Playing the saxophone Who started on tenor then switched to alto, or vice versa

Who started on one and switched to the other

  • Started on tenor and switched to alto

    Votes: 6 20.7%
  • Started on alto and switched to tenor

    Votes: 23 79.3%
  • I switched back again

    Votes: 4 13.8%

  • Total voters
    29
Then, you may have a good intermediate disguised as a beginner.



I was missing the G key pearl on my Vito tenor. For a time to fill the void, I found a small fender washer the right diameter, attached it with some contact cement, which got me by in the Community Band. Then purchased a set of simulated (plastic) pearls for it on E-Bay for a reasonable price, which fixed the problem, paid less than $10 for them. Something as simple as that could correct a cosmetic defect helping you to earn more for it when you sell.
Thanks for the information. Did not pay much for it Total price including taxes etc. Etude
$ 106.25 , Vito $ 118.45 Mendini 198.
 
Thanks for the information. Did not pay much for it Total price including taxes etc. Etude $ 106.25 , Vito $ 118.45 Mendini $198.

You're welcome. If the pads are in decent shape and there isn't too much wrong with them, then you got them at bargain prices.

Whilst browsing on Amazon, lo and behold, found a good used Mendini tenor sax in black nickel with nickel silver keys, bundled with all the goodies (electronic tuner, reeds, mouthpiece, case, etc.) for $190 US with free shipping, sold by the same vendor who deals new. Should be here in about a week. Will have more to report when I take it for a spin.

First time I've seen used offered by this vendor, he may have offered before, but didn't see it.

I'm stoked. :banana:
 
Started on alto as that was what funds allowed, played that for a few years and then got a great deal on a tenor. Mostly play tenor now with the bands and for fun but, I have recently been asked to play at a concert on the alto, forgot how much I enjoyed playing it, and also that it has a beautiful sound.

I also occasionally play a soprano but had to get a straight one as, a man of weight and stature, I looked like I giant with an curved one! 😉
 
I also occasionally play a soprano but had to get a straight one as, a man of weight and stature, I looked like I giant with an curved one! 😉
Personally, I think that people would think nothing of it, particularly when they hear the lovely sound of it! 😉

At times I've been tempted to obtain a curved soprano, but my current straight one plays well, keeps me satisfied. My next may be an Eb Alto Clarinet.
 
I also occasionally play a soprano but had to get a straight one as, a man of weight and stature, I looked like I giant with an curved one! 😉
I normaly play tenor, and occasionaly bari.
This weekend I got myself a curved soprano. My daughter said I looked like somebody shot at me with a "shrinking ray" and hit my sax
;-)
 
The curved soprano sax is somewhat a novelty. Reason why I got my straight soprano versus curved was at the time, the straight was less expensive. In public, I've even had people ask me what type of clarinet it was.

I consider it fun to switch between all 4, actually all 6 if including the clarinets. Regarding the "shrink ray" effect, this is why I like my Eb sopranino clarinet. Plus, it was easy to pack case and all in a motorcycle saddle bag.
 
Have you identified the maker of the Vito? One I have, an older tenor, appears to be by Jupiter.

Just curious, out of the 3, which one is your favourite, and why?
Got a helpful hint from another member of a sax forum. So I was able to identify the Vito as a stencil of Jupiter 669 alto sax.

Mendini was newer and great sound. But I sold it due to concern of its ergonomics. Had the tenor version it caused me arm and pects problems.

Etude took awhile to get used to, due to shorter neck. Just sold it today. Hard horn to sell of any I owned.

Once I played the Vito I was hooked. Great sound, excellent key actions. My mouthpieces and reeds pair well with the sax.

My preferred mouthpiece is a E. Rousseau 6 studio.

Playing Legere 2.25 American cut, Signature, Studio cut reeds, Bravo 2.0 reeds.
 
Decades ago started on tenor. Ex-wife nixed that idea in no time.

In January I started on flute & clarinet (both very physically light instruments). But the “bug” hit and now have a YTS-61, YAS-62(1), and most recently a Couf Superba 1 soprano. I’m done for horns.

The YTS went in for a stuffy “D” repair, so I’ve been playing (if you can call it that) the alto & the soprano. In the end, I think I prefer the two ends of the horns, the tenor & soprano. No slight to the alto.

I’m a huge fan of Grover Washington Jr so to be able to play anything of his one day (East River Drive my choice) is a big goal. As to the tenor, anything by Stan Getz, and finally on the alto anything by Paul Desmond.

I’m 65 yrs young restarting this journey. Who know where I get, but Rubank & I get together almost every night for practice now.
 
Started on clarinet age 7. Got an alto age 14. Didn’t much enjoy it. Got a tenor age 16, enjoyed it less. Dabbled on soprano for a bit.

After college decided to try and play the sax properly. These days I rarely pick up the clarinet. Funnily enough I think I’d play it more if I was still playing chamber music.

Alto player from my early’20’s. Became an improved tenor player in my ‘40’s due to necessity.

Always been decent on soprano as I find it really similar to clarinet.

Alto 70%
Tenor 30%

Clarinet and soprano nominal.
Update:

My earlier evaluation was what I do “at home”. Here are my paid gigs:

2015 - 2025
Tenor 100%

2014
Tenor 90%
Alto 5%
Soprano 5%

2010 - 2013
Alto 80%
Tenor 8%
Clarinet 12%

2004 - 2009
Tenor 70%
Alto 30%

1998 - 2004
Alto 90%
Tenor 10%

1992 - 1997
Alto 90%
Tenor 5%
Clarinet 5%

1988 - 1991
Clarinet 95% (classical)
Alto 5% (not classical)
 
I started learning to play the sax in late December 2024.

I wanted a tenor but I found locally a YAS-25 in really good condition at a very low price - it just needed some new pads and a service. I've been having great fun with it and progressing very well according to my teacher (and my wife!).

Last month the vendor called me with a YTS-25 so I grabbed it, again low cost for what it is, just needed a minor service. It is well used, lots of minor scratches and some lacquer wear but no dents, dings or problems and it sounds, even with my newbie chops, wonderful!

Today I practiced on the alto for the first time in a fortnight. Took a minute or so to adjust my embouchure but no problems playing apart from the fact I didn't like the pitch anymore. I find the tenor much easier to relate to tonally. Also, for me the tenor feels more comfortable, I like the relaxed posture, ergonomics, easier-blow and overall experience playing it.

When I see the alto and tenor on their stands, it's the tenor I want to pick up and blow!

I'm an old amateur late starter who is doing this for his own pleasure with no aspirations to be 'great', get gigs* or be anything other than a hobbyist blower, so I feel it would be best to concentrate on the tenor to try and make the sounds I want.

* There is community band open to newbies near me - Saltdean Jazz Band - but I have not summoned up the courage to join yet.
 
My first saxophone was a tenor in 1969. I had already played clarinet for about 4 years. I played in big bands on the both coasts in the ‘70s, then played sop/alto/tenor in a fusion band in the San Francisco Bay Area in the ‘80s for a few years. When I moved to Santa Fe, NM, in the late ‘90s, I took up bari because there were openings in the two local big bands. After a couple years, I earned positions on fourth sax (second tenor) in both bands and sold my bari. I eventually found fewer reasons to keep sop and alto saxes, so I sold them off about 5 years ago. The tenor sax remains as my only - and preferred - saxophone voice.
 
Update:

My earlier evaluation was what I do “at home”. Here are my paid gigs:

2015 - 2025
Tenor 100%

2014
Tenor 90%
Alto 5%
Soprano 5%

2010 - 2013
Alto 80%
Tenor 8%
Clarinet 12%

2004 - 2009
Tenor 70%
Alto 30%

1998 - 2004
Alto 90%
Tenor 10%

1992 - 1997
Alto 90%
Tenor 5%
Clarinet 5%

1988 - 1991
Clarinet 95% (classical)
Alto 5% (not classical)
Reverse timeline

Saxophone's Benjamin Button
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,325
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom