Playing the saxophone Transposing Eb EZ

prelude1

Member
Messages
66
I'm sure all of you that are well versed know this. This is for beginners that struggle.....my main instrument is guitar. I play a lot of lead and can move between major and minor easily.... What I noticed is that the transposed note is the relative minor....root note....G relative minor is Em so transposed G is E....EZ stuff for you accomplished players..... but maybe this will help some beginners like me.
 
To transpose from Concert, for an Eb horn, up a major 6th or down a minor 3rd.
Might be wise for beginners to learn how we think.
The relative minor is how my 50 years of guitar brain works and gets me to the exact same place…..but i agree if one is a a total beginner….im 74. Lol im going with how my brain works.
Cheers.
 
As someone who has had to play an Eb bari part from a concert pitch bass part, and I've had to play cello (concert pitch bass clef) from an Eb part.... you get used to having to shove up or down a minor third and you pray that if you're playing bari from a cello part it doesn't wander into tenor clef as all bets are then off...
 
Ok guys.... This is a single issue....hypotheticals don't apply....I stated Eb... Of course it won't work for Bb..duh!.. relative minor is exactly the same as 3rd minor down....semantics...sorry I posted!!! Just trying to help those that struggle with transposing... This helped me immensely.
 
sorry I posted!!
I'm not. I never linked the 6 of relative minor and Eb transposing. So that's fun.
I'm not sure anyone's convinced that it's the way to go for 99% of beginners... For a start, they could go wildly wrong for Bb 😉.
But, either way, it doesn't really matter; what ever way you work it out is only a steppingstone - after some time and practice, you won't even think about it.
 
What I noticed is that the transposed note is the relative minor....root note....G relative minor is Em so transposed G
That should work for me

I'm not a beginner, but whilst I can transpose a whole tone up to Bb tenor in me head, I've not found a quick shortcut to Eb sax... Hitherto I've laboured down from concert, four half steps, one step at a time
 
Nice thing about an Eb instrument is that if you have a Concert pitch bass clef part, just play it as if it were treble clef and add 3 sharps. I've done this with an Eb bari sax, play a trombone or bass clef baritone. Only thing if using an alto sax is that you'll be playing an octave up. But at least you are playing.
 
I too, was once a guitar player. And I soon learned the 'relative minor' of many major chords. Both with exactly the same key signature and notes but with a different 'tonic' (the ground note for the chord or scale). So C->Am, G->Em, F->Dm. D->Bm, etc.

At a recent 'jazz improvisation workshop' we were asked to decide if - given a 'key signature' - the melody was written in the major key or the relative minor key. The clues were - of course - in the starting and ending notes. The 'rhythm section' provided confirmation by either playing in the major key (starting, for example in a tonic 'C' chord) or the relative minor key (starting in the relative minor tonic 'Am' chord),

Since then, I've learned that (on any instrument) the 6th note in any major scale is the 'tonic' of the 'relative minor' scale. And that the 3rd note in any minor scale is the 'tonic' of the relative major' scale.

As an ex-guitarist and now tenor saxophonist, I (happily!) don't have to think too much about major and relative minor scales. Except when playing with a 'concert pitch' band on tenor sax (transposing chords/scales to tenor sax 'on the fly'), when I sometimes have to play outside my 'comfort zone'. Many (on the fly transpositions) from a major to a relative minor scale are still familiar to me from playing guitar.

But there are still a few 'on-the fly' transpositions that I'm still learning to play more fluently. Such as concert E/Em (F# on tenor) and concert B/Bm (C# on tenor). I admit that I would struggle to find the relative minor scales for these scales 'on the fly'. Thankfully all (concert C) major and minor chords are indicated in the vocal sheets (which are the only sheets we have!
 
Last edited:
A few times with our trombone ensemble missing a 4th bone, played the 4th trombone or bass bone on the bari sax by playing bass clef as treble adding 3 sharps, or, the band library was missing the bari part so librarian substituted that on hand, a bass clef part, so know from experience.
 
I find it easier to just learn the concert pitch of fingerings. One note at a time. There's only 12.
No need to jump through mental hoops. Just play as written.

The confused looks I get when handing back an Eb sheet and asking for concert, reveals it to be an uncommon practice.

It does simplify things though.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,427
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom