BalancedReaction
Member
I think Pete meant Grafton.??? Graftonite?
I think Pete meant Grafton.??? Graftonite?
Yes but that's a brand not a material It is made from acrylic). I do have a` Grafton and it seems to sound quite like most other saxophones.I think Pete meant Grafton.
I did. The Graftonite must be the more expensive oneI think Pete meant Grafton.
Can someone explain or point to something that explains the difference in acoustic effect between this and what material the horn is made of?bore surface finish
I can imagine that the internal bore of a wooden clarinet may have a roughish surface compared to a plastic one?explains the difference in acoustic effect between this and what material the horn is made of?
For a more polished sound?I can imagine that the internal bore of a wooden clarinet may have a roughish surface compared to a plastic one?
Yes.Can someone explain or point to something that explains the difference in acoustic effect between this and what material the horn is made of?
No question about that. Is often like that. But a ligature can clamp the reed in more than one way. Have you tried an Ed Daniels lig on a mouthpiece with big window?The function of ligatures is to clamp the reed, period.
Maybe so does porosity? Maybe that is why pads have reflectors (aka resonators)The surface finish has a minor effect, as roughness will tend to slightly disturb the standing waves,
If you have two ligatures, and you put them both on the same mouthpiece at the same point on the reed, they should sound and feel the same. If they do not, then at least one of the ligatures is defective.No question about that. Is often like that. But a ligature can clamp the reed in more than one way. Have you tried an Ed Daniels lig on a mouthpiece with big window?

And he'll probably sue anyone who says otherwise .....But the thing is that is so obviously wrong any sane person will ridicule it. We now know better. It is Elon Musk who does it.
I agree with just about everything that you said, I suppose that as far as ligatures go, you are probably right as well.I'll summarize what I believe, and what every qualified scientist who's studied this subject believes, based on data and the understanding of how single reed woodwinds create sound.
<SNIP>
The function of ligatures is to clamp the reed, period. A reed with a flat back, clamped to a mouthpiece with a flat table, cares not what kind of clamp is used. If the reed is convex on the back, the position and type of clamping can matter to tone and response, but it's highly unrepeatable and unreproducible; the solution is not more ligatures, but a better joint between the reed and mouthpiece table.
Maybe the issue is that the Rovner isn’t tight enough or needs oiling.My theory is that the leather (or is it synthetic?) band will hold the reed less rigidly than the metal ligature (leather will allow a bit of movement).
I wasn't really sure what the question was.I've read the whole thread and failed to find The Definitive Answer.
It's back to diligent practice, I guess 🙁
Your theory is correct. Use the metal ligature, it is repeatable. The flexible leather or synthetic material lig is not. If your sound is too bright, then change reeds or mouthpiece. Using a ligature to adjust the tonal spectrum of your sound is, in my opinion, a bad idea (TM). I want my equipment to work the same way every time.My theory is that the leather (or is it synthetic?) band will hold the reed less rigidly than the metal ligature (leather will allow a bit of movement).
This, fo me, is another reason to avoid flexible ligatures. They need to be tight to work properly. A metal two screw requires only a firm tightness, similar to the neck receiver screw.Maybe the issue is that the Rovner isn’t tight enough or needs oiling.
