Mouthpieces Who plays a Metal Mouthpiece on Alto Sax.......?

I've been playing Zagar metals for ages for alto, and just switched to HR to experiment on the difference. I love (personally) zagars pieces and also like my new HR aizen.
Zagar pieces have been the only metal ones ive tried that work with alto for me... maybe becuase of the type of metals or something..
 
When i played alto i used a H/R link on the Buffet Crampon which was a lively quite bright horn. On the Yani A 500 which was the stuffiest horn i've ever played i used a Berg o chamber metal to open it up
Rob.
 
I've only liked playing alto with HR pieces until I recently picked up a vintage SS Berg Larsen.

Besides the tone and resistance being spot on for me it also just felt good in my mouth. :thumb:

Sounds stupid, but I think I generally I don't like metal pieces because of their fit or feel in my mouth (at least in the case of the Link and Meyer I've tried). But it may have been my embouchure being less mature than it is now?

The differences between my HR Berg 90/2/SMS and my new SS Berg 100/1/M I would like say tonally they are surprisingly similar - round and fat but with a bit more edge in the SS piece.

Also, the metal piece is way louder and slightly more resistant, which is probably due to the tip opening difference and the higher baffle. Also the higher register is much cleaner and easier to play on the SS 100/1/M. More reed picky though.
 
I have gone through a ridiculous number of reeds in the relatively short time I have been trying to play alto, one of which was a Jody Jazz DV, which I liked a lot and am not sure why I sold it! I did find it hard at first when going from HR to metal, to deal with the smaller size ....lots of 'leakage' from the corners of the mouth!
It may be a coincidence but most of the alto players who make the lovely clear bright sound which I like, use metal.
That Sonny Stitt clip was gorgeous ..... none of the 'rough edge' which many seem to have, and maybe prefer.
 
I've been giving my battered Oleg Maestro an airing on alto recently. It's a much knocked about thing (bit like the player) with a good bit of lost plating. It has a big baffle, but this has been moderated a bit to take the edge off, by Brian Powell. He also levelled off the table and evened out the rails. All paid for by the previous owner, I paid £40 for it, I think. It's a really good piece, surprisingly a bit resistant to play, but a good strong tone. Can do bright and raunchy, without ever getting screechy. Good for a blast of strip joint jazz.
 
I have gone through a ridiculous number of reeds in the relatively short time I have been trying to play alto, one of which was a Jody Jazz DV, which I liked a lot and am not sure why I sold it! I did find it hard at first when going from HR to metal, to deal with the smaller size ....lots of 'leakage' from the corners of the mouth!
It may be a coincidence but most of the alto players who make the lovely clear bright sound which I like, use metal.
That Sonny Stitt clip was gorgeous ..... none of the 'rough edge' which many seem to have, and maybe prefer.

I just noticed I wrote 'reeds' in my last post, when I obviously meant mouthpieces :blush: (can't edit it now).
Sorry 'bout that.
I daren't say what I am using currently .... I think Pete might excommunicate me !
 
I just noticed I wrote 'reeds' in my last post, when I obviously meant mouthpieces :blush: (can't edit it now).
Sorry 'bout that.
I daren't say what I am using currently .... I think Pete might excommunicate me !

Why can't you edit it? You should be able to.

BTW, I don't mind what mouthpiece you use
 
There is no Edit option under that post, on my screen.

And I know that you don't .... just kidding 🙂
It's just a brand that you have been .... shall we say .... rather less than enthusiastic about !
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hi everybody,

disclaimer: this is going to be a long one, I'm quite into mouthpieces and such.

well, I play about 13 years of alto now, of which 6 withouth metal mpcs. I was 17 and asked for a band and then it started (GAS).
I must say I believe, no I'm quite certain that the inside dimensions overrule the material influence with at least a factor 50, but metal mpc often have those other dimensions.

In the beginning as a starting classical player I got a S80 C*, which I played until last september or so for classical. I have"dabbled" with other ebonite mpc`s: Tone Edges, a riffault (rascher style) I even refaced and "squared" a simple chinese plastic mpc for what I thought were my preferences. But my Soloist C** is just the thing (altough I am considering some alterations from a dutch refacer).

But for coverbands and the "party/carnaval" band I play in I use metal pieces for about 7 years now. First one was a sort of bright STM copy did its thing for a while but sold it to a collegeu.

The second is still my favorite and that`s a Lebayle Metal Jazz 8. It allows me to play loud enough to annoy the trumpet players and lush enough for a ballad (icw a legere 2¾).

but sometimes I find it necessary to pull out the metalite M11 (or M!!)

I also have an STM 5* but its just awfull, playing wise and quality wise. And believe me I know that piece inside out (litteraly) because I copied it into 3d.

And since recently I'm contemplating of getting a guardala studio for alto since I love it on Tenor so much. But I'm getting the lebayle refaced first as I can see after years of use that the rails arent even.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm intrigued to know what it is now. As I get to try more and more mouthpieces, my opinions change all the time. I've never tried a Wanne alto so I wouldn't know about those. Jody Jazz I was initially unimpressed by the DV, but was impressed by the HR I recently used in my sound comparison test. Oh yes, I did have a Phil Barone that didn't work for me.
 
Oh yes, I did have a Phil Barone that didn't work for me.
Sorry for asking, but you know, i just had to...there has for quite a long time now been rather a lot of hostility between you and Mr B, is it because you are now rivals in the mouthpiece business, or does it go back further than that?

Fwiw, I've tried three Barone mouthpieces now, an alto bought off ebay, and an alto and tenor that came with the sax, and to be honest i hated all three.

Sorry for being a nosy bugger, but I've often wundered.....
 
Sorry for asking, but you know, i just had to...there has for quite a long time now been rather a lot of hostility between you and Mr B,

As you've asked I'll reply (although it's not directly relevant to the thread)

Any hostility is not really "between" us, I'm sure you won't see anything on the internet that shows me being hostile to Phil Barone, you will however possibly find posts on SOTW in which I actually recommend him as one of the good mouthpiece makers/refacers.

The only hostility seems to be one way, and I don't know the reason for his hostility unless it's because I have differing opinions on some aspects of saxophone playing.

As with anyone, I may take somebody to task (politely) if I think they are giving incorrect information or advice, but I would never (knowingly) be "hostile".

In general, the mouthpiece makers I know are not unpleasantly competitive, I don't think any of them could possibly see the tiny PPT Corporation being a competitor and I get on well with many of them.
 
I'm intrigued to know what it is now. As I get to try more and more mouthpieces, my opinions change all the time. I've never tried a Wanne alto so I wouldn't know about those. Jody Jazz I was initially unimpressed by the DV, but was impressed by the HR I recently used in my sound comparison test. Oh yes, I did have a Phil Barone that didn't work for me.

I will stop being mysterious ...as bodak guessed, it is a Wanne, a Durga 7, obtained at about half the MRSP (or is that MRSP?) and it appears unused, there is certainly not a mark on it.
First impressions were of the super finish .... although the inside bears very fine, even machining marks, unlike, for example, the highly polished DV. Theo says that he believes he can be sure of the exact dimensions if it's left unpolished, while polishing might remove varying amounts of metal (or something like that!). I like the satin gold/silver finish of the exterior, which doesn't show fingermarks.
When I first put a reed on and blew ..... yikes 😱 .... much squeeking! It has very thin rails and reeds need to very precisely positioned.... on TW's advice, I move the lig setting to #2 from the tip, and tried other reeds, which, along with a few weeks of use and familiarisation, solved the problem.
The reed it seems to like most, for me, is a La Voz Soft. The Legere Signature and Fibracell Premier are also OK, but don't seem, to me, to have as much character as most of the cane reeds I have (RJS 2S, and Superial DC ). Vandorens and Hahns appear to be fractionally narrower and don't seem completely to cover the rails.
It's a pity because I want to like plastic reeds, for practical reasons ....they do work better on my HR Mouthpiece Cafe NY!

So how does it sound? Well, amazing, when my teacher, Don, played it 🙂 He was highly impressed, but not by the new prices. (He also plays bright loud mpcs...mainly to be heard against his 1st tenor man, who really blasts with his MkVI and, iirc, a Guardala).

It has none of what I can best describe as rough-edged (almost Kazoo-like!) character at the high-end, which so many high-baffle mpcs seem to have, and I really don't like....it is bright and clear, and the lower notes are full and rich.
It seems to combine the best of both worlds, for those who strive for a brighter sound overall (sorry, that sounds like a commercial, but I did a lot of listening before I jumped on this one!)

Listen to Skip Spratt playing an alto Durga on YouTube, www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zb6GGZ8xk3U
and Steve Neff, at www.neffmusic.com/blog/tag/durga-alto (I prefer Skip's sound on this mpc)

When I play it, it is much louder and more free-blowing than my HR, but it's easy to play softly. It's nowhere near as bright, in my hands(and mouth!), but I guess that I don't push the air through it with the force of old pros like Don, Skip and Steve!

I also to expect a bit more freedom in the sound when I move the lig back to a more rearward position, thereby allowing the reed to vibrate more freely. I appreciate that precise adjustability.

So, it's early days, but I am very pleased with the Durga, so far. The MPC Cafe seems rather uninteresting by comparison, but, of course, YMMV! Theo Wanne has been remarkably friendly and helpful, with personal email advice ....especially to someone who didn't buy directly from him, and who expressed quite strong reservations in my first impressions post, in his forum!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I will stop being mysterious ...as bodak guessed, it is a Wanne, a Durga 7,

I know nothing about Wanne mouthpieces, apart from a wooden one I saw at Frankfurt that had a crack right down it, maybe that's what you mean, and I don't take that as representative so i would have anything against them because of that, only the price. Strangely though (I know, having said I get on with all the mouthpiece makers I've met) he was very dismissive when I met him a couple of years back, the opposite of what I would call polite.

But I wouldn't let that colour my opinion of the mouthpieces if i ever tried one.
 
Yes, I recall your saying that, and I railed against anyone who'd be dismissive of you! (what a brown-nose I am ) 🙂
(And also, your saying that there must be something just as good out there for less money!)

well, I got 'something just (exactly) as good out there for (considerably) less money' ;}
 
I would find very difficult to separate myself from my brass Ponzol M2 , I also have a Brancher J21 and have played Link STM (several sizes) before deciding it wasn't for me. Mind you that doesn't mean that great players don't do that!

Perhaps Skip the Dutch intro, by the way Benjamin was born in the UK

Benjamin Herman Otto Link STM

The Late (passed away few days ago) Piet Noordijk on Berg Larsen


Peter King........also Otto Link!

 
Last edited by a moderator:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,077
Messages
578,685
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom