Saxophones Upgrading from a student sax

I started playing in January on a Hanson SA-5 - I had real trouble using the octave key. It felt like I was having to move my thumb up and across, instead of just sliding it over - a real 'mechanical' feeling. When I upgraded (GAS) to a 2nd hand student Yani the difference was amazing, so easy to use. This may or may not have been to do with the setup, but the shape of the key is significantly different (the Yani curves round a lot lower - the Hanson was more 'above' the thumb rest). Just my 2p... 🙂

My problem with the octave key isn't about how my thumb moves as I seem to be able to manage without thinking about it too much. My problem was (according to the repairer) that the octave key wasn't opening the apertures enough (not sure if this is the right word). He has fixed it for me and it's better at the moment although I'm still having problems with G. I was frustrated that the instrument needed repair so soon after purchase and was told it's because it's a cheaper instrument and that it will need adjusting more often than on a better instrument. Just want something more robust which hopefully will sound better as well. I probably have GAS but I've got some cash so why not. Just want to make sure I chose wisely.
 
My problem with the octave key isn't about how my thumb moves as I seem to be able to manage without thinking about it too much. My problem was (according to the repairer) that the octave key wasn't opening the apertures enough (not sure if this is the right word). He has fixed it for me and it's better at the moment although I'm still having problems with G. I was frustrated that the instrument needed repair so soon after purchase and was told it's because it's a cheaper instrument and that it will need adjusting more often than on a better instrument. Just want something more robust which hopefully will sound better as well. I probably have GAS but I've got some cash so why not. Just want to make sure I chose wisely.

Even mid-high range new instruments can need setting up properly.

One advantage of BW is that this is done before sale (I think before the dealer gets them).

But if it's playing OK now, think twice. What you get as a step up now may not be what you want in 12 months time when you've progressed more and learnt more about the different options. That said there are quite a lot of BW fans on the forum who don't seem to be feeling the need to upgrade.

But I still think it's worth a trip to one of the dealers to see what's available and get a second opinion.
 
Spot on about upgrades and BW horns. I love my BW sopranos and not tempted to spend £2000+ for an incy wincy improvement, if any.

If it were not for GAS many firms would go out of business. BTW Trevor Jones in Bristol - www.trevorjonesltd.co.uk, who stock the Buffet 400 saxes, are open to "sensible" offers, as they are certainly feeling the pinch. I can easily imagine getting a £100 or so off a Buffet 400, which seems a very serious rival to the BW Alto (Receiving many excellent reviews online). If I was looking for a new Alto at under £1000 it would probably be my first choice - Matt Lacquer at £840!). Tenor wise I'd go for the BW.
 
My problem with the octave key isn't about how my thumb moves as I seem to be able to manage without thinking about it too much. My problem was (according to the repairer) that the octave key wasn't opening the apertures enough (not sure if this is the right word). He has fixed it for me and it's better at the moment although I'm still having problems with G. I was frustrated that the instrument needed repair so soon after purchase and was told it's because it's a cheaper instrument and that it will need adjusting more often than on a better instrument. Just want something more robust which hopefully will sound better as well. I probably have GAS but I've got some cash so why not. Just want to make sure I chose wisely.

Hanson have a 5 year warranty and servicing on all instruments. It should have gone back to them with details of the problem!!!
There is at least one other member with a Hanson SA 5, and I think that they are happy with it. If they read this perhaps they would like to comment on it?


John.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hanson have a 5 year warranty and servicing on all instruments. It should have gone back to them with details of the problem!!!
There is at least one other member with a Hanson SA 5, and I think that they are happy with it. If they read this perhaps they would like to comment on it?


John.

My sax is from Cranes in Cardiff (their own make) not a Hanson (that was a post from someone else), and it probably should have gone back but my repairer is nearer to me and by the time I paid petrol & parking it didn't make sense to make the trip. Thanks anyway.
 
Moving, Sliding? There should be no movement of the thumbs position on the button. It is a rolling motion, up (Hanson) across (Yani).

John.

Ok, so I'm bad at describing it as well as doing it!

The upward rolling motion on the Hanson was what I found difficult. Teacher thought it was badly designed too. I won't tell you what the tech thought... ;-)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hanson have a 5 year warranty and servicing on all instruments. It should have gone back to them with details of the problem!!!

The warranty no longer applies to second-hand instruments, they've changed their policy. As I discovered after buying one second-hand and phoning Hanson up to arrange a service...
 
Ok, so I'm bad at describing it as well as doing it!

The upward rolling motion on the Hanson was what I found difficult. Teacher thought it was badly designed too. I won't tell you what the tech thought... ;-)

Hi Steve,
I wasn't being critical of your description ;}
As for the key being above the thumb rest, lots of well thought of saxes, Selmer BAs for example, have it there with no probs. I'm sorry that you had difficulty with it, but you are sorted now :thumb:

John.
 
Just thought I'd let you all know I splashed out on a Yani A901 and part exed my Yamaha AS100. I bought it from Trevor Jones in Bristol. He had a fantastic deal on with cost of £1800 and minimum part ex of just under £300, so total cost of £1536. I tried out a Yamaha 62 and a Jupiter 769, but there was absolutely no contest. The sound of the Yani is superb and I can see myself keeping it for many years to come. If I'd gone for a cheaper model I would have probably wanted to upgrade again in a couple of years and with such a good deal I couldn't leave it in the shop. Now I have to keep playing for years so I can do it justice! One very happy sax beginner!!!

If you're interested just type in Trevor Jones and Bristol and you can see all the deals he has on saxes. Well worth a look.

Thanks everyone.

P.S. I do still have a little problem with G's but my teacher believes it's a result of being unlucky with my saxes to date and is now a "mental" problem. When I relax or run up to them it's no problem, but starting out on a G is another matter. I can solve this when I use my diaphragm so I just need a bit of time and practice and with my Yani I want to practice all the time, just life, housework and my son gets in the way.
 
Enjoy the new sax. I'm not envious, honest... lol

Forget about the Gs. It'll become a non-event. Especially when you listne to the wonderful sound of the new Yani!

Ditto.. I discovered last week that a friend from choir (he a keyboard player and oboist as well) bought his wife a new Yani A991 for her as a present last year.... Any benefactors out there?
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,073
Messages
578,619
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom