Intonation Tuning: where do I start?

Bernie

Little chickety boom, one stick, you dig?
Messages
894
If I understand correctly, when the low notes of a sax are in tune, the high notes will be out. So my question is, which note should I use for tuning?
 
The saxophone is an imperfect instrument that doesn't play in tune. This adds to it's musical personality and unique charm. The high register is easy to pull down. The low register less so if at all. Tune alto to A with the F# fingering. Check the octave.

Mouthpiece position is crucial. The simple act of pushing in will raise pitch and pulling out will lower it. That's the simple bit. Having said that, pulling out and lipping up or pushing in and lipping down may give better results.The saxophone is very sensitive to mouthpieces as far as intonation goes. Matching mouthpiece and reed to player and instrument can be frustrating.

There's much reading on the subject on here.

Best advice is to get it close and just play. It's surprising how sweet an instrument can sound when playing that appears way off against a tuner.
 
I like to tune to low F# (A concert for the alto). Then I check the F# in the 2nd octave both with and without the octave key, and then I finger low B and overblow to the 3rd harmonic which is the same F#2. If they all match, then I know the mouthpiece in in the optimum position. It is important to remember that once this is accomplished only one note on the saxophone is guaranteed to be in tune.

There is another aspect to tuning that you rarely hear talked about, and that is matching pitch. This works best if you have two players playing the same type of instrument, but can be done using a keyboard or tuner as well. One is designated as the "fixed pitch" and the other player matches that pitch by "lipping' (humoring) his/her own pitch to tune out the beats on unisons and octaves. More experienced players do this instantly and automatically, you might say instinctively. What it boils down to is tuning is all about listening. The sooner one puts away the tuner with the dial and starts to tune aurally rather than visually, the better the results are going to be.
 
There is another aspect to tuning that you rarely hear talked about, and that is matching pitch. This works best if you have two players playing the same type of instrument, but can be done using a keyboard or tuner as well. One is designated as the "fixed pitch" and the other player matches that pitch by "lipping' (humoring) his/her own pitch to tune out the beats on unisons and octaves.
Yes, I do that. Then you adjust the mouthpiece position so that the lip/jaw pressure that works is the most comfortable. I tend to tune on left-hand-only notes so I can hold the mouse button down with the right.

Completely agree about listening. Your tuning is only ever going to be as good as your ear.
 
If I understand correctly, when the low notes of a sax are in tune, the high notes will be out. So my question is, which note should I use for tuning?
It seems logical to me to tune to A440. Which on alto sax is top line F#. I hope that is correct, some one with more experience please tell me if I'm doing the correct thing.


I didn't read what is above, I suggest moderator delete this.

Edit done much later.(2300gmt)
Thought I had asked a draft question 'cos I did not read the thread properly, but having read the following post maybe not so draft.
 
Last edited:
It seems logical to me to tune to A440. Which on alto sax is top line F#. I hope that is correct, some one with more experience please tell me if I'm doing the correct thing.
There are lots of players who do tune to F#2 (A440). There is nothing wrong with that. In my experience it works better to tune the lower register and then lip some of the high notes down as needed rather than to tune the high register and end up having to lip some of the low notes up which is not as easy.
 
Hey,

Sax intonation depends on how good one can work with the different resistances you have for every note, how good you can control your airstream, how good your voicing is.
If you cannot "fill" the horn let's say on low D, middle D will be terribly sharp.

First of all, you have to find your pitch center:
http://www.steveduke.net/articles/mouthpiece.shtml

With my students, I found it useful to tune with drones:
http://davidvaldez.blogspot.co.at/2010/09/drone-exercises.html
www.dronetonetool.com
http://raschwartz.wix.com/the-tuning-cd

Cheers,
Guenne
 
More experienced players do this instantly and automatically, you might say instinctively. What it boils down to is tuning is all about listening. The sooner one puts away the tuner with the dial and starts to tune aurally rather than visually, the better the results are going to be.

I've been playing traditional Irish fiddle, which presents intonation challenges all of its own. I think my ears are pretty well tuned in, but also perhaps quite tolerant
 
There are lots of players who do tune to F#2 (A440). There is nothing wrong with that. In my experience it works better to tune the lower register and then lip some of the high notes down as needed rather than to tune the high register and end up having to lip some of the low notes up which is not as easy.

Hi jbtsax,

I've been told above that it is incorrect to say "if the low notes are in tune the high notes will be out". But what you write seems to suggest that this in fact correct. Or am I misunderstandng something?

I'm editing this to say I think I understand better now, thanks to Guenne's link.
 
Last edited:
Hi Guenne,

Those were great links. I think I understand the tuning issue a lot better now. Drones play a big role in the Irish music I have been playing, I am going to enjoy using those cello drones for sax practice.
 
You could always take my approach to tuning.
When I got the sax I pushed the m/p on halfway and played it for three years.
Then I bought a Tascam which had a tuning facility and played most of the notes, moved the m/p about a thirtysecond of an inch so on average several around the middle showed in tune.
Check it if I remember when I change the reed.
 
Hi jbtsax,

I've been told above that it is incorrect to say "if the low notes are in tune the high notes will be out". But what you write seems to suggest that this in fact correct. Or am I misunderstandng something?

I'm editing this to say I think I understand better now, thanks to Guenne's link.
That statement is an over generalization. There are some notes in the saxophone's upper register that have a tendency to be a bit sharp such as high G and quite sharp such as high A and C#. Using one of these notes to tune to A440 would require pulling the mouthpiece out which would make the low register slightly flat.

Determining the best "length" of the saxophone depends upon many different variables such as the air temperature, the stiffness of the reed, the volume inside the mouthpiece, the player's embouchure and oral cavity, etc. Setting that "length" is part of an overall compromise as well since moving the mouthpiece on or off affects the short tube notes proportionally more than the long tube notes. It is all relative. Playing "in tune" like singing is all about listening and matching pitch. Finding the best spot on the cork for the mouthpiece just gets you into the ball park, the rest is up to you.
 
Last edited:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,384
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom