Mouthpieces Why are mouthpieces so expensive?

I was going to start a new thread about expensive mouthpieces not necessarily being best for you, but the "compose" tool pointed me at this fine old thread which seems relevant.

I got one of the third generation Rousseau JDX mouthpieces for my tenor saxophone when they came out just over a year ago, and paid £140 for it. This stood up very well against the £400+ Jody Jazz DV HR that had been my previous go-to contemporary-sounding mouthpiece. In fact I found tthat as well as giving a similar sound and feel to the DV HR, the JDX was more reed friendly and easier in the altissimo for me, and so I sold the DV HR. Both of these mouthpieces are made in the same factory using the same techniques (CNC-machined and hand-finished) but there is a three-fold price difference.

The price difference might be down to R & D costs. The JDX 3.0 tenor has had a pre-existing design applied to it in the form of the V-shpaed chamber that was originally just used in the baritone version. The DV HR version however might have required more modifications to the existing metal DV design in order for it to work in a hard rubber model. More prototypes, therefore more machine time and finishing and testing time.

Alternatively, the price difference might just be marketing, a desire to keep the DV series as the flagship model.

As an aside, my go-to mouthpiece for jazz ensemble is one of the new hand-finished Brilhart Ebolin mouthpieces, which I got on sale for around £120. This replaced a £550+ hard rubber Theo Wanne Lakshmi. The Lakshmi has a very intricate chamber which would have required extensive CAD work, intricate machining and probably much prototyping so I can see where the money went. The Brilhart on the other hand is injection-moulded using 70 year old moulds, although it required extensive hand-finishing time after coming out of the crude mould. (My backup to this is the Phil-Tone Orion, another mouthpiece bargain.)

What have I learned from this mouthpiece journey? If you're in the market for a new mouthpiece, try everything you can get your hands on, don't dismiss the cheap mouthpieces just because they're cheap.
 
I did have an aunt that always wanted to buy the most expensive versions. In here village she was referred to as the "golden". Marketing thrives on such people to play with this emotion and sell them their flagships. While some of the B-brands have a better quality. Sometimes called A-brand simplicity.
Chinese marketing is based on the thought that most people don't want to pay too much. They go for low margin and maximal volume. For the people who thrive A-brands, but don't have the money, they produce counterfeits after a week of the A-brands introduction.
Both types of marketing work with the principle: if you can fool them, fool them.
For mouthpieces I have the philosophy that you have to kiss a lot of frogs before you find a good one.
But this was developed before Yamaha and Yanagisawa showed that it was possible to make a constant quality in mouthpieces.
 
"I have worked machine tools and something like that would take a few minutes to make....."

The OP said, call me Mr Quick. 😜

Should have hired him to make this
1.5"x4"x9", 6000 series aluminum plate, squared up, and ready for the drill press.
Look Mum, no fingers.

IMG_5248.webp
 
So many things in the world have changed.
As an example I seem to recall copper being a cheap metal once that people are now stealing for it's scrap value. Wood was always at the lower end of costs in buildings and so on. It's not now
So relating similar things to the mouthpiece market....
Finite resources, space rental or mortgage, machinery repair costs, limited markets all make it increasingly difficult to turn a profit that will allow the maker to stay financially solvent.
In the chain it's a very different place now. I remember going into a music shop when a Yamaha 4C about £13 with a quality ligature in a plastic case. An Otto Link STM about £65. I'm no statistician but in terms of value for money against wages today I think that the Yamaha would be £22 to £25 but it's up 1/3rd on that. And Otto Link much much more of an increase.
Reeds were cheap consumables, I don't see them as cheap now. I thought nothing of slinging out one that didn't suit me and now I'll give it every chance.
The irony is, at that time I was on fairly low wages and these days my income was greater in comparison yet I still feel the pinch of these things. An increasingly expensive hobby.
So a maker isn't just battling the costs that they incur making their wares, they have to absorb at the other end like we all do of rising energy & food costs.
Maybe I don't have all the facts and some make a tidy and comfortable living at our cost but maybe not.
I used to enjoy just going out for a drive but now I drive when it's necessary. Fuel, tyres, insurance milage bands, uninsured and poor drivers have all increased massively.
The knock on effect just hits your pocket.
So while it may seem an uncomplicated process with cheapish materials, I'd argue it ain't that simple unfortunately.
Including where you are in the world and your own needs.
 
I guess the OP's question is more relevant than ever, or is it? I guess for me the question is: What is expensive?

MPs are accessories that are necessary in allowing us to produce the sound we want--much like string players require bows. Look at the price of high-end string instruments, and then look at the price of high-end bows.

Since I'm a bass/bari sax player, let's look at upright basses. If a player spends 100K - 200K on a high-end double bass, then the bow they choose is going to carry a hefty price tag as well. They can easily run 5 - 10K.

Translating that into saxophones, when I got my minty, rare as hens teeth, Black Gold Couf bari from Paul Maslin at PM Woodwind, I was on the hunt for the perfect MP that did EVERYTHING I needed it to do.

After nearly a year of searching, I ended up working with Theo Wanne, and they made the PERFECT Durga for me, specific to the horn--they had never made one for a JK bari/Couf before. It was an awesome experience from the get.

Yes, it cost many times more than the cheap crap available from China, but I paid for Theo's expertise. His skill. His design skills. His knowledge. These are all things I would NEVER get from cheap knock-offs, or cheaper MPs available. It is also the LAST bari piece I will ever have to buy. Period.

So to answer my own question: Expensive with regards to MPs to me is relative to the price & quality of the instrument in question, and all the things that go into one's own sound production.
 
In an age of automated mass production an item that needs hand finishing stands out because applying that finish, is time consuming.

That time is consumed by a skilled artesian who demands more than minimum wage to apply the magic.

Discovering the magic may take a lifetime of trial and error to learn or it may just be a gift. Either way it is a rarity and and rare things command a premium. Considering the niche nature of the finished product, customers are few and far between and there we have the reason for the high price.
 
I always try to evaluate by factoring in both value and price. And as previously pointed out it's all relative. For a really high quality hand crafted piece I don't have a problem with a price of $700 or so.

More than ever my motto has been "buy once, cry once". If you settle for something that isn't exactly what you're after but is a lot cheaper imo you'll end up unhappy.

Back in the 80's I paid $250 for my Guardala Studio alto piece. $250 in today's dollars is about $750.

Considering that it's given me roughly 40 years of service and could probably fetch $1200 or so if sold today I think that is right up there with some of the best money I've ever spent.

I've been very happy with my 10mFan Robusto metal pieces.

Very flexible piece. Can scream if needed - easy altissimo production and can get right in your face but imbued with a nice beefy core sound. They aren't cheap but give me exactly what I want.

Just received a rhodium plated piece to go with the gold plated one.
JM900008.webp
JM900006.webp
 
I remember going into a music shop when a Yamaha 4C about £13 with a quality ligature in a plastic case. An Otto Link STM about £65. I'm no statistician but in terms of value for money against wages today I think that the Yamaha would be £22 to £25 but it's up 1/3rd on that. And Otto Link much much more of an increase.
What year was this? Some time in the 1980s at a guess? The Bank of England does an inflation calculator to allow comparison in real terms through time.

I have said this on the forum a number of times before, but many aspects of playing the saxophone (particularly entry level saxes) have become much, much cheaper in real terms. My first tenor, a mediocre 1970s Buescher, cost £290 second hand in 1980. That's about £1250 in today's values. A brand new student tenor sax, which would be far better to play, from a reputable shop with after-sales service, costs less than half that amount. A decent second hand student tenor, something like a Jupiter, would be about a third of the real cost of my old Buescher.

Pro level saxes have remained roughly the same cost in real terms, with the exception of Selmer, which have got more expensive, but that's just their marketing-BS led business model.
 
Translating that into saxophones, when I got my minty, rare as hens teeth, Black Gold Couf bari from Paul Maslin at PM Woodwind, I was on the hunt for the perfect MP that did EVERYTHING I needed it to do.

After nearly a year of searching, I ended up working with Theo Wanne, and they made the PERFECT Durga for me, specific to the horn--they had never made one for a JK bari/Couf before. It was an awesome experience from the get
You found a baritone mouthpieces that's meets your needs. I guess you earn some money as well with your bari and mouthpiece as working tools? You know what you wanted.

I play blues and rock at a low level. I just want to make blues and rock songs bigger with my bari. Most of the time I'm playing tenor but I like to play bari as well.

I decided to buy a baritone Metalite. Bingo! My other mouthpices are resting in the drawer.

575 :- for the Metalite mouthpiece and 590 :- for five Plasticover! I'm now back on LaVoz reeds? Just 390 :- for five. Why are reeds so expensive.
 
Last edited:
You found a baritone mouthpieces that's meets your needs. I guess you earn some money as well with your bari and mouthpiece as working tools? You know what you wanted.

I play blues and rock at a low level. I just want to make blues and rock songs bigger with my bari. Most of the time I'm playing tenor but I like to play bari as well.

I decided to buy a baritone Metalite. Bingo! My other mouthpices are resting in the drawer.

575 :- for the Metalite mouthpiece and 590 :- for five Plasticover! I'm now back on LaVoz reeds? Just 390 :- for five. Why are reeds so expensive.

I love my Graftonite & Metalite MPs on bari. I played them for 2 decades on my Mark VI. They worked fantastically for my R&B, rock, and blues bands.

Then I got the Couf, and NONE of 10 bari pieces I had would play right. 2 came close, 1 was almost perfect. 8 were horribly out of tune--including the 2 Rico pieces. The 2 that were the closest were a Runyon Quantum and a vintage SS Berg. Both were in tune, but the left palm keys wouldn't speak exactly right.

I need to be able to hit those notes 100% in tune from ppp to fff 100% of the time. Hence I reached out Theo after speaking to some players here. The GM for the company lives 20 minutes down the freeway from me. He came to my house and looked at the pieces I had, listened to what my horn was doing with them, and a month later he delivered a custom Durga to me.

The Durga also sounds fantastic on the Mark VI and the Committee III BTW--which makes sense, since they were originally designed for vintage baris.

The Durga paid for itself in no time at all, since it allows the Couf to be my primary bari.
Some years back I recommended that our bari player pick up a Melalite so he'd project better with the brass band. It was like thirty bucks and it did the job quite nicely... until he dropped dead. Probably not related. Probably...

Likely not related. But you never know. 😉 >:)
 
What year was this? Some time in the 1980s at a guess? The Bank of England does an inflation calculator to allow comparison in real terms through time.

I have said this on the forum a number of times before, but many aspects of playing the saxophone (particularly entry level saxes) have become much, much cheaper in real terms. My first tenor, a mediocre 1970s Buescher, cost £290 second hand in 1980. That's about £1250 in today's values. A brand new student tenor sax, which would be far better to play, from a reputable shop with after-sales service, costs less than half that amount. A decent second hand student tenor, something like a Jupiter, would be about a third of the real cost of my old Buescher.

Pro level saxes have remained roughly the same cost in real terms, with the exception of Selmer, which have got more expensive, but that's just their marketing-BS led business model.
It would have been 1989 / 1990.
I agree though and kinda forgot that my Corton alto was over £400 around that time and was what my local music shop stocked for us poorpers that couldn't afford a low end Yamaha.
I think you could match that quality today without much trouble and slightly fatter wallet so yes entry level quality may be more accessible as well as much more choice.
Out of interest, by the time I was trying to get my hands on a MKVI tenor just a few years later £800 to £1100 seemed to represent the price in exchange and mart. That did seem awfully expensive and meant saving for but perhaps it worse today in comparison.
 
If mouthpieces are so expensive, why do we have drawers full of them?
The fit between embouchure and saxophone requires some variation in mouthpieces. It takes time to find a good match. So there are many trials and most mouthpieces end in drawers as stagnant value.
To accommodate this, stores have gigantic cupboards full of different mouthpieces. Most pieces have to wait years before sold. It is likely that on average a mouthpiece is played around 0.1% of the time. But you have to pay also for the storage costs.
 
The fit between embouchure and saxophone requires some variation in mouthpieces. It takes time to find a good match. So there are many trials and most mouthpieces end in drawers as stagnant value.
I was very lucky in my youth to have a father so revered that folks would just give him musical instruments. Knowing his son played saxophone, I ended up with horns just given to me, from sopranino to bari. And not to rub it in... many of them Selmers. After collecting these horns with all their old mouthpieces, I had quite a few of these old mouthpieces in a drawer (in my father's old desk, actually). Then cam the Internet and the realization that some of the pieces I had were quite coveted. We're talking vintage Meyer alto, vintage Link tenor, vintage large chambered soprano mouthpieces. I hit the lottery. Every one I didn't use got sold or traded for what I could use. Now I have a main mouthpiece for each of my horns with a near (as I can get) identical backup, also for each. I still have a few in that drawer though; a vintage soprano mouthpiece, a vintage baritone mouthpiece and a vintage alto mouthpiece I keep in case someone else wants to play my horns some day. If they tried to play them with what I use, they might think something is wrong with the horn...
 
I was very lucky in my youth to have a father so revered that folks would just give him musical instruments. Knowing his son played saxophone, I ended up with horns just given to me, from sopranino to bari. And not to rub it in... many of them Selmers. After collecting these horns with all their old mouthpieces, I had quite a few of these old mouthpieces in a drawer (in my father's old desk, actually). Then cam the Internet and the realization that some of the pieces I had were quite coveted. We're talking vintage Meyer alto, vintage Link tenor, vintage large chambered soprano mouthpieces. I hit the lottery. Every one I didn't use got sold or traded for what I could use. Now I have a main mouthpiece for each of my horns with a near (as I can get) identical backup, also for each. I still have a few in that drawer though; a vintage soprano mouthpiece, a vintage baritone mouthpiece and a vintage alto mouthpiece I keep in case someone else wants to play my horns some day. If they tried to play them with what I use, they might think something is wrong with the horn...
lol… I thought I was lucky that my dad scored a $30 clarinet for me in the 3rd grade to get my musical journey started. 😀
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,057
Messages
578,193
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom