Playing the saxophone Transcribing/playing by ear

Mix O Lydian

Member
Messages
219
Location
England
When people say "transcribe" a solo what does that generally mean? Is it sufficient just to listen and play by ear or should I write it down as well?
I can read/write music, but nothing too complex!
 
As @mizmar says, the literal meaning does require writing it down.

The other thing is ear learning which can be a very valuable exercise musically but shouldn't strictly be called transcribing.

Up with the correct usage of language and down with free for all.

Rhys
 
Yes, it’s the full house meaning really, so that I could give a transcription to another musician to play regardless of whether they had heard it before.

But, we usually talk about transcriptions/transcribing in relation to learning, so it can be whatever suits you of course. Ideally it will be enough information that you know roughly what it means if you came back to it a few months later.

It can be simplified rhythmically, maybe a basic outline. Get from it what you find to be useful. You won’t be publishing it as a book of transcriptions, so it doesn’t need to be perfect.
 
This is what I've learned:

  • To transcribe a solo you need to transcribe the whole song.
  • Write out the chord changes. A one or two chord 12-bar blues is fine if you never been transcribing before.
  • Figure out the bass line for the form and the chords.
  • Count up how many measures you are going to transcribe.
  • Listen to what the person you want to transcribe is playing.
  • Write it down.
I have never done this. I tried once .... .

I listened to reel to reel recordings by lowering the speed to half and then I also played one octave down. Pitch .... what is that?

I more transform songs, riffs, solos ....... . I can't play like the recording artists.

Trascribing is more or less to write down the dots. I try to write down words and phrases. "Play a high G and drop it down to low G and try to sound as a full ochestra " ..... I think this information is import as well.

Playing by ear. Sometimes, but 90% I learn by ear and play from what I remember what I learned by ear.
 
Transcribing is great for various reasons. It is obviously good for ear training and as such it may not really matter whether you write it down or memorise it. Memorising is of course also good for memory training but is most useful when you recognise recurring patterns.

The other hugely beneficial thing though is analysis. I did an article on this as it makes little sense as an impro tool to just transcribe without digging into what is going on. See here (please accuse the clickbaity title)

 
Transcribing is great for various reasons. It is obviously good for ear training and as such it may not really matter whether you write it down or memorise it. Memorising is of course also good for memory training but is most useful when you recognise recurring patterns.

The other hugely beneficial thing though is analysis. I did an article on this as it makes little sense as an impro tool to just transcribe without digging into what is going on. See here (please accuse the clickbaity title)

Ooooo, thanks, I shall have a read!
 
Transcribing technically means to write down.

But I've found recently NOT writing it out makes me properly learn whatever it is I'm "transcribing". Playing it over and over to the record, getting all the nuance of phrasing and so on, thinking about the notes in relation to the harmony at that point in time and internalising it is key for absorbing that for your own improvisation.

With transcriptions I've done this process with, I can still play those transcriptions entirely from memory, and I can work it in other keys easier. For those I just worked out and wrote down, I can't.

So I would work on getting the thing internalised completely and then write it out, and you'll find that there will be rhythmic things that notation doesn't quite cut it for and so on. But having it written out can be useful for analytical work on the phrase that you're learning alongside the harmony.
 
Transcribing is great for various reasons. It is obviously good for ear training and as such it may not really matter whether you write it down or memorise it. Memorising is of course also good for memory training but is most useful when you recognise recurring patterns.

The other hugely beneficial thing though is analysis. I did an article on this as it makes little sense as an impro tool to just transcribe without digging into what is going on. See here (please accuse the clickbaity title)

Great article, Pete. First time I've read it so thanks for sharing! I especially valued your examples of analysing solo's!
 
So I would work on getting the thing internalised completely and then write it out, and you'll find that there will be rhythmic things that notation doesn't quite cut it for and so on. But having it written out can be useful for analytical work on the phrase that you're learning alongside the harmony.
Transcribing is great for various reasons. It is obviously good for ear training and as such it may not really matter whether you write it down or memorise it. Memorising is of course also good for memory training but is most useful when you recognise recurring patterns.

The other hugely beneficial thing though is analysis. I did an article on this as it makes little sense as an impro tool to just transcribe without digging into what is going on.
Thank you both! I will transcribe aurally, which will be beneficial for my ear training and playing with others. But if while listening, as often happens, certain patterns or phrases "speak" to me, whether on their own or within the context of the whole piece, I would attempt to write them down for further analysis.

I have been playing along to pre transcribed solos and learning how to play them off by heart. This is helping me familiarise myself with the language and articulation and I feel more open to learning a few simple solos by ear now, compared to three months ago.
 
FWIW, my 'weekly jazz improv group' leader mentioned something yesterday that I found useful.

Transposing developed 'improvs' on a 'Blues Scale' to a different key is not too difficult It just means learning the 'Blues Scale' in different keys. The same applies to the Pentatonic (and many other) scales.

His point was to learn to recognise similarities between different tunes, Not in terms of 'idental chords'
but in terms of relatively identical 'chord interval sequences' (with some variations)

The example he gave was 2 tunes that we've been learning to improvise on: Bernie's Tune and Cantaloupe Island. He pointed out that in the AABA form of Bernie's Tune, the A section (Em7 ->C7) was the equivalent interval to many of the chord sequences in Cantaloupe Island (Gm7 -> E♭7)
 
When people say "transcribe" a solo what does that generally mean?
I had to look up a word I've been using for many years!

Transcribe;
  • kopiera - (copy, duplicate, replicate, pattern)
  • spela in - (produce, record, screen, shoot)
  • överföra - (communicate, convey, infect, transfer, transfuse, transmit)
  • skriva av - (duplicate, extract)
  • återge - (record, reflect, render)
  • transkribera - (transliterate)
  • ta upp på band - (transcibe)
What was I really doing as a young Rock & Roll Saxophone enthusiast when I recorded Creedende Clearwater Revival songs and played along with John Fogerty's tenor sax? I recorded the whole songs 10-15 times to have the band rolling instead of re-winding. I just learned to play what I heard. The Tandberg reel to reeel I used was steady so I think I was close when it came to the right pitch? I didn't write anything down, I transfered it direct to my brain - memory - muscles. Lots of repeats. The neccessary repetition is important in RockSax. Not only when you are playing, also in the learning process?
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,062
Messages
578,393
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom