Playing the saxophone Where are they now?

Perhaps it's just me, but when you start progress seem very quick.

I've felt as I have progressed, it's gotten more challenging. I am more critical of myself, and trying to get my head around chords and improvising is like wading through treacle.

Learning any instrument takes hours, and years of perseverance and dedication, I suspect many don't have it, get disheartened, throwing the towel in 🤷‍♂️
 
I've seen, on very rare occasions, a person leave due to some sort of slight that they felt.
We've had a few of these, often accompanied by what we call a YAGE (Yet Another Grand Exit). Here's an example:


Although this is against the rules (or rather the guidelines) we kept that one because it's quite interesting to see how some people just have the wrong attitude to exist peacefully in a forum situation.

People sometimes YAGE when they want to get a point across and go out all guns blazing. But we always try to be very open with the members and also own up if we got something wrong. In the above case though you can see the member basically didn't like there being rules and somehow mistakenly equated moderation with the removal of free speech.

But there have been a coupe of other YAGEs where, like this one, the member involved blames the cafe for something we didn't do and then badmouth us elsewhere so we cannot defend our actions. That is quite upsetting because there is very little we can do when other people believe them. However we always like to be open about reasons when questioned if at all feasible.

However we are quite proud that we can settle most issues diplomatically and (Jeanette my be able to confirm) we have hardly ever banned anyone apart from spammers.
 
Last edited:
We've had a few of these, often accompanied by what we call a YAGE (Yet Another Grand Exit).
Wow! I just read that thread you linked, initiated 14 years ago. My first thought to the OP was, "Hope the door doesn't hit you in the arse on the way out!" :confused:

I don't picture you Pete as such as he described you. He was definitely off-kilter.

We had a few like him at work. Fortunately, they didn't last long.
 
However we are quite proud that we can settle most issues diplomatically and (Jeanette my be able to confirm) we have hardly ever banned anyone apart from spammers.
I certainly can, I can probably count on one hand the number we actually banned and even a couple of them were let back in. 😀

Members have lots of reasons for leaving and sadly we know we have lost some good ones. We do sometimes try and contact established members if they disappear to ensure something hasn't happened to upset them that we may have missed.

Jx
 
Many years ago, I was one of the mod team for a music forum that was part of a higher education establishment. So, all members were students of the institution. The institution had some very strict rules about what could or could not be discussed. For example, any discussion of what questions had been set in exams was strictly forbidden. Nowt to do with moderators, that was the institutions rule. Oh boy.... the number of "mods denying freedom of speech... this is a democracy..." etc. arguments was unreal.

I joined the Café later in 2011 so I missed that one!
 
I joined the Café later in 2011 so I missed that one!
But you probably experienced the other two big Yages. Neither of whom were banned (contrary to what they said outside the forum) but just failed to communicate with us very well and threw their toys out of the pram.

Jeanette iscorrect in that often if there are members who were banned for some reason there is often a chance they will be welcomed back after appropriate discussion and clearing of the air.
 
I think life gets in the way sometimes. I dropped off the SOTW planet even though my gigging in the mid 2000s-2015 actually increased. Working a job, hustling gigs, maintaining the house/property, children getting married/divorced etc...
There was a point where I had to accept, the best level of skill that my time allowed.

Also musicians of all types and jazz in particular can at times be very critical, on each other and themselves.
 
I have to agree with folks about the value of forums Vs social media. I am in a number of Facebook groups, the whole experience is very ephemeral, whilst I might catch something interesting scroll by now and again there's not often thoughtful engagement, and digging back "through the archives" is basically impossible.

It's a real shame that forums in general are not what they were 10/20 years ago and folks get caught in their social media of choice bubble.

I had a long hiatus from this forum, directly linked to not being able to play saxophone, once I started up again I came back and was glad it was still here 🙂
 
I for one really appreciate having a forum to discuss music and the saxophone. Other than this site, which I just recently joined and SOTW which I've been on for years, I don't go on any other social media. I actually like the 'rules' against discussing politics, religion, and other contentious topics. I certainly have rather strong opinions on those topics, but they have no place in a forum like this, thankfully.

I just read that YAGE that Pete mentioned. Kind of astounding. What that guy didn't seem to realize is that having free speech simply means you can't be thrown in prison for speaking your mind. It doesn't mean you won't be held accountable in other ways for disparaging or inflammatory statements (and maybe I've gone too far just pointing that out), or that a forum can't set rules for what topics or 'speech behavior' will be allowed or not allowed.

As to beginners leaving the forum, I haven't been on here long enough (just a matter of days at this point) to know who left, but many who start playing music unfortunately lose interest and give it up when they discover it's not so easy to become an overnight sensation. Also, as pointed out already, life can get in the way.
 
I love the idea of a forum like this where you can discuss music and horns with kindred spirits. I don't do much in the way of social media. I have an Instagram account and that's it.
 
It doesn't mean you won't be held accountable in other ways for disparaging or inflammatory statements (and maybe I've gone too far just pointing that out), or that a forum can't set rules for what topics or 'speech behavior' will be allowed or not allowed.
Agreed. We have a right of freedom of speech in general. Being a voluntary member of this or any forum implies "consent of the governed".
 
As to beginners leaving the forum, I haven't been on here long enough (just a matter of days at this point) to know who left, but many who start playing music unfortunately lose interest and give it up when they discover it's not so easy to become an overnight sensation. Also, as pointed out already, life can get in the way.
I am a fairly newcomer, too. Overall, this forum seems very stable, beginners posting their recordings are treated respectfully, critiqued respectfully. Basically, the responses towards beginner questions have been respectful. If topic has been covered before, a poster generally kindly directs them to that topic.

IMO, the Café management team keeps a good eye and gently corrects when posting strays ... and is a bit more stern when warranted.

If a poster's off-topic post has some merit, one may see their post moved to a more appropriate topic. I have yet to see this style of moderation in other forums I visit, which although unique helps to "keep peace within the family".

Although folk come and go for one reason or another, fortunately I would say that these YAGE's seem relatively low here.
 
beginners posting their recordings are treated respectfully, critiqued respectfully. Basically, the responses towards beginner questions have been respectful
It's always gratifying to help out a beginner. And remember, we were all beginners at one time. You could also argue that because there is always plenty more to learn no matter how experienced you are as a musician, so we all remain 'beginners' in a sense. There's a Zen term I read somewhere called 'beginner's mind'. I think the implication is to keep an open mind and be ready to learn something new at every opportunity.
 
@JSL I think you make a valid point about beginners. Many will start but then discover that either it's a lot tougher than they'd imagined or the instrument doesn't suit them. I do think that for many people it's the case of finding the 'right' instrument.

My own experiences points that way. My main instruments are cello and saxes. I also play the viola da gamba (viol) that suffers from a lack of people to play with as most of the music is written for consorts. I have electric bass guitars, but lack the opportunity to play them much. I play piano to a basic level and I'm learning the organ. I do have some recorders but I've not spent that much time on them.

One consequence of playing that lot is I have to read all four standard clefs - bass tenor, alto, and treble.

There are several instruments I've tried and I just didn't get on with them. I rented a standard 6 course lute from a luthier and had lessons for six months. I can read lute tablature, as some viol music (known as 'lyra way') uses it. Progress was horrifically slow and I decided it just didn't suit me.

I did want to play the viola as it's really useful to know. Getting an instrument with the right set-up is critical and I had a go with the string tutor at a summer school a few years ago. I just couldn't deal with the angle of the left arm and shoulder.

The other instrument which I really fancied having a go at was the highland bagpipes. I bought a practice chanter, and started lessons with a very good player/tutor. This was when I lived in Shropshire and he was over the border in Wales. He lived in a very grand house which had been in the family for 500 years... although the current house was more recent, being Jacobean... The fingering is really bizarre. I would still like to play but it's not an instrument to make quick progress on. The good news is that a practice chanter is cheap, so it doesn't cost a lot to find out.
 
I'm 100 % Rock & Roll Saxophone. I play a mix of "electric" blues, Rock & Roll, oldtime R & B, Soul ..... . Since late 70's I've just been thinking and and playing RockSax. Rock & Roll Saxophone didn't start with SOTW or Breakfastroom/Cafe Saxophone .... internet helped up to spread Rock & Roll Saxophone. But did the number of rocksaxophonists (beginners) increase with internet?


After many years on internet I also ask myself; "where are they now"?
 
I just read that YAGE that Pete mentioned. Kind of astounding. What that guy didn't seem to realize is that having free speech simply means you can't be thrown in prison for speaking your mind. It doesn't mean you won't be held accountable in other ways for disparaging or inflammatory statements (and maybe I've gone too far just pointing that out), or that a forum can't set rules for what topics or 'speech behavior' will be allowed or not allowed.
I treat any forum like visiting someone's house. Be polite: you're a guest. If you don't like the way things are run, then bugger off and open up your own house to the world. Personally, I like this house, and the way it is run. Kudos to all, because there's a lot of work goes on in the background to make things run smooth.
The above really resonated with me when Timbo posted it and is what I have in mind on other forums I use 😃.


Jx
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,317
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom