Very, very new to this so please be gentle

Duck

Member
Messages
63
Location
UK
Hi all,
Having had limited opportunity to screech to far (by the way please be a little more sensitive - so far I've seen 'duck with piles', 'strangled duck', 'duck strangled by foghorn'........) 😉anyway, back to the point - I can't work out where the correct positioning on the mouthpiece is?
I've noticed that I'm producing much stronger, cleaner notes if my lower lip takes in more of the mouthpiece, but this reduces my ability to tongue the notes cleanly and also seems to give wider scope for being out of tune?
Is there any descriptive method anyone can share with me so I can try to get mouthpiece positioning as close to 'right' as possible?
Many thanks
Rach
 
Hello Duck,

My apologies for my earlier reference. I am sure that you do not have piles. That aside, embouchure is something that seems to divide the sax community but Pete has a good artilce http://www.petethomas.co.uk/saxophone-embouchure.html which may help. Ultimately you need to experiment until you find something that suits you.
 
Somewhere or other I read to slip a business card between the reed and mouthpiece and where that stops is where the reed meets the table of the mouthpiece.
It is around this point your lower lip should be.

There was also a long post on Sax on the Web ages ago by a mouthpiece manufacturer (forgot the name) who suggested that most players do not take enough m/piece into the mouth.

IMHO to start don't take too much m/piece so you can control the reed better. As you develope you should be able to take more m/piece.
But Sax Starved's last line is so true.
 
Rache,

Get yourself a tutor/teacher, it will pay dividends long term.

Even if you only do it for the first 6 months at least you're headed in the right direction!

Trying to describe the embouchure is difficult even with the excellence of Pete's brilliant web resource.

Great looking pooch by the way!

Simon
 
The Mouthpiece manufacturer was Phil Barone, I believe. Do get a teacher as suggested - especially at the start.

Having just measured (these things are subjective) my Alto mouthpiece my own comfort zone is between 8mm and 11mm, if I focus on light teeth marks on mouthpiece guard. After a while you should know/feel when you are taking too little or too much in.

Kind regards
Tom 8)
 
I know of one in Larry Teals book 'The art of saxophone playing' and I know there are writings with a different outlook than his so...

As all the previous posts suggest, everyone settles on their own embouchure of which there is no right or wrong.
I think as long as you avoid the extremes you are in the ball park.

From your post, a compromise between the strong clear tones and tongue control and tuning is your personal trade off and of course its very common.
Get comfortable between the too much/too little, too tight/too loose, lots of bottom lip/not enough bottom lip and eventually you will make any adjustment you need, more sub conciously.

Some great players have some really quirky embouchures and general styles though.
Sanborn, Young and the list would go on and on.
 
TomMapfumo wrote:
Having just measured (these things are subjective) my Alto mouthpiece my own comfort zone is between 8mm and 1.1mm, if I focus on light teeth marks on mouthpiece guard.

Kind regards
Tom 8)

How do you measure so accurately, to .1 of a mm. Are you using vernier calipers, or do you have some sort of micrometer? :laugh:
 
In my experience, most players with problems take in too much mouthpiece.

But I don't think there is any way to measure what is the right amount.

A good teacher can gauge that, based on your physical characteistics, mouthpiece and style of music.

Too many variables to make rules..
 
Hi Rach,

I am also very new to this sax playing lark and my teacher told me that it would be a good idea to change my mouthpiece, the one my sax came with was even more basic than basic. I have now got a new one (selmer c* - so nothing hugley expensive or fancy but much better than I had) and it has made a massive difference, He also said that every time I get a good sound to try to remember where my embouchure is.

Do get yourself a teacher - had I not had one I would have been getting more & more frustrated at the sound I was making thinking it was all me.

Hope this helps
Emma
 
Thank you all very much for your input. I seem to be doing a bit better now and am actually making some fairly sweet sounds at times!! I think some of the problem is tiredness. I tend to do much better very soon after picking the sax up than I am doing 20 minutes down the line. I find that at this point, even when I feel I haven't altered position one iota, I can make some truly remarkable noises! 🙂
One strange thing that happens is a sudden inability to get notes out at all, almost as though the sax fairy has decided to bung the neck up! I have to completely reposition and start over when this happens - is this me or pretty common? The other thing which is bugging me is an inability to play a straight low c without going down the scale to it - presumably this will come when I've got more of a feel for a something near to correct embouchure?
Anyhow, back to it! Once again, many thanks for all your help
Rach
 
Embouchure is the key to your problems. As a beginner your mouth is not yet trained to hold the correct position for any length of time, which is why you lose your ability to hit notes correctly after playing for a while. The more you practice the longer you will be able to play. Don't worry, it comes quite quickly if you do a little each day. Hitting the low C is probably a sympton of the same problem, although I did find that experimenting with different reed strengths and mouthpieces definitely helped. What reed/mouthpiece/ligature are you playing?
 
Duck, if you are only just starting out your embouchure will get tired quickly, and strange noises will come out of the horn. Keep at it though, the more you do it the longer you will last.

Oh cripes, I've just had a Leslie Phillps moment :erm:

Is this the first time Leslie Phillips has been mentioned on this forum?
 
I'm using the mouthpiece which came with the sax - a Yamaha 4C and was advised to use the 1.5 reed to start. I have a 2.5 reed as well though (Rico Royals). Any advice on that side?

Thanks Bob. No doubt very good advice! 😉
 
The 2.5 might be a bit strong right now, but no harm in trying. You'll probably get a lot of breathy sound and not much else (and a very tired embouchure), but give it a go. Then stop if you're not ready to play it yet.

How long have you played the 1.5 reed? They can soften up quite quickly so you might find it's just 'worn out' and closing up. Perhaps get yourself a couple more 1.5's and a couple of 2's.

Oh, and the low C, that'll take a bit of time. If you can get to it by running down the instrument that's a good start. Run down to it, then blow the C for as long as you can manage whilst playing about with the embouchure to see the effect it has. You'll want it quite loose to get those low notes.

Phil
 
Hi Duck, Phil has hinted on the answer, your 1.5 reed may be getting a bit soft, so maybe going to a 2 might help. Playing long tones will aid your embouchure development. Simply play a note and hold it for as long as possible. Listen while you play and aim for the sweetest and steadiest tone you can achieve. Again like Phil said, while playing these long tones, try to alter the sound you make by altering your technique. This also helps to alleviate the boredom factor. Very soon you'll be effortlessly breathing sweet sound into your horn. 8)
 
The other thing to think about is what you do with reeds. Many recommend having several reeds on the go, soaking them before use, but rotating them. For example having 4 reeds on the go means that each reed is only used one day in four, allowing them to dry out and not become too soft. If you use one reed at a time they usually last for a shorter time and can be damaged/softened by the amount of saliva they experience.

I invested in a Vandoren reed holder (holds 4 reeds) some time ago and my reeds are now playable for much longer - 6 months or so is quite common.

I think that a step up to some 2 strength reeds would be worth trying, as they will always come into play at some stage of your development.

Finally, given your experience it may be best to practice for no more than 10 minutes at a time and take a good break in between - you should be surprised at how your embouchure develops.

Kind regards
Tom 8)
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,509
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom