Playing the saxophone Who started on tenor then switched to alto, or vice versa

Who started on one and switched to the other

  • Started on tenor and switched to alto

    Votes: 6 20.7%
  • Started on alto and switched to tenor

    Votes: 23 79.3%
  • I switched back again

    Votes: 4 13.8%

  • Total voters
    29
Hi Pete,
I liked your breakdown of what sax you played.

Why are you playing alto sax more than tenor sax?
Me Pete? Not that handsome @Pete Thomas fellow?

Originally I was a clarinet player. From age 7 - 23 really. I got an alto aged 14 or so but wasn’t that into it. At that time though my influences were Desmond and Grover Washington Jr.

My clairinet playing transferred to those guys quite naturally. After music college I became disenchanted with the clarinet and where I lived and moved back to where I had previous contacts, and the work was sax work.

I got more into “pop-jazz” or Smooth / Funk whatever and that suited alto. I did have a tenor in my teens but I didn’t consider myself particularly good on it. Not a natural voice for me.

In the early 2000s I was being asked to double alto and tenor more and more, then in 2004 I got into a band of a rock n roll artist, so I had to jump ship.

In 2010 I was in a BBC house band and that involved alto and clarinet, we had another sax guy who did Bari, tenor and occasional flute.

Recently, I I’ve been dep’ping for a rock artist - tenor again!
 
I started on alto in high school, stopped sax altogether for 45 years, then resumed 2 years ago. Recently I picked up a tenor as that instrument seems more needed for classic rock. Alto is yanigasawa, tenor is yamaha. I am finding that the tenor is easier to play, at least as far as embrochure goes. This is surprising to me. I intend to continue to play both.
 
First teenage saxophone was a wreck of a tenor that I bodged back to life, I got about half way thru the Tune a Day book then the age of Punk happened and I was in bands straight away, ( and cheerio to reading notation etc! ) I switched back and forth from Tenor to Alto a couple of times, but found Tenor was more 'me' and worked in a band better, obviously back then you could only afford one instrument at a time !
 
Me Pete? Not that handsome @Pete Thomas fellow?
Isn't it age before beauty? 😉

About 13 years ago, I was participating with the worship band in a local Nazarene church. For pre-worship music as fill whilst attendees entered the sanctuary, they started out with some free playing background on piano, bass, rythm guitar, drums. I joined in with improv on my sax.

The bandleader shouted to the youth director, "Now, we have Saturday Night Live!" 😉
 
@PigSquealer , this will improve your play. 😉
 
@PigSquealer , this will improve your play. 😉
'ere.. do you want to swap your farm for some magic beans ? :thumb:
 
No! It's GAS! There's no cure! :confused: >:):optimistic:😉
As with many other types of suffering, there is a path. Among the first steps is awareness.

I once owned five Borgani Jubilee tenors of the various finishes and mechanism options. I recall that I also had a TH&C, 156, and full pearls Super 20 - all in freshly overhauled top condition. I call that my Peak Tenor Era.
 
@PigSquealer , this will improve your play. 😉
I don’t think this will make intentionally bad playing worse. Besides gold plays way too bright. I’m more a sliver kind of swine.
 
I started on alto when I was ten years old and soon thereafter started playing pretty much all of them, but for bass and C melody. I was very fortunate to have a father who was not only revered in his town, but had a dixieland band on the side comprised mostly of doctors and lawyers (The Bars & Tonics). One of the doctors was a tenor man, but he also had a soprano and bari. They were all vintage Martins and he'd lend them to me for extended periods. Also, as part of that whole revered thing, if any of my father's patients had a spare musical instrument lying around, they'd end up giving it to him. Not just saxophones mind you... but accordions, guitars, mandolins... you name it. By the time I was in college I had two sopranos, an alto, a tenor, a bari and even a sopranino all my own. So very fortunate in this regard and I've played them all regularly over the years, but for the sopranino which had limited use. Paid off too, as when I got to college I tried out for the stage band on tenor. Those seats were filled, but when they asked if I played bari, it was HECK YEAH and I was in. Got lead alto the next year, but quit mid-semester to join an R&B band gigging in Boston. Don't think I've read music since, other than a fake book.

Gun to my head, I'd have to grab my tenor as my weapon of choice, but I consider myself a saxophonist rather than a tenor man. You just can't play them the same way. They're each their own.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,060
Messages
578,349
Members
8,128
Latest member
Roger Atlas
Back
Top Bottom