Miscellaneous Why isn't music taken seriously in schools?

I went to a grammar school in the NE in the early 60s, it means something different in the US, and we were offered the chance to learn an instrument, any instrument they said, and so, this being the 60s, I elected to learn the guitar; nothing happened. What was available was the piano, which we couldn’t afford, the violin, ditto but I had no interest though in later years I heard one student playing the trumpet but I don’t know if he got any coaching. Given the period I’m sure others must have chosen guitar but, I think, snobbery removed it from consideration. So that was it, eventually I could buy my own and taught myself. Apart from that false offer music barely featured in my time there, we weren’t taught to read which I still bitterly regret.

In the 80s I worked in a school, comprehensive, in London that had a whole corridor given over to music and some good, enthusiastic teachers. The suite was available to for adult education evening classes and I got my first taste of improvising jazz there. It was hugely popular and lasted about 5-6 years before the government decided that subsidised adult education was a waste of money, pretty well all of it as it turned out, and pushed up prices, reduced wages for the tutors and so it died. It struggles in odd places at prices that a lot can’t afford.

I assume it varied across the country and some did better than others but those have been some of my experiences of public educational support for music and the value accorded to it. The one good thing about it is that those who opt to teach it are generally very committed.
 
Last edited:
The second issue becomes something alluded to in the OP.

What IS considered a 'musical instrument' today ? I am gonna sound hella curmudgeonly here, but...laptops and DJ software in the music room, and we will soon be approaching a generation of 'performers' who have relied solely on studio sampling, glorified karaoke machines, etc; 'players' who have never 'played' with other human beings.
Performers self-promoting who truly don't even know what a "chord progression" is.

I am not saying DJ's and 'generated' tracks have no place...but I have heard enough young folk refer to themselves as musicians when in fact they play no musical instrument, nor do they sing.

So culturally, there is this element to contend with as well...the dynamic which exists in modern society that a sax, trumpet, cello, clarinet, etc...community bands, stage bands, concert bands, etc...are all 'old'school', as relevant today as an Edsel.
My personal opinion is that laptops and software are tools to assist with the creative processes, and that they're not musical instruments in themselves.

What does sound curmudgeonly is assuming that the existence of these tools means that younger generations won't take up the things we regard as musical instruments. This is simply not the case, at least in the UK, which has been demonstrated to me by my own experience of my daughters' peers.

Some examples. Today I went in to the small town near where I live. There was a young guy there, I'd guess 17 or so, playing guitar and singing his heart out. He was brilliant (and had a guitar case with a fair bit of money in it, so his efforts were appreciated). A couple of weeks ago I gave a lift to a neighbour's 17 year old son, as his mum's car had a flat battery. In the five minute journey we talked about his musical aspirations, his plan to go away to study music and his dilemma whether to focus on guitar, piano or possibly to take up another instrument. One of my daughter's aquaintences heard I could play sax, and asked me to help him find a good one at a reasonable price, as he was concerned that a lot of stuff marketed on the internet was crap. He now plays every day. Another friend recently lost her elderly mother. She asked me if I could help her son, 18, to record some piano stuff to have played at her funeral. He sat down and played for five minutes, totally improvised, flawlessly. I recorded it on a digital recorder. He was brilliant. My younger daughter has a friend who wrote her first proper song aged 11. She's now 18, and playing professionally.

To quote Paul Weller "I could go on, and I probably will". I think music is thriving among the youth of today, and that makes me happy.
 
I agree, giving children the opportunity to give music a go is a must. Some will like it, others hate it, but it might just be the spark that someone was missing.

A friends daughter is a competitive wrestler, representing the UK. She'd never wrestled in her life until a coach came into their school and took a PE lesson. Seeing her natural ability, suggested she come to a training session, the rest is history.

Even now, I've not the foggiest idea about how people make a living playing music.

The only professional musicians I knew of at school were the Royal Marines band, as my grandfather was a bands man - I was always far from good enough to apply.

Whether it's laptops and mixing decks, or a conventional instrument the theory must be similar, if not the same.
 
This is a perennial challenge. As presently constituted, the UK educational system (certainly in England) is utterly obsessed with "performance statistics" especially around the three Rs - anything that is deemed to not support that is superfluous and to be got rid of. Hence the very significant degradation of all arts and other 'non-essential' subjects over the last 40 years or so. This is a grotesque failure to understand the many benefits of the arts.

The stupidity of this is obvious. Review after review shows that music education has many benefits and leads to improved results in, for example, maths and English. That is in addition to other skills such as team work, cooperation etc. Despite all the research that shows this, it's relegated to the back burner.

I went to a grammar school in the 70s. I had two 40 minute class music lessons a week, where I learnt to read music etc. From second form onwards (err year 8? age 12/13) we had an instrumental lesson where I first encountered cello. I sat music O Level as an optional subject in 6th form.

There have been numerous government initiatives over the last 30 years - I was reading an academic analysis of this the other day. Despite these reviews there has been no improvement.

Essentially, you are at the mercy of a postcode lottery. If you are in London, you have several music hubs and a large resource pool of ensembles, bands, orchestras etc. In the rest of the country the service is much patchier. Many counties have music hubs but everything is centrally based in the main county town. Given that, where I live for example the county town is 25 miles away with very poor public transport, the only way to get here is parental taxi service.

Music is rapidly becoming the purview of those who can afford it. Private schools provide music tuition as standard in general, often with plenty of rehearsal spaces etc. The way it is going, apart from a few fortunate places, the majority will have limited or no access to music education.
 
@Tenor Viol I agree that there is a rather crude emphasis on performance stats, imposed on the teaching professions. Certainly much more than I as a parent wanted to see. However, my experience has been that it is not to the exclusion of extra-curricular activities. The following is what the ordinary state school I attended says about its music education

Music
Egglescliffe has a national reputation as one of the most musical schools in the country. In recent years we have won national performance awards, performed at St Mark’s Basilica in Venice, recorded with the Gabrieli Consort, performed at the Royal Albert Hall Schools Prom, sold out the Sage Gateshead for our 50th anniversary concert and performed Les Miserable at Middlesbrough Little Theatre. Every week, nearly 350 students take instrumental lessons in school and 11 ensembles rehearse, ranging from orchestra to big band jazz.


The first bit is the boasting stuff, but the really important piece is the stuff at the end about how many kids get lessons in school. I think there are currently about 1,000 on the school roll.

This is a link to a search of the school where my kids went, again, an ordinary state comprehensive.

music - Sackville School

As you can see, loads going on. There is also loads and loads of other extracurricular stuff for sports, drama, astronomy, arts, and so on.

The national curriculum has Music as a mandatory subject from Key Tage 1 to 3 (age 5 to 14) along with Art and Design and Design Technology. So that's quite a lot of opportunity. After that, it is a statutory right to study music in school up to GCSE level.

Regarding music now being the purview of the affluent, that's an odd one. Musical instruments are, in real terms, more affordable than they've ever been. However, the adult music education I tapped into in the early 1980 - free lessons and practice space at the local tech - has completely vanished. That's a real shame.
 
What does sound curmudgeonly is assuming that the existence of these tools means that younger generations won't take up the things we regard as musical instruments.
I just re-read my post #18....and I never said that, and if it was implied in any way then it wasn't my intent.

I also made no comment on whether music was thriving among youth or not...

But the fact is, as DJ's and glorified karaoke machines and laptops and sampling, etc.... are now the norm, and.... literally.... 'music' made/created with no actual (conventional) musical instruments being played - has now been a norm in recording and performance for a generation or more...

There IS a very sizable percentage of young people who have the desire, with the hardware very EASILY at hand, to 'make' music ....without ever 'needing' to learn a (conventional) musical instrument.

So beforehand,the desire of a youngster to "want to make/play/perform music" was met with the following options: "learn an instrument, learn to sing"...

Whereas nowadays...the desire does not require one to learn a conventional instrument, or even learn to sing....there are other 'paths' in the modern context/definition of 'creating music'...and many youngsters choose those options instead, and eschew actually learning an instrument or taking proper voice lessons. So yes music may be just as much of an interest now as before (I don't believe it is, but let's say it is) but the paths to it can bypass conventional academic music education/methods altogether (to the detriment of the individual, imho).

That was more my point.
 
Last edited:
School music lessons almost put me right off. Too regimented and talentless teachers. What's that old saying?
I tried again in my teens with private piano lessons but I was never going to be a classical pianist. However some of the basics got hammered home, so that when I decided to take it up as an adult, I had a head start.
I have very mixed feelings about school music. 4 beats to the lesson was common time. No doubt things have changed. I do hope so.
Making maracas out of light bulbs and drums out of baby milk tins, probably reflected the state of funding in the 60's, or maybe it was the skiffle influence.
Sampling has been around since the 80's and tape loops since the 60's.
Top of the pops has a lot to answer for. Miming to records isn't new and the teeny bopper screaming at the band on the stage while the actual musicians played behind the curtain often happened.
"Kids today don't know they're born." (Socrates) 😉
 
In rural America where I live, huge marching bands were the norm when I was a kid in the 70s and still are today as far as I can tell. Both my kids had great music education in public school as well (that's government funded and tuition-free in case you aren't familiar with the US system). I started in 7th grade, my kids in 6th. Band class was an hour every day. From 8th to 12th grade, I also had jazz band, for a total of 2 hours of music per day in the normal school day plus additional practice nights and weekends if we were prepping for a competition in addition to a couple of weeks of band camp in the summer which was all day, every day, usually living in a dorm at a local university. In between we had competitions, all region band, all state band, solo and ensemble festival, trips to a few college bowl parades and of course, playing/marching at every football and basketball game (smaller pep band). That's a lot of music education.

Thanks to all that, as well as my own personal interest in jazz and theory at home, I came out a pretty solid player. I was lead tenor all through high school as well as all 4 years of university in the big band even though I didn't major in music. After a 10 year break to start my family and career, I returned to playing music in community big band and concert band as well as starting my own jazz combo, trad jazz group and sax quartet plus the occasional stint in rock/pop/r&b/swing bands for weddings, parties, festivals and other events as well as some recording sessions. So the past 25 years or so have also been very busy for me musically, thanks to the education and experience I got in public school. In all that time, I had a handful of private lessons from local sax pros on and off who taught me a lot of great stuff in a short time. I was already an adult by the time I was ready for that kind of advanced study, so paid for those myself.

I can see where poorly funded inner-city schools wouldn't have the same resources and opportunities for their students, and music programs are the first to go when there are budget cuts. So that's definitely an issue in the US. I'm lucky to live in the part of the country that I do.
 
You mean free tuition, I hope!
Maybe it's a British vs. US English thing, but I meant exactly what I said - "tuition-free" as is free of tuition. "Free tuition" implies that there is tuition, but I don't have to pay it. That's not the case for public school in the US. There is no tuition to begin with, so it's free of tuition, or tuition-free. Similarly, "sugar-free" foods/drinks have no sugar to begin with. "Free sugar" foods/drinks (if there were such a thing) would contain sugar that I don't have to pay for.

Public colleges and universities in the US are a different matter. Those do indeed have tuition which may be free under certain circumstances, hence "free tuition" would be the appropriate phrase in those cases.
 
Maybe it's a British vs. US English thing, but I meant exactly what I said - "tuition-free" as is free of tuition.
In that case I stand corrected.
But now I'm confused. I don't really understand how music education can be tuition-free. Seems like a contradiction in terms. Not trying to be antagonistic; would genuinely welcome clarification.
:headscratch:
 
Last edited:
In that case I stand corrected.
But ... I don't really understand how music education can be tuition-free. Seems like a contradiction in terms. Not trying to be antagonistic; would genuinely welcome clarification.
:headscratch:
Maybe my understanding of UK public schools is wrong. I thought your public schools were equivalent to our private schools, requiring paid tuition. Only your "state" schools are free. So I was trying to clarify that our pubic schools do not have tuition like yours, i.e., ours are free of tuition like your state schools.

Since music education here is usually part of the normal curriculum, it's also free to all who attend public school.

Does that make more sense, or have I made it worse? How would you describe a state funded school compared to one you have to pay to attend in terms of tuition?
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,433
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom