This has been caused by the loss of local education authority music teaching. When I was younger, everyone at my school had the chance to learn an instrument. The school provided peripatetic music teachers to get people started. If they showed promise, the local authority then provided out-of-hours tuition on top of that. I started cello at 12 with a peri at school. Unfortunately, my parents didn't know how the system worked and I missed out on the extra teaching, which is why there was a 35+ year gap in me playing cello.

Unfortunately, the bean counters that know the price of everything and the value of nothing now control governments/councils and they see 'no value' in the arts and everything is focused on a narrow curriculum and arts have been almost entirely eliminated from schools. There are a few more enlightened places, but they are few in number.

One reasons why music lessons are relatively expensive is the loss of all the teaching posts - both full-time and peri.
 
There is a difference IMHO between "guided practicing" and lessons I personally would take.
I pay about 80 Dollars for a lesson with Greg Fishman, and I'm having a lesson every 5 weeks or so.
Practicing about 3 hours (for the stuff I do with Greg) a day, and I can hardly keep up.

What I want to say (and I'm telling this my students too): The most important teacher you will ever have is you.
Somebody else can also give you input, but you have to process and digest it.
A higher number of lessons will not change anything.

I'm not an advocate of practice plans, but in your case maybe it would be useful to work on this with your teacher.
A good teacher will not feed you with tons of information (provided he has it) in one lesson - you will probably not be able to keep track - and relies on your focused practice. Lessons are for keeping you on track and add some info every time.

In my (online) teaching I differentiate between students having a lesson only once every two months or so, or students having lessons every week.
Did you ask your teacher about a discount for having lessons frequently?

Greetings, Guenne
 
There are a few apps that might bei helpful. I use Anytune for practice on my Ipad. It allows to slow down your backing tracks. The free version is ok the pro version will cost you 15 €(?) but sounds decent even at 50 % of original bpm. Equivalent on microsoft devices would be the amazing slow downer.

If it comes to rhythm Read Rythm might be really the right app for your problem. Trains your precision on rhythm starting simple but can be set to increasingly difficult patterns. You can vary the bpm to your liking and it will analyze your precision giving your deviation from perfect timing. It is 4 € but worth it. No idea if there is an alternative on windows devices.

A tuner that I recently switched to is Tonal Energy. The graphic presentation of your tuning as a red or green spot with a smiling or disapointed face is fun and to me much more recognicable than a needle that flips around. I use it from time to time to check my tuning during long tones or sometimes when playing a slow track. I know, the standard advice is use your ears but your ears may deceive you.

I did not mean to offend you in my previous post. Just wanted to say some things come at a cost and there is a reason for it.

Alphorn
Hey @Alphorn no offense taken...🙂...I probably knew it was a contenscious topic but I honestly feel that for where I am at theory wise lessons do not offer value for money...After 5 years playing I am happy with where I am at...I can play complex tunes to a backing track and read and understand some theory....as usual I have done everything bum about face and my playing is a lot better than my reading which I haven't needed to improve on to date...I can (i know) transcribe and play to backing tracks but want more and would like to play with others...Generally a non-conformist, I know 3 people who play sax and don't play from scores we get together to Jam but not often enough...So the non conformist has to conform..I never meant to question the value of lessons this is a change of direction for me so as I can join a group...again I am happy with the playing side for the time I have been playing but £40 an hour for someone to count whilst I play doesn't seem to represent value for money...once I am over this hurdle and move onto more complex issues and can resume one lesson a month I have no issues at all paying. its all part of progression...
 
Most music teachers are very concerned that music is moving out of the reach of many. This has been caused by the loss of local education authority music teaching. When I was younger, everyone at my school had the chance to learn an instrument. The school provided peripatetic music teachers to get people started. If they showed promise, the local authority then provided out-of-hours tuition on top of that. I started cello at 12 with a peri at school. Unfortunately, my parents didn't know how the system worked and I missed out on the extra teaching, which is why there was a 35+ year gap in me playing cello.

Unfortunately, the bean counters that know the price of everything and the value of nothing now control governments/councils and they see 'no value' in the arts and everything is focused on a narrow curriculum and arts have been almost entirely eliminated from schools. There are a few more enlightened places, but they are few in number.

One reasons why music lessons are relatively expensive is the loss of all the teaching posts - both full-time and peri.
cool thanks @Tenor Viol but there is a whole generation of older learners that the cost of lessons excludes...If I need work or if I feel that the person who needs the work doing can't afford it I will be flexible with the cost of my time, its only time....That customer isn't solely responsible for the costs of my training, fuel, tools, only the here and now and my time....a majority of those people will always come back so it's kind of a less is more situation......the whole area of music seems to be pricing itself out of interest, most of the population on min wage may enjoy lessons but they are out of reach, at 4 xs the amount...That's a lot of missed interest...
 
There is a difference IMHO between "guided practicing" and lessons I personally would take.
I pay about 80 Dollars for a lesson with Greg Fishman, and I'm having a lesson every 5 weeks or so.
Practicing about 3 hours (for the stuff I do with Greg) a day, and I can hardly keep up.

What I want to say (and I'm telling this my students too): The most important teacher you will ever have is you.
Somebody else can also give you input, but you have to process and digest it.
A higher number of lessons will not change anything.

I'm not an advocate of practice plans, but in your case maybe it would be useful to work on this with your teacher.
A good teacher will not feed you with tons of information (provided he has it) in one lesson - you will probably not be able to keep track - and relies on your focused practice. Lessons are for keeping you on track and add some info every time.

In my (online) teaching I differentiate between students having a lesson only once every two months or so, or students having lessons every week.
Did you ask your teacher about a discount for having lessons frequently?

Greetings, Guenne
Thanks @Guenne....I try to put in as much as I can...The issue for me is just getting over the counting and rhythm bit very basic... I need intensity and feedback for this part...Ihave discussed it briefly and will/ have to find a way through...
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,702
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom