Miscellaneous What about a CaféSax YouTube channel?

Would you engage with a Café YouTube channel

  • No. Nada. Waste of time.

    Votes: 2 10.0%
  • I'd subscribe on YouTube

    Votes: 13 65.0%
  • I'd like cross posting from my channel

    Votes: 3 15.0%
  • I'd be happy to have my xOTM posted there.

    Votes: 1 5.0%
  • I'd create YouTube content just for that.

    Votes: 2 10.0%
  • Sounds good... but... I'll wait for another initiative to crash and burn.

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Has potential

    Votes: 7 35.0%

  • Total voters
    20
I stopped participating in Y**T*** a few years ago, because their AI immediately generated a false positive, identify a Christian hymn published in the 1880's that I posted with me singing, using my midi loops on my keyboard as the backing tracks as copyrighted music belonging to worldwide major music companies. Then told me, that I could post but not monetize if I desired. (I don't care about monetization.)

Immediately I filed a complaint back that my content was from the Public Domain, the voice was my own and I used my own backing tracks. I never received a reply, but they removed the so called copyrights.

Those who want to post a YT link of them performing here is fine. However, I see YT as a can of worms personally. I do not like their position relying on AI exclusively without any human intervention, and requiring the poster to defend themselves.

Although the push is for forums to abandon their unique presence on the 'net and shift to social media, I would like to see the Cafe continue as-is. A move to YT could possibly shift posting traffic to YT, decreasing support for the Cafe forums.
 
A move to YT could possibly shift posting traffic to YT, decreasing support for the Cafe forums.
This worries me also. Google (for obvious reasons) favours YouTube vids in its search results. Some are OK but most IMO are awful. I know if some guy jumps onto the screen with “Hi guys! What’s up?” I just switch off
 
Although the push is for forums to abandon their unique presence on the 'net and shift to social media, I would like to see the Cafe continue as-is. A move to YT could possibly shift posting traffic to YT, decreasing support for the Cafe forums.

I never had heard of CS/TTS until a member at another forum (more active than here) recommended it when I created a thread about wind instruments.

Given the much larger audience at YT, it seems more likely to me that traffic would flow to CS rather than vice-versa. I'm not a fan of YT (or TikTok, etc.) as a business but until other video platforms like Peertube have the audience/reach, if you want to increase visibility it makes sense to go where the people are. Yeah, it's a bit of chicken and egg isn't it, but that's where we're at.
 
But a CafeSax channel could, of course, subscribe to someone else's channel / play list etc.

But why would we do that?

If it makes YT take notice, if not, don't.
I'm not poopooing the idea, just wondering how it would work (in our favour). I know very little about how Youtube works I'm just intrigued by this if you know what causes Youtube (or rather, Google) to take notice and then what they do.
 
Let's look at it from the other direction, we're wanting potential sax players to engage with the content and forum.

What sax content are we currently consuming on YouTube?

Tutorials? Performances? Reviews?

How would the cafe sax content be different from what is currently available?
 
This worries me also. Google (for obvious reasons) favours YouTube vids in its search results. Some are OK but most IMO are awful. I know if some guy jumps onto the screen with “Hi guys! What’s up?” I just switch off
Café Saxophone is an excellent forum for musician comeradery and provides a good educational experience for those wanting to improve their musicianship. YT is more about popularity and conformance by providing content that garners the most public views, which through YT advertisements, puts more money into Ggl's coffers. Thus, comments from the public can obscure an instrumentalist's comment, who have serious questions, plus posts are very limited to extent of content.

Several other forums that I was involved with (because of my interests) folded when they started a presence on social media. One was Brotherhood of the Ring, about a specific popular control line model aeroplane series but covered all aspects of control line model building and flight. As soon as they provided a presence on FBk, two years later, posters on the forum decreased to where they could no longer justify the costs.

Also, what might seem desireable by the posting community takes on a different perspective with the CS administrative team. I gather they already have their hands full in providing an excellent environment in CS. Managing a YT channel requires resources also, which may stretch resources thin, affecting their ability to administer CS. (CS is non-profit whereas Ggl is for profit.)
 
. I know very little about how Youtube works I'm just intrigued by this if you know what causes Youtube (or rather, Google) to take notice and then what they do.
I have no deep knowledge. I just have them impression that YT will prioritise pushing channels which have regular activity and engagement - views backed up likes, subscription etc.... from my limited experience.


As soon as they provided a presence on FBk,
I'm not sure yt would do that. But I do think FB is partially toxic.
 
I do like the idea but I think what it comes down to is

  • It can be advertised here, but how would people outside of the cafe either find it or engage with it?
  • How it could help get people to the Cafe (when there's good chance people would most likely comment on Youtube instead)
  • Someone needs to volunteer to do it (ie upload the videos)
 
With my limited experience:
- with sufficient content / engagement, it'd get pushed onto folks yt front page / under videos they view. The description / cards (when allowed) should link back here.
- you can actually turn comments off - select "made for kids"
- ...
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,315
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom