Miscellaneous Why Jazz isn't cool anymore??

I therefore move that we abolish the record shop terms and just play 'music' in future...
;}

Nick

Sounds like a plan to me!

In the meantime I'm really enjoying my new drum DVD on Funk grooves. I don't care what we call the music I make with these grooves. All I know is that they are really cool to play.
 
For my tuppence worth I always remind students that there are two kinds of music; good and bad.
Make sure you're playing and listening to the good sort!

I'm with you so far...

I don't really differentiate between Beethoven and Brubeck, or Mahler and GaGa - it's all using Western-type twelve chromatic notes and scales we're all familiar with to make interesting harmonic noise. 'Music' - a big descriptive term like Martin said.
But I do think the category labels have their uses as long as they're not used too rigidly or exclusively.

Some pieces I like, some I don't, but that doesn't define 'good' or 'bad' either, it's just my taste. Postmodern New Orleans or not, Payton generally plays good music and don't really mind what he chooses to call it.
I don't really mind either, but if I was offered a choice between going to a jazz gig and a post-modern-New-Orleans-music gig, I'd almost certainly choose the former. as it sounds like a lot more fun. And the older I get, the more important the element of fun in music or any other form of art/entertainment becomes. I've had quite enough things in real life to be heavily serious or depressed about.

I kind of do mind, though, when he starts trying to tell me that nobody else (eg me) can do aything worthwhile in jazz either, because he's declared it dead. Playing jazz is what I've spent a large part of the last 18 months learning to do and I intend to continue doing so, because it gives me a great deal of satisfaction. I don't expect I'll ever reach Mr Payton's level of skill, knowledge or professional success, but it means a lot to me.

I agree that we as musicians get typecast and channelled into pigeonholes to suit the marketing of the record industry/media etc., and I'm not particularly happy with that but I'm also not talented enough to change it. Neither is Payton, it seems, which is a shame. Perhaps he's frustrated because of this.

'Jazz', like 'Classical', is a broad descriptive word that sounds narrow if you have little musical education and find the music you think the term suggests inaccessible for whatever reason. There is some 'jazz' that everyone will like, in the same way that most people won't go out of their way to buy 'classical' music but often quite like it when they hear it at the football, on TV, in films etc. 'Pop' however seems to me to contain most of the ingredients of 'jazz' but without the crazy spontaneity which turns off listeners who can't see the merit in it. It is indeed a fusion of all the things Tom suggested, because musicians feed off each other in terms of inspiration.

I therefore move that we abolish the record shop terms and just play 'music' in future...
;}
I think it's reasonable to give your audience some idea of what to expect when you ask them to part with their cash for a CD or drag themselves out of the house on a cold winter's evening. "An evening of music" isn't going to sell a lot of tickets, and with good reason.
 
I've got a lot of sympathy for Payton's point of view. Maybe that's because I grew up in the USA and lived through that era and clearly remember the excitement of 1950s jazz being something new and of its time and very much a departure from big band music (although it grew out of it). I don't want or need Payton's terms/definitions, but understand where he is coming from.

I've never lived in the UK so have no idea how you commonly classify music or what constitutes jazz when someone there uses this term. In the USA, Australia and New Zealand (where I'm familiar with what's happening), jazz has been somewhat codified for the purpose of teaching and relies very heavily on what was happening in the 1950s as its basis. This has led to a lot of budding musicians taking in this training and finding that it leads nowhere. 1950s jazz is just as dead today as big band music was in the 1960 and beyond. There are a few aficionados and people who want/like to play big band and Dixieland, but the audiences are miniscule. The audience for 1950s jazz is slightly bigger, but it's fairly incestuous with most being players of the same style and not much of the audience being Joe/Josephine public.

I hear a lot of anger in many of these replies but think it's misplaced. Jazz as a term can be whatever you want it to be and I think some would consider any improvised based music to be jazz. Payton clearly says that's not part of the equation, he’s specifically addressing 1950s style jazz. That style would have (should have?) died, except it is being kept artificially alive by pedagogs who like the idea of music being a codified type of learning. I've often heard this rationalized as a sound basis for learning about music. Maybe so, but probably any discipline, like classical can claim the same. Most students become what they are trained to do, especially if this involves an enormous amount of physical and mental discipline. In any of the arts, sport, or sciences it would be very difficult to suddenly switch to a completely different way of thinking, playing acting etc.

I agree with Tom Mapfumo's list. These are improvising artists of today. Most of the music that I've heard that's moving forward is coming from Northern Europe where it seems the 1950s influence isn't all pervasive. Jan Garbarek can pack out any house anywhere. What mainstream 1950s style jazz player playing 60 to 80 year-old “standards” today can claim the same?

Each of us can play and love whatever we want. The problem arises where elite dictate an orthodoxy of what is an acceptable standard for being educated as an improvising musician. That standard is firmly and unjustifiably entrenched in the 1950s. If all students were aware of all the possibilities, it could be different. They are not.

Payton is rough, but wrote his article to provoke. I guess it worked. He has a valid point in my mind, but if you can't hear the difference between New Orleans style music and 1950's jazz, then it's like someone who doesn't know or understand Classical music not being able to hear or understand the difference between the Classical period and Romantic. It's all orchestral, so what's the difference? Yes, there's a big difference if you are educated to those sounds and ideas.

The 1950s is dead, RIP, let it go and move on.
 
I see Jazz as a river.

Up in the highlands, at the source, a number of springs merged, the waters combined, this fresh vibrant beck splashed and sparkled. As it flowed, so it changed its character, always drawing on the fresh contribution of the tributaries that flowed in, building strength, growing in grandeur. As it widens, it flows more slowly but becomes more majestic (think Ellington), more impressive. Sometimes there is a confluence with a powerful incoming stream, which revitalises it. And then further downstream it starts to meander a bit, losing its strong sense of direction. Finally it fragments into a delta, many streams flowing through rich fertile silt, ultimately losing its identity into the sea.

The explorers who made the journey down that river for the first time were privileged indeed. Imagine hearing "West End Blues" with fresh ears - an experience denied to us now who have heard so much that came after. But despite that, the river is still there for us. We can visit, hear the ragtime at the source, the swing and the bebop further downstream. We can even go exploring in those areas ourselves and expect to find some corners, some angles, some perspectives that others missed. But we can never BE those first explorers...

And don't forget what this river has given the world. What would modern music be like without Jazz?

Perhaps Payton is saying that the river is all mapped now, there is no place for explorers on the grand scale. But the river is not dead: it may not be the coolest place on the planet, but it is immensely beautiful, and for each of us personally, when we go to a new spot on that river, it is a personal exploration. Most of us won't get the fame, but we get something, possibly something different for each of us.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I love the analogy too. I would add that it has more than one source and many tributaries and it hasn't lost it's identity into the sea yet. I wonder also how many people these days do go back upstream to see where it came from. Alyn Shipton, in his perceptive New history of Jazz, has coined the phrase "looking forward from within the tradition". I think that is massively important.
 
For anyone that feels that "1950's Jazz" is dead and we should move on, I couldn't disagree more! The style may have morphed into funk, be-bop, etc... but that doesn't mean we should abandon it! Jazz is an improvisation based style of playing and as such, is extremely fluid. One of the hallmarks of jazz that defines it is the experimentation! In this regard, it is almost impossible to delineate a definite starting and ending point for the various styles. Why must any style of jazz go out of favor? I'm not saying it has or it hasn't!
The analogy of jazz as a river was very interesting but the theory that the river has been completely mapped doesn't really hold true (if that is indeed what Payton is implying) because improvisation comes from the human soul and that is an endless well that has only barely been tapped! A theory that I agree with holds that for new students, the best way to start is by learning from the masters and then making it your own. Does this "artificially" keep 1950's jazz alive? Perhaps, but it also sets the groundwork for later generations to create their own styles of jazz. To try and claim ownership of a particular style or to arbitrarily declare a style dead is (IMHO) the height of hubris! I don't give a d*mn how good you play! Your opinion is still just the opinion of one person! I'm sorry for Payton that he feels that way as he sounds rather bitter. Jazz dead? Quite the contrary! Rather, I would suggest that there has never been a music style more alive than jazz! It's constantly evolving and being relearned and reinvented. This is what distinguishes Jazz from Baroque, Classical, Romantic, etc... Western European styles with fixed rules. It is a living style of music! (Here endeth the sermon.)
 
Some seem to think that it's OK to teach someone how to become a musician today by teaching in a mode that audiences do not care to listen to. Do you think that kids today should be taught using a slide rule and only communicate by letter or telegram? Hey that's what Einstein, Teller, Oppenheimer, Crick, Fermi, and all the great 20th century scientists/physicists used and look what they accomplished! No, if you are a student today you need to use the tools that are available today because they work better, faster, and give you the opportunity to dialogue with other professionals and the world at large. The great players of the 1950s STOPPED playing in the style of big bands. They moved on. There is no single period in which music gets stuck or should get stuck, only the teachers it seems get stuck and wind up educating their students to become more teachers, who do the same and cripple the next generation. It's time to stop wasting all of that potential talent on trying to perpetuate a period of music that audiences do not want to hear.

Any of us can listen to and play whatever we want. This is about a mindset that somehow thinks jazz should be frozen in the 1950s and that audiences care to hear "standards" re-done a zillion times over. When the players in the 1950s used these tunes they were common popular tunes that everyone knew. They didn't play Stephen Foster tunes, Dixieland, or even Ragtime. Three generations have passed since then. That's two generations beyond anyone who actually heard these as popular music that a "jazz rendition" was a variation on. Who today, that's not a mainstream jazz head, could go through a real (or fake) book and recognize any of these? Let the 1950s go in terms of teaching and pushing novices to lock themselves into a dead end. If one thinks that the "formulae" should be perpetuated, then at least do your renditions on popular music of today so that it has relevance. That's what those guys did. Everybody knew the tunes, so they could see how and where the music was clever and what the "treatment" was about. Mainstream has locked itself out crying that "nobody understands me, or wants to listen to how great I am". If you are speaking an arcane language using metaphors that have no relevance, then you are not trying to communicate. Budding musicians need to communicate to audiences today if they are to be successful. A 1950s style Jazz education not only does not prepare them for this, it can cripple them as they need to retrain and reinvent themselves if they are going to make it as a pro.
 
My feeling is that it's not jazz that died around 1960, it's popular music. Todays jazz musicians tend to play old standards, rather than popular modern tunes, because the popular tunes are so vapid and devoid of any harmonic or even, in most cases, melodic interest. The sad truth, in my opinion, is that there's no mass audience for what saxnik referred to above as "good" music. Who knows if there ever will be again. It's all about packaging --- looking good wiggling your arse on the video. I'm afraid that was never going to be an option for me even if I wanted it. The only recent pop artist I can think of who had anything about her was Amy Winehouse. And she had a very backward-looking style.

I'm afraid I tend to upset a lot of people by saying this, but I think the rot set in about the time of Elvis Presley. Rock and roll had been quite a fun offshoot of blues-based music. It had probably just about run it's course when the marketing men got their hands on it and packaged it up to be more palatable to a wealthier (mostly white, but let's try not to get bogged down in that issue) teenage (and therefore easily led, however much they always like to think they're being rebellious) American audience. By the time the Beatles and the Beach Boys arrived, pop music was doomed. Punk was fun in a way, but there was no real music there. And in case you think I feel like this because of my age, I was born in 1958.

There. I feel a bit better now I've got that off my chest.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Some seem to think that it's OK to teach someone how to become a musician today by teaching in a mode that audiences do not care to listen to. Do you think that kids today should be taught using a slide rule and only communicate by letter or telegram? Hey that's what Einstein, Teller, Oppenheimer, Crick, Fermi, and all the great 20th century scientists/physicists used and look what they accomplished! No, if you are a student today you need to use the tools that are available today because they work better, faster, and give you the opportunity to dialogue with other professionals and the world at large. The great players of the 1950s STOPPED playing in the style of big bands. They moved on. There is no single period in which music gets stuck or should get stuck, only the teachers it seems get stuck and wind up educating their students to become more teachers, who do the same and cripple the next generation. It's time to stop wasting all of that potential talent on trying to perpetuate a period of music that audiences do not want to hear.

Any of us can listen to and play whatever we want. This is about a mindset that somehow thinks jazz should be frozen in the 1950s and that audiences care to hear "standards" re-done a zillion times over. When the players in the 1950s used these tunes they were common popular tunes that everyone knew. They didn't play Stephen Foster tunes, Dixieland, or even Ragtime. Three generations have passed since then. That's two generations beyond anyone who actually heard these as popular music that a "jazz rendition" was a variation on. Who today, that's not a mainstream jazz head, could go through a real (or fake) book and recognize any of these? Let the 1950s go in terms of teaching and pushing novices to lock themselves into a dead end. If one thinks that the "formulae" should be perpetuated, then at least do your renditions on popular music of today so that it has relevance. That's what those guys did. Everybody knew the tunes, so they could see how and where the music was clever and what the "treatment" was about. Mainstream has locked itself out crying that "nobody understands me, or wants to listen to how great I am". If you are speaking an arcane language using metaphors that have no relevance, then you are not trying to communicate. Budding musicians need to communicate to audiences today if they are to be successful. A 1950s style Jazz education not only does not prepare them for this, it can cripple them as they need to retrain and reinvent themselves if they are going to make it as a pro.

This. Absolutely.

Fortunately you don't have go across the channel to find jazz being played that isn't trad or bebop. Led Bib, Polar Bear, Portico Quartet, TrioVD are all Brits and there are many others. Not commanding big audiences, admittedly, but contemporary jazz rarely does. Jan Garbarek being the very welcome exception.

As for popular music dying, BigMartin, I think you need to get out more. Just listening to Radio 1 doesn't give you any idea of the vast range of popular music that's out there. Where does Porcupine Tree fit into your dismissal of popular music? Or Fleet Foxes, Joanna Newsome, Todd Rundgren, Roy Harper, The Beatles - there's loads out there. Have you listened to them all?

Concerning 'good' and 'bad' music - I'd be interested to see a definition. 'Bad' music is what my students manage to play, all too often. ;} 'Clever' music and 'not terribly clever' music are terms I could probably live with but 'good and 'bad' are just subjective opinions masquerading as absolute values.

I'll stick with my own definition. There is music I like and music I don't like. It crosses all genres and eras, I can't predict it or account for it and no one can can dispute it.

Finally, to elaborate on my original comment of 'not thought provoking', the chap is an American and probably has little idea about what goes on beyond the shores of the USA (see SOTW for many examples - I'm sure the USAnians who post here are excepted 🙂 ). It all sounded to me like a college student trying to be clever.
 
This. Absolutely.

Fortunately you don't have go across the channel to find jazz being played that isn't trad or bebop. Led Bib, Polar Bear, Portico Quartet, TrioVD are all Brits and there are many others. Not commanding big audiences, admittedly, but contemporary jazz rarely does. Jan Garbarek being the very welcome exception.

Well, that's kind of what I was saying. There's plenty going on, but it's not "popular", in the mass-audience sense. It's all niche stuff, which is OK by me, as long as it's out there to be found. I've tried to like Jan Garbarek, but he sends me to sleep.

As for popular music dying, BigMartin, I think you need to get out more. Just listening to Radio 1 doesn't give you any idea of the vast
range of popular music that's out there.
Depends what you mean by "popular". I mean stuff that everyone's heard of. Beyonce, Whitney bloody Houston, Lady Gaga, Madonna, or whoever it is that I'm forced to listen to these days when I go to the dentist. I can't even be bothered learning their names any more, there'e too much real music to listen to.

Where does Porcupine Tree fit into your dismissal of popular music?
Right into the "not that popular" category, for a start. Just heard a bit of their stuff on YouTube. Could have been Oasis for all I could tell. I just find that stuff really bland. Sorry.

Or Fleet Foxes, Joanna Newsome, Todd Rundgren, Roy Harper, The Beatles - there's loads out there. Have you listened to them all?
Have heard the last three and think they were really dull. Got dragged to two Harper gigs by my wife a long time ago. Boring songs, could play the guitar a bit, couldn't sing a note. We've agreed to differ on the subject. Don't understand why the Beatles are still worshiped. I suspect very little of what you hear on their albums was played by them. Their live recordings were dire.

Concerning 'good' and 'bad' music - I'd be interested to see a definition. 'Bad' music is what my students manage to play, all too often. ;} 'Clever' music and 'not terribly clever' music are terms I could probably live with but 'good and 'bad' are just subjective opinions masquerading as absolute values.

I'll stick with my own definition. There is music I like and music I don't like. It crosses all genres and eras, I can't predict it or account for it and no one can can dispute it.
Fair enough, but i think it's interesting to stir things up a bit, now and then. Perhaps I should say, "For me, popular music died around 1960."

Finally, to elaborate on my original comment of 'not thought provoking', the chap is an American and probably has little idea about what goes on beyond the shores of the USA (see SOTW for many examples - I'm sure the USAnians who post here are excepted 🙂 ). It all sounded to me like a college student trying to be clever.
Well , to give him his due, I think he's provoked some interesting discussion here.
 
<to BigMartin> Well, if you define 'popular' as 'appearing on the radio' then I might be inclined to agree with you. I'd be more inclined to use something like 'able to fill the Albert Hall'.

Porcupine Tree = Oasis 🙂)) I'll bet they'd be dead chuffed at that comparison.

So what's not bland in your mind then?
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,677
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom