Playing the saxophone Why so expensive

in your opinion is it worth 2 lessons a week just focusing on note durations, recognition, beat and rhythm.
You don't need to have 2 lessons a week for this, but you do need to put plenty of time in at home which is free.
Start with simple pieces but read it without putting the letter above so that your brain gets used to this as a way of learning, learn some basic theory of what the value of the dots mean and away you go.
Don't expect miracles to start with but the more you do it this way the easier it becomes.
Maybe a lesson a week or once every 2 weeks might suffice but it's still down to you to put the work in.
 
Hi thanks @Jimmymack...trouble is playing from the dots to get into a group..in your opinion is it worth 2 lessons a week just focusing on note durations, recognition, beat and rhythm.
Jazzdoh is spot on here, it takes time just doing it. I don’t think that you will get much, if any, benefit from going to a teacher that regularly just to check your progress, what you need to do is just do it, with a metronome, over and over again.

You will improve by small increments by doing it every day but expecting to see an obvious improvement in two weeks is possible, maybe, but one week is unrealistic and it’s not the way it seems to work, you’re getting better without realising it until one day you notice that you’ve improved, then you just carry on and keep doing it. In my experience you can slog away at something for a couple of months and it will suddenly click, and these things happen at their own rate and not in a regular fashion.

You don’t need someone checking your progress as you can check it yourself, the metronome is a hard master/mistress, but it’s your friend. Trust your own judgement.
 
@eb424 As I wrote some days ago you need a "teacher/mentor/instructor … that can help you with playing the saxophone. You are a person with lots of questions and that is very good. A silent “student” is not a good thing. And you have not only questions about dots and theory … you also have questions about music, saxes and other equipment.To wait for a whole month to get answers to questions ……. .

I didn’t have a saxophone teacher to help me with my playing or other questions. I wish I had a teacher/mentor/instructor that I could see often. But there were no teachers that were into my kind of music. Back in the late 70’s and 80’s I just had two players/instructors that I could ask. Later I expanded the contacts.

I’m not saying it’s wrong to have a lesson for a saxophone teacher once a month if that is what you want. But “keep the door” open for other options to do in between:

  • Lessons via internet. You need good equipment (camera and microphone, computer + software, good internet connection, good speakers and a room with ok acoustic).
  • Start a Rock Sax group. Some Rock Sax players that you can meet and trade ideas with. Learn from each other. Small rhythm section or backing tracks? It’s a matter of space and money. But you can do a lot with backing tracks.
  • Go to rock or blues jams. Listen and talk. Later you can start playing. With the right guy beside you, I’m 100 % sure you already can play easy songs on your sax like “Last night”, “Hi-Heel Sneakers”, “No Particular Place To Go” … You don’t have to play solo. Just to be a part of playing songs you like is important. Go home with a smile on your face and count down the days to the next jam !!!!
 
@eb424 As I wrote some days ago you need a "teacher/mentor/instructor … that can help you with playing the saxophone. You are a person with lots of questions and that is very good. A silent “student” is not a good thing. And you have not only questions about dots and theory … you also have questions about music, saxes and other equipment.To wait for a whole month to get answers to questions ……. .

I didn’t have a saxophone teacher to help me with my playing or other questions. I wish I had a teacher/mentor/instructor that I could see often. But there were no teachers that were into my kind of music. Back in the late 70’s and 80’s I just had two players/instructors that I could ask. Later I expanded the contacts.

I’m not saying it’s wrong to have a lesson for a saxophone teacher once a month if that is what you want. But “keep the door” open for other options to do in between:

  • Lessons via internet. You need good equipment (camera and microphone, computer + software, good internet connection, good speakers and a room with ok acoustic).
  • Start a Rock Sax group. Some Rock Sax players that you can meet and trade ideas with. Learn from each other. Small rhythm section or backing tracks? It’s a matter of space and money. But you can do a lot with backing tracks.
  • Go to rock or blues jams. Listen and talk. Later you can start playing. With the right guy beside you, I’m 100 % sure you already can play easy songs on your sax like “Last night”, “Hi-Heel Sneakers”, “No Particular Place To Go” … You don’t have to play solo. Just to be a part of playing songs you like is important. Go home with a smile on your face and count down the days to the next jam !!!!
Hi @thomsax...room unfortunately is the issue I play in my caravan or hire the church hall...I do have a few people that I play with but neither read tho I would say one is a pro player so he kicks my butt...We only get together once a month it's not enough..I have 2 teachers one's very young and is quite money orientated but she is good and TBF she is the only teacher I have had whose had a pint and ciggie before a lesson...and not in her time...I need to read the dots so I can join sax bandits which at least will get me playing with others once or twice a month...I would love to start something over the hall or get together with others, or even attend one of your days got toput the effort in...I'm waiting for everyone on here to arrange a get together for a day......it's fun but difficult, but like you even without a teacher if your determined enough you'll get there....Think people get a bit fed up with my questions tho, think they would all chip in to get me a teacher and get me off here...Lol.. 😉
 
Last edited:
I haven't read every post on this thread so these points may have been covered already, but....... the cost of lessons is usually tied to the MU rate for teaching. For instance, about 15 years ago I was paying £19 for 45 minute 'cello lessons for my daughter up here in Cumbria. I don't know what the MU rate is now, but I would guess somewhere around £35 - £40p.hr. Doubtless even more in London. The other thing I'm getting from above comments is the idea that saxophone lessons are distinct from basic music lessons and should be charged at different rates - I agree. If you're being charged £40/£60 an hour just to learn basic note values and reading, then I would buy a book! Although I've never had a sax lesson in my life, I would expect that it would involve being taught to play the machine my someone who already could, rather than take me through school music lessons again!
 
"Think people get a bit fed up with my questions tho" Don't hesitate, feel free to send me a question. I have lots of Rock Sax material and if I don't have the answers I'll ask a person that's more clever than me.

"Last Night" is just 3 tones( A, E, D) for Bb horns. You don't have to be a killer reader to read it. 😉
ln.jpg
 
.
Think people get a bit fed up with my questions tho
I don't think so. Anyway, everyone is free not to open threads they are fed-up with.

I do think it can be frustrating (and fascinating) when folks give perfectly reasonable or standard answers and five pages of equally good replies and perspectives, it's still not over.

IMHO That is no reason not to ask whatever question you need. But it is a reason for you to put in sturdy work on the basics; with or without a teacher.
 
I haven't read every post on this thread so these points may have been covered already, but....... the cost of lessons is usually tied to the MU rate for teaching. For instance, about 15 years ago I was paying £19 for 45 minute 'cello lessons for my daughter up here in Cumbria. I don't know what the MU rate is now, but I would guess somewhere around £35 - £40p.hr. Doubtless even more in London. The other thing I'm getting from above comments is the idea that saxophone lessons are distinct from basic music lessons and should be charged at different rates - I agree. If you're being charged £40/£60 an hour just to learn basic note values and reading, then I would buy a book! Although I've never had a sax lesson in my life, I would expect that it would involve being taught to play the machine my someone who already could, rather than take me through school music lessons again!
It's just for this period of note recognition and duration....Ive been focusing on playing for 5 years time to get to the basics....books ok but remembered today it's quite difficult looking at a score trying to recognise a note then work out the dration and rhythm whilst tapping your feet...lol
 
"Think people get a bit fed up with my questions tho" Don't hesitate, feel free to send me a question. I have lots of Rock Sax material and if I don't have the answers I'll ask a person that's more clever than me.

"Last Night" is just 3 tones( A, E, D) for Bb horns. You don't have to be a killer reader to read it. 😉
View attachment 20065
what do you do on the low A, take it all up........? more questions.....pmsl.. Also if you want any of mine let me know... 😉 currently working on you never can tell chuck berry.....
 
Last edited:
.

I don't think so. Anyway, everyone is free not to open threads they are fed-up with.

I do think it can be frustrating (and fascinating) when folks give perfectly reasonable or standard answers and five pages of equally good replies and perspectives, it's still not over.

IMHO That is no reason not to ask whatever question you need. But it is a reason for you to put in sturdy work on the basics; with or without a teacher.
Hi @mizmar think the issue is that things move on we seemed to go from whether music lessons are value for money then it moves on to reading....As BT say it's good to talk....really think a big meet up sax day would be good......It would be nice to put faces to people.....
 
Hi @mizmar As BT say it's good to talk....really think a big meet up sax day would be good......It would be nice to put faces to people.....
I'm getting to the point where I have the time and energy to arrange another café meet @aldevis @Pete Thomas what do you think. Shall I start thread 🙂

Jx
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,701
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom