Saxophones Why is soprano saxophone less popular?

Well, I'm no expert; but I've heard Garbarek live, including his curvey sop - and that's as ethereal as the best clarinet I've heard (Giora Feidman, for my money)... I'm still not going to start on the soprano, myself.
 
Last edited:
There's very few soprano players I enjoy listening to... there's two I LOVE. Coltrane and Wayne Shorter. I have to say I think Wayne Shorter has my favorite soprano sax sound - he makes that thing SING. If you haven't checked it out take a listen to Wayne Shorter's "Native Dancer". His soprano playing is phenomenal.
 
Because high-pitched saxophones sound horrible (played well or not). Alto up to normal range is OK (as long as people stay away from altissimo), but if you want a high-pitched wind instrument clarinet just sounds so much nicer. Soprano sax just sounds like an oboe simulator on a cheap synth.

(I realise some of that may be slightly controversial 😉 )
Oi! Not everybody plays soprano like I do!
 
Because high-pitched saxophones sound horrible (played well or not). Alto up to normal range is OK (as long as people stay away from altissimo), but if you want a high-pitched wind instrument clarinet just sounds so much nicer. Soprano sax just sounds like an oboe simulator on a cheap synth.

(I realise some of that may be slightly controversial 😉 )
If you listen to me I would agree but we have some fabulous sop players on the forum 🙂

Jx
 
All depends on how well it's played. Arguably it's harder to play higher notes nicely.
Oi! Not everybody plays soprano like I do!

If you listen to me I would agree but we have some fabulous sop players on the forum 🙂

Jx

Well my post was slightly tongue-in-cheek of course, but I'm really not a fan of even a well-played soprano (or smaller) saxophone so it really wasn't a dig at the skill, or otherwise, of the player. Each to their own though 🙂


Not so sure about that. The clarinet's known as 'the misery stick' for a reason, and it's not just the torture of wrangling a sound out of the thing.

As a far better clarinettist than a sax player I'm possibly just a tad biased - I find saxophones far harder to play (well) than clarinet. But I'd like to suggest that the "misery stick" moniker refers to the expression and feeling of the tone, lending itself to renditions of miserable soulful tunes (especially the lower register)
 
It's the 12th and the open tone holes that make me miserable.

So easy to squeak.

I thought sop would cover the range and be easier to play.

It's not.
Different difficulties is all.
It's funny, that's pretty much my position but from the other side 🙂
Even though it SHOULD be easier, the overblowing in octaves still catches me out far more than it ought to considering recently I've been playing more sax than clarinet. My brain still naturally seems to think clarinet when I'm playing woodwind, and I do find myself consciously having to "think sax". And as for reminding my vice-like embouchure muscles to back off a bit... :rolleyes:

But keeping on topic (ish), sound-wise I think high-pitched saxophones just aren't my thing.

Edit: The first gig I got with a local jazz band when I was a teenager was because their usual woodwind player hated playing clarinet, so he was happy to play saxes for the whole set and let me sit in for tunes that needed clarinet - suited me fine 🙂
 
As a far better clarinettist than a sax player I'm possibly just a tad biased - I find saxophones far harder to play (well) than clarinet. But I'd like to suggest that the "misery stick" moniker refers to the expression and feeling of the tone, lending itself to renditions of miserable soulful tunes (especially the lower register)
Nah, it's just the misery of playing the thing. 😉

In all seriousness, I started out my musical pathway on the clarinet, about 45 years ago. I went through the classical grades up to grade 8, which I did while doing my A levels, a time when I was really getting into post punk New Wave music. I was really getting thoroughly bored with the clarinet and all that Mozart mullarkey, when the school loaned me a battered old tenor sax. I picked it up and was able to play it straight away and was instantly smitten. I've had a go on the clarinet periodically over the intervening years, but really, it's been sax all the way. Even the odd foray into flute, guitar and harmonica hasn't diverted me from The One True Path. I play soprano, alto, tenor, and baritone. Of these, to be honest, my least favourite is the soprano, but I prefer even that to the clarinet. We're all different.
 
To be honest @jonf my clarinet is probably one of the least played of my instruments at the moment - doesn't really work in a rock band. When I do play it though (mostly classical stuff from my old exam music stash to keep the music reading part of my brain alive, and a bit of trad jazz) it still feels "right" - it's the only instrument I really consider myself properly good at - others I just blag with varying degrees of convincingness.

Anyway - sorry for causing a thread derailment - back to the original topic 🙂 (at least nobody's started bringing fish into it yet)
 
I don’t play soprano because I generally don’t like the sound but I know several players and most of the major league tenor players seem to succumb at some point so it’s never struck me as rare, I obviously would be happier if it was. The only people I can think of who I actually enjoy are Coltrane and Shorter. The other problem I have is that playing long, rapid runs seems to be the default.
 
It's the 12th and the open tone holes that make me miserable.

So easy to squeak.

I thought sop would cover the range and be easier to play.

It's not.
Different difficulties is all.
You know, when I was playing clarinet, I never had issues with squeaking.

I also found playing the high notes way easier on clarinet than on sax, really even easier than flute.

But I never could come properly to grips with the little finger keys across the break; and because I've got a damaged right index finger, it's really hard for me to cover that hole properly. Rather than getting into the plateau clarinets, I just bagged the whole project and went back to covering clarinet doubles on soprano, played quietly into the stand.
 
I don't play a lot of soprano, but when I do I really enjoy it (not sure about the audience, although I have had some positive comments so must be doing something right) but for me alto is where I am most comfortable, I think most players have a horn that just feel right.
Soprano is far less forgiving and so easy to play badly than the bigger horns.
 
One of my favorite players of all time is Sidney Bechet.
Born in New Orleans, played and recorded with Louis Armstrong, played several instruments but mostly recorded on soprano sax, live much of the time in Europe (Paris), died at 62 in 1959. He wrote a song called "The 14th of July" that is perhaps my favorite song.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,598
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom