Theory & Impro Using patterns in jazz impro

But practicing them makes sure that one can respond nimbly in the moment.
On a totally mundane note - I find patterns useful to avoid stumbling, particularly when "crossing the break" and up high. Not every sequence is scales and arpeggios, after all.
Whether from the page, by ear or imagination; it's nice not to trip up.

Sure, the sax is maybe the not the most troublesome wind instrument, break wise.
 
I'll have to give some more thought on using patterns. I guess I do it on occasion, but not to any great extent. On this point, though:
If someone else in the group plays the same "improvised" solo each and every time, I'm all for it so long as it entertains. However, on a personal level... and this is maybe something I've been focusing on in just the last ten years or so... I seek to break out of patterns. True improv. On the spot. In the moment. And what you feel. Putting away your best licks.
What I sometimes (but not always) do with certain tunes that I play on a regular basis when taking a solo is to play the same pre-conceived solo, that I know fits and works well, on the first chorus, then improvise on the next chorus or two, depending on how long the solo will be. And there are plenty of tunes where I almost never play the same thing when improvising. Of course, it's not really improvising if you are repeating a given solo. I will say if I improvise something I really like, I'm not going to totally abandon it forever. I'll either repeat it the next time or play an altered version of it.
 
While I find patterns very worthwhile for practice, I think direct application of them on the gig is not very desirable. A good description of this can be found in "Practice Notebooks of Michael Brecker". Appendix IV, "Michael Brecker's Practice Method", is a very good example of a rudimentary way to make a simple pattern, 7-1-4-m3 (or 1-2-5-4, it depends on harmonic application) multi-useful as a variety of practice exercises over multiple tonalities that can work their way into a solo on a (likely) subconscious level.

That Appendix reads like it's a synopsis (if not transcription) of a clinic he gave at William Paterson University in 1995. Key quotes as a takeaway for me is "When I learn a pattern -- these really are basically patterns -- after I sort of learn it I try and forget it." "Improvising for me is kind of a misnomer; I love to improvise, but a lot of it comes from making sentences out of words. I spend time sort of learning words and making sentences out of them." From what I can tell, maybe half of his solo content is permutation of 4-note groups ("words") strung together into cohesive phrases ("sentences"). I'd give my left nut to play like him, but I never will, nobody will I think; but I like where he's coming from. He doesn't describe how to play something canned. He describes learning to speak more fluently.

I bought the Practice Notebooks as a PDF from someplace online in the past 6 months or so, I forget exactly where, but if you google it you'll find it. Something like $25, well worth it.
 
I don't think anyone here is advocating for the "don't study any music that isn't yours, it will pollute your artistry!" position, although I've sadly encountered it plenty of times, inevitably by musicians who never end up being very good, and whose writing/improvising sounds... ironically and/or predictably... extremely derivative and boring. Because, of course, they have internalized tons of music on a surface level through cultural osmosis. And since they never studied deeper, never expanded their melodic/rhythmic/harmonic vocabularies past a superficial point, those superficial cliches are all they have, at best.
Lot of meat to the above, and quite frankly, that last sentence hits home for me. I've long felt a sort of guilt that I never put in the time and effort to shed like I know many here do. I've never been a practice player and pretty much only take my horns out at home if I have to learn a new tune or get my lip in shape for work. Funny thing is though, that even when I'm not playing I've got music in my head. Like almost always. Don't really know how to explain it, but even after a long break from playing, when I get back to it I'm almost refreshed. Like I had these things brewing inside that I can now get out. And in some strange way... I'm actually better for the time off. Crazy, I know... but then I read that last sentence above and I have to ask myself am I just getting by on a pretty melody with a riff here and there to make people smile? And you know what? Maybe I am. And even if true... I'm good.

While I find patterns very worthwhile for practice, I think direct application of them on the gig is not very desirable.

What I don't want to sound like, is if I'm playing a method book rather than a song. And not surprisingly, that's how I feel when I listen to most players today. So I have embraced my inner laziness, excused it with an ear for melody and making someone who knows absolutely nothing about music... smile.
 
As I said above, I think this is an inherent tension in improvised music. If you insist you'll never play anything you have played before, you risk sounding bad. If you insist you'll never play anything you haven't fully worked out in the practice room, you risk sounding like you're playing out of an exercise book .

The issue is made more severe by the demand for technical virtuosity in African American improvised music, especially since the 1940s. The only way you get serious technical virtuosity is to practice technical exercises, A LOT. It's inevitable that the phrases and patterns you're practicing to gain facility on the instrument, will become familiar in your ear and fingers and will tend to creep into your composing (which is what improvisation is, done on the spot). But if you refuse to practice technical facility, then you box yourself in to playing just what you can play; and if there's not a lot in that tool box, then you end up sounding boring because you just play the same two solos over and over.

As a general-case solution I would say the key element is your aural IMAGINATION. If you can imagine interesting things to play when improvising, then you can either play them with the technique you have, or you can't, and if you can't, then you practice technical things till you can . The driver has to be the aural imagination rather than the finger patterns you have on the shelf. This is a difficult discipline and the more technical facility you have the more you have to focus on the music and letting the technical facility being something that is a tool, but isn't itself the music.

Some examples:

Coltrane was an example of spectacular technique. But he himself admitted that his fingers had a tendency to try to drive the bus rather than his imagination. And later in his life he moved increasingly away from the kinds of virtuoso displays and more toward trying to explore sound and tone and music for themselves .

Mingus famously HATED to hear his sidemen play stuff that sounded like they'd prepared it in advance and weren't responding in the moment. But you'd better believe guys like Dolphy Jordan Byard etc.put in MAJOR hours with the exercise books working all the permutations of patterns so that they could play ANYTHING that their aural imaginations called on them to play.

And finally, one of my greatest inspirations ever, Rahsaan Roland Kirk. Kirk had technique and plenty to spare. But a very large fraction of the time, he was playing purely from inspiration. The freedom of his conceptions is maybe unmatched by anyone working on the side of jazz with chord changes, tonality, etc. Again, someone who obviously had to spend thousands of hours mastering his instrument(s), but then insisted on playing what his imagination came up with.

That's the essence and underlying fundamental principle of African American improvised music. All of us who perform this stuff are working toward it.
 
Speaking strictly of patterns, I do practice a couple of diminished scale patterns that I like. So far, they haven't popped out in my solos, but maybe at some point they will. They work well over dominant chords & ii-V changes. The diminished scale lends itself well to various patterns. And to an extent pentatonic scale patterns can be effective.

I think the best way to approach these patterns, assuming you find some you like, is to practice & internalize them, then let them happen naturally while improvising if they fit well into the melodic flow.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,071
Messages
578,552
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom