Which saxophone

magz

Member
Messages
26
I have my first lesson on thursday, and think that i would like to get a yamaha sax, as they are so well known.
I was just wondering what the difference is between
YAS 275, YAS 475, and the YAS 62.
This is a long term project to learn the saxophone, and i want something that is going to last a long time.
Does anyone have any experience with any of these saxophones?
 
Hi Laura,
If you've made your decision, then I can only say that I played the 62 series alto and tenor in the late eighties and was absolutely satisfied with the product. However you will find far more enlightening info by reading the extensive reviews by stephen howard at this link.
gruss - spike
 
within yamaha you generally get a better horn for more cash.

my trusty old yas25 (a bit like a 275 only built in japan and not korea, and slightly better built) is a good horn with solid intonation. it has very little character of its own, but responds quite well to different mouthpieces and setups. a couple of the notes are a bit boomy, but pretty compensatable.
i have said (a lot) that a 25 is a much better horn than a 275 - and i stand firmly behind that - but ive played some 275s that are more than playable

my wife plays an old yas52, which was a bottom end pro horn that i think is roughly equivalent to the 475. the engraving is nicer, it has a bit more soul and it blows more openly.

i have played a 62, but only a quick blast on someone elses. it was a nice horn, but i think if i were spending that kind of money i would be wanting something a bit more special.


not sure thats much help but there it is
 
Phil - Don't know about the YAS's, but my YTS275 says "Made in Japan" on it.

This link "http://www.justflutes.com/pages/product-detail21272.htm" seems to indicate that the 275 is made in Japan whereas the 275E is made in Indonesia. Whether that's correct or not, I don't know.

EDIT - Another look shows that the quoted link only has that paragraph on the YAS275 not the YTS275. Possibly the tenors are all still made in Japan and the only the current UK altos have moved...? Or maybe not! Dunno! 😉
 
I owned a YAS 62 once. It was a very good horn but i don't think I'd get one now that some of the newer makes are such good instruments and better value than Yamaha. Although there's absolutely no reason why a beginner should not buy an expensive horn if you can afford it, especially when as committed as you obviously are, I am now of the opinion that's its best to get something a bit cheaper.

However if that horn really inspires you, and it's a very subjective choice, then go for it. What I would warn is that if you want a horn that will be with you for a long time, you need to be confident that you have the ability to choose that horn for the way it suits you and your playing style, otherwise it might be better to wait.
 
interesting,

i noticed the dropoff in quality control, and was led to believe it was due to a factory move

i will have to investigate before i rant further
 
Hi Magz,

No worries! It's a considerable chunk of change and you're right to be cautious.

Try this - http://www.shwoodwind.co.uk/Reviews/Saxes/Alto/Earlham_Pro2_alto.htm

Best regards,

Frank
 
I am so confused, everywhere i look i find differnent saxophone makes.
I may be more sensible to buy a cheaper saxophone as i am only a beginner, and may find that its not for me, but i want to get a great sound from it, and something that wont fall apart.
Does anyone have any suggestions?
 
I've always recommended to purchase the best instrument you can afford.

You've said you are willing to spend 1K which is a heck of a lot of money and will get you a very very good saxophone. The trouble is, all saxophones are different. Have their strengths and weaknesses.

This is because you are now paying for small additions and various other things which make small differences, such as certain styles of octave mechanisms and so on. Advancing players and professionals will want varying amounts of 'specialty' with their saxophone to suit their likes and dislikes better, thus improving their saxophone experience. As a beginner I think it is inadvisable to pay for these things which definitely aren't necessary, or possibly beneficial to a beginner.

I find that the saxophone has a relatively small affect upon the tone, so it isn't what I consider the biggest factor.

When *I* look for a saxophone *I generally prioritize* in this order:

Feel of keywork - Does it run smoothly opening and closing all keys? Are the keys in places suitable for me (I can't play Keilworths because of the D key position, for example.

Build Quality - this has a large affect upon the feel and will help it when played extensively and ruggedly (no bending keys) and hopefully should make repairs less frequent and cheaper.

Balance and Weight of sax - (does it hang around your neck nicely? Are you comfortable with it when in a correct posture? Is it too heavy for you to be comfortable? Does it feel too light?)

Sound - Is it a pleasing sound? Can you manipulate the sound effectively? How extreme can you make your dynamics? Does the articulation come through clearly or is it muffled? Does it project well?

Playability - How does it blow? Do you need to work harder to blow it sufficiently? Do you tend to over-blow as there isn't enough resistance?

-----------------------------------

If you were to go by *my prioritising* you could/can judge the first three for yourself without having to be able to play a note.
It's always advisable to take someone who plays and is experienced along with you and can advise you on the build quality and how it sounds.

The mouthpiece is the bit of gear that will have the greatest affect upon the sound/tone. You can manipulate any saxophone quite drastically with mouthpiece selection. The reed and ligature will further help this.


For these reasons, I'd recommend; Walstein, Hanson, Gear4Music, Low end big brand saxes like Yamaha, Yanagisawa for trying and make a decision based on instinct, first impressions (they are very important) and what other people (who you respect the opinion of, not the salesman unless you know them) think.

I don't think any of that actually helps you find a sax, but maybe you can understand my point and possibly use it to help you find something suitable.
Best of luck in the hunt.
 
Thankyou for all your help, that really helped me, i will definatly go for a cheaper one, until i have a few years experience and know exactly what i want from a saxophone.

Thanks again
 
Please don't take any of that as *fact*.

It's just information I've put together from my limited experiences, other bits I've gathered from other people and witnessed and so on.

The principal for me is what feels right to you, is what's best for you. That doesn't mean you have to spend any large amount of cash, but it also doesn't mean you won't have too.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Trending

Latest Song of the Month

Forum statistics

Topics
32,008
Messages
576,605
Members
8,106
Latest member
gmaric22
Back
Top Bottom