Some seem to think that it's OK to teach someone how to become a musician today by teaching in a mode that audiences do not care to listen to. Do you think that kids today should be taught using a slide rule and only communicate by letter or telegram? Hey that's what Einstein, Teller, Oppenheimer, Crick, Fermi, and all the great 20th century scientists/physicists used and look what they accomplished! No, if you are a student today you need to use the tools that are available today because they work better, faster, and give you the opportunity to dialogue with other professionals and the world at large. The great players of the 1950s STOPPED playing in the style of big bands. They moved on. There is no single period in which music gets stuck or should get stuck, only the teachers it seems get stuck and wind up educating their students to become more teachers, who do the same and cripple the next generation. It's time to stop wasting all of that potential talent on trying to perpetuate a period of music that audiences do not want to hear.
Any of us can listen to and play whatever we want. This is about a mindset that somehow thinks jazz should be frozen in the 1950s and that audiences care to hear "standards" re-done a zillion times over. When the players in the 1950s used these tunes they were common popular tunes that everyone knew. They didn't play Stephen Foster tunes, Dixieland, or even Ragtime. Three generations have passed since then. That's two generations beyond anyone who actually heard these as popular music that a "jazz rendition" was a variation on. Who today, that's not a mainstream jazz head, could go through a real (or fake) book and recognize any of these? Let the 1950s go in terms of teaching and pushing novices to lock themselves into a dead end. If one thinks that the "formulae" should be perpetuated, then at least do your renditions on popular music of today so that it has relevance. That's what those guys did. Everybody knew the tunes, so they could see how and where the music was clever and what the "treatment" was about. Mainstream has locked itself out crying that "nobody understands me, or wants to listen to how great I am". If you are speaking an arcane language using metaphors that have no relevance, then you are not trying to communicate. Budding musicians need to communicate to audiences today if they are to be successful. A 1950s style Jazz education not only does not prepare them for this, it can cripple them as they need to retrain and reinvent themselves if they are going to make it as a pro.