All depends on how well it's played. Arguably it's harder to play higher notes nicely.Not controversial. Just wrong.
All depends on how well it's played. Arguably it's harder to play higher notes nicely.Not controversial. Just wrong.
Not so sure about that. The clarinet's known as 'the misery stick' for a reason, and it's not just the torture of wrangling a sound out of the thing.if you want a high-pitched wind instrument clarinet just sounds so much nicer.
Oi! Not everybody plays soprano like I do!Because high-pitched saxophones sound horrible (played well or not). Alto up to normal range is OK (as long as people stay away from altissimo), but if you want a high-pitched wind instrument clarinet just sounds so much nicer. Soprano sax just sounds like an oboe simulator on a cheap synth.
(I realise some of that may be slightly controversial 😉 )
If you listen to me I would agree but we have some fabulous sop players on the forum 🙂Because high-pitched saxophones sound horrible (played well or not). Alto up to normal range is OK (as long as people stay away from altissimo), but if you want a high-pitched wind instrument clarinet just sounds so much nicer. Soprano sax just sounds like an oboe simulator on a cheap synth.
(I realise some of that may be slightly controversial 😉 )
Grovel, grovel, @Jeanette best sop player in the world.If you listen to me I would agree but we have some fabulous sop players on the forum 🙂
Jx

All depends on how well it's played. Arguably it's harder to play higher notes nicely.
Oi! Not everybody plays soprano like I do!
If you listen to me I would agree but we have some fabulous sop players on the forum 🙂
Jx
Not so sure about that. The clarinet's known as 'the misery stick' for a reason, and it's not just the torture of wrangling a sound out of the thing.
It's funny, that's pretty much my position but from the other side 🙂It's the 12th and the open tone holes that make me miserable.
So easy to squeak.
I thought sop would cover the range and be easier to play.
It's not.
Different difficulties is all.

Nah, it's just the misery of playing the thing. 😉As a far better clarinettist than a sax player I'm possibly just a tad biased - I find saxophones far harder to play (well) than clarinet. But I'd like to suggest that the "misery stick" moniker refers to the expression and feeling of the tone, lending itself to renditions ofmiserablesoulful tunes (especially the lower register)
That's my job!(at least nobody's started bringing fish into it yet)
You know, when I was playing clarinet, I never had issues with squeaking.It's the 12th and the open tone holes that make me miserable.
So easy to squeak.
I thought sop would cover the range and be easier to play.
It's not.
Different difficulties is all.
Excellent. Although I do feel that the lyrics should be auf deutsch.Forget Bechet, Coltrane, Gorelick etc.
This is how a soprano should be played:
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UJ1WvzD_kHw
