Mouthpieces Vintage mouthpiece program at Get-a-Sax

Very few things that are made by a casting process avoid further work by either hand or machine to get them as they should be.
Mainly it gets done by machine. The cylinders and heads Harley made in 1942 for my old chop never saw any hand work. Those destined for the racing motors had hours and hours of painstaking work to get the most power out of them.

I'll ask my mate who designs Reaction Injection Moulding machines and strange spinning machines for carbon fibre if the shape of a mouthpiece would let you make it that way. The machines are 'seriously' expensive! So even if it can be done you would have to be Yamaha to even think about it!

But having seen what comes out of a good RIM mahine - no handwork required.
There you go then. Prototyping, high performance and small runs tend to have hand finishes, scale production less or none because the volumes allow the eye-watering investment in tools and machinery.

I work in medical device development (though not as a mech eng), our prototypes are 3D printed or SLAed, then hand finished, or maybe silicone cast for a few dozen. A soft tool for IM is a few grand, probably adds £1 to each component made; a multi-cavity hard tool is much more, but you can make millions of components from it. Look at Lego - billions of parts to micrometre precision! No hand work there...

I’d be really interested to read a comparison of semi-unfinished* vs finished printed mouthpieces. You hear about some vintage pieces which sound great and look terribly finished - maybe it actually helps the sound in some way?

cheers

Jonathan

* you’d want the outside finished enough to be comfortable to play!
 
Ugly does not help the sound but looks are not the deciding factor of how a piece plays. Most of what you can see does not matter. Ive refaced many beautiful pieces that play like crap.
 
Just got off the phone after asking my mate the Professor at a 'well known' university.
For a product that does not need hand-finishing you use a Stereolithography Apparatus (SLA).
As you know, it is an expensive bit of kit!

A Reaction Injection Machine can also do it, you would use an insert to create the inside of the sax mouthpiece, and if the shape is too complex to get the insert out you use a low-melting point alloy and melt it out!
It is an expensive bit of kit!

A very smooth internal finish on a mouthpiece is probably bad. It is bad on the inlet manifold of an internal combustion engine, and probably bad on the internals of a saxophone. Hence Theo Wanne using his whizzo new 'sharkskin finish'. Perhaps he is just a petrol head that read the books by Smokey Yunick? By the 1970s the engine pros had stopped creating mirror finish innards, something amateurs still think is best to this day.

So, the rough-looking hand finished vintage mouthpiece may well sound really good partly because of that roughness!
And ditto a 3D printed mouthpiece.
 
There are other considerations when it comes to a hand finished piece. One has to ask if it is just hand finished to get rid of the machine marks or is it hand finished to take into account the relationship between facing length, baffle and performance.

When I make a piece its hand faced AND play tested. Very small changes are made in the facing and facing length to help ballance the piece tonally. Also response is taken into account. I assert that play testing is AS or MORE important than hand facing and that hand facing alone is not a guarntee of a great mouthpiece. Mass produced stuff is what it is...a widget. Some better than others.

Since a machine cant hear and feel I suggest most pieces from a machine do not attend to the making of music. Somehow I think this is what it is about.
 
I received my GS vintage copy. It's been very quick. It looks good. The table is very clean and smooth and it pops nicely.

The packaging is very good too. Unfortunately I am not in a position to play it yet. Family issues... :confused:🙁😡

IMG_20210303_105340653.webp
 
So, the rough-looking hand finished vintage mouthpiece may well sound really good partly because of that roughness!
And ditto a 3D printed mouthpiece.

FWIW, the Florida-era Otto Link STMs were very nicely finished regarding cosmetics. I know because that's when I bought mine (early '70s). I also know firsthand that they were not all faced well - I played literally dozens, fresh in their boxes, sitting in front of a table at Ponti's in NYC, searching for the best playing 7*. Of course, all those not-so-great STMs are now equally valuable because they are all "vintage".

There is little correlation between roughness/smooth and tone. Some makers tune the baffle until they like it and leave it there, others like to leave a mirror finish; some of the best pieces I have owned had chambers carved with a Dremel. What matters is how it plays.
 
Recreating "vintage mouthpieces" is fascinating topic. A lot of players want to "recreate" the sound of their favorite player(s) and getting a mouthpiece similar to the ones they used is a part of it, but it is just one element in the scope of things that go into sounding like the greats. D'Addario has been one of the companies at the forefront of taking accurate measurements of famous vintage mouthpieces and "machining" exact replicas down to .0005" accuracy. They can then mass produce them to sell at a reasonable price.

 
I had a look around... A very nice Makerbot 3D printer that can do 0.1mm layers is £7,000. The few 'special' one-off parts I might want can be custom made for a lot less than that though!

I have a Syos mouthpiece, you have to look closely to see the layers.
Well a £150 FDM printer will nominally do 0.1mm layers too, but a Makerbot machine will no doubt be far more accurate and reliable.

There are couple of issues with that though. Firstly mouthpiece facings need to be an order of magnitude more accurate than that. Secondly, although the machine's motion system may be very accurate and repeatable, melted plastic warps and shrinks as it cools so, if you want the best accuracy, fine tuning is required on an individual part basis.

A better bet would be something like this Phrozen Sonic Mini 4K 3D Printer or it's professional grade equivalent. Note that the 720ppi (or 35 microns) mentioned in the description is the resolution in X and Y. It is capable of 0.01mm resolution in the Z axis. So it's just about good enough for a mouthpiece facing but again these are the machine's capabilities and the vagaries of the material have to be taken into account too.

After much experimentation with this type of machine I can print a mouthpiece that plays straight off the printer. Plays but not great. This is only the case if I orient the part so that the flat part of the facing prints if horizontal and prints last thus conforming to the FEP film on the LCS screen. That is pretty flat if the FEP is in good condition (i.e. brand new) and there is no air trapped between the FEP and the LCD. This is with a consumer grade machine as referenced above. This orientation I am forced to use means that the top of the piece is very rough due to the large numbers of supports required and it requires hand finishing there, but this is just for cosmetic reasons. High accuracy isn't required there.

I can get a subjectively better quality and internally more accurate print by orienting the piece vertically but that way always requires hand finishing of the table and tip opening.
 
The C Melody mouthpiece is great, gone are all the inconsistences in tuning and evenness of tone.
This is an option I should keep in mind. When I am in the mood for C melody.

But I realize that I never posted about my GS Slant. It's very good. But it has an angle that makes it tiring when I play it. Since I don't play much these days, it's not an issue. A ne d be it's currently my go to mouthpiece on tenor. The next two are my Phil tone refaced Tonalin and my PPT 7*.
 
I realize that I never posted about my GS Slant. It's very good. But it has an angle that makes it tiring when I play it. Since I don't play much these days, it's not an issue. A ne d be it's currently my go to mouthpiece on tenor.
Hey @saxyjt , GS Slant is my go to Tenor mouthpiece, too. I particularly like how malleable it's tone is and how responsive it is. I have a number of tips from 5* to 8* depending on my mood. At the moment I prefer D'Addario Select Jazz reeds or Legere American Cut reeds, varying reed strength for the different tip sizes.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,717
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom