Miscellaneous Touchy!

Dave Dunn

Member
Messages
245
Location
South Australia
Screenshot_20220302-232851_YouTube.jpg
I just came across this! :headscratch:
Some people are seem a little bit touchy, a little bit full of themselves, and a little bit desperate for content!!!!
Come on Dave, I'm allowed to have an opinion! No need to get your frilly little pink panties in a knot! 😛
I'm an honest person, I speak what I feel, the comment was definitely not made to get it featured on your channel! 😀 I'd just like some different bloody songs mate, does the world need another recording of Giant Steps? I can't see how that could possibly be true! Try to think past those old, done to death songs, that's all I was saying.
 
... And don't get me started on all those recordings of Beethoven's fifth or Bach's flipping fugues! Apparently "Yesterday" has been covered over 2000 times! An you can't even get contract in 'vagus if you can't do "love me tender", allegedly...

But it's easy cope with it, without self harming; don't listen or watch stuff you don't like! Easy.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure that whether the world needs another recording of "Giant Steps" is really the point. Does the world need another daft old git learning the saxophone? Probably not, but it's not going to stop me. Does the world actually need music at all? Again probably not, but I'd be sorry to lose some of it at least.
 
Last edited:
I feel bad about posting this now, like I sank to the same level. To be honest, I thought it'd probably have been deleted by the time I woke up, and I'd be in trouble for posting it!

I was just laughing so hard that I wanted to share the laughter!

To me, it was just a throw away comment, on a post that had no other comments at all.
He asked in short, "want to hear me playing Giant Steps?", I replied honestly, and I thought, perhaps mistakenly, somewhat humorously!

You'll note that in my initial comment, I did not criticise him about anything but song choice, but this feels a bit like a personal attack now, something I'm not really comfortable with.

Mind you though, his turning my comment into it's own seperate, new post, does reflect badly on his personality, but then, so does my posting his reaction here, so I guess he got me there, I sank to his level.

Is he not a member here anymore? I thought maybe we could converse privately, rather than everything being a public display, although it seems like he's pretty comfortable with that!

I'm sure he's a nice bloke, and I really have no beef with him at all, I just found it amusing.
His videos are usually interesting, experimental, and fun, that's why I'm subscribed to him on YouTube, but also why I thought picking a song like Giant Steps was such a boring song choice, not exciting or innovative at all, perhaps I expected too much of him.

Had he not posed it as a question, and just posted a video of him playing Giant Steps, I would have said nothing and skipped to the next video, but he asked a question, and got an answer, I certainly didn't expect him to make a fuss over my comment!

And I really didn't think he'd imply that I commented for the "fame" of commenting on his channel!!! 😛 In Australia, we call that having tickets on yourself! That really cracked me up!

Coincidentally, things like this are how I got the name "Dave Diamond" as a teenager. The Vietnam Vets branded me that. I'd say something like the comment in question, and they'd say " Sheez! You're a bloody Rough Diamond Dave!!!" and the name stuck.🙂

In any case, I can't delete this thread now, but as always, I stand by anything I say, even if the response surprises me, so I don't mind if it stays, or if it goes. I do think it reflects badly on my own personality though, but what can I do, I am what I am! 😎
 
To me, it was just a throw away comment, on a post that had no other comments at all.
He asked in short, "want to hear me playing Giant Steps?", I replied honestly, and I thought, perhaps mistakenly, somewhat humorously!
Thanks for, finally, giving the context for your initial post...:rolleyes:
I wonder if this thread would be different if you hadn't kept some info back?
 
I don't think anyone would want hear me playing Giant Steps.

I know I'm repeating myself, but...

I went to a jazz jam last night. Apart from me and my drumming collaborator, who just make stuff up, I think every other tune was written by an American in the 1930s, 40s or 50s and interpreted in a style put together by black Americans in the 1950s. A lot of it was very well done and appreciated by the audience. There's obviously still a market for it. If anyone had attempted it, Giant Steps may well have suited them nicely. Nearest they got was Mr. PC (1959 - to save anyone looking it up 🙂 ). To me, it just seems a shame and a bit narrow minded - but at least it's not a blues jam.

I probably need a big smiley here but my computer has decided it's not giving me the option. You'll just have to imagine it.
 
Some tunes and genres just grab you for a lifetime. Some are passing fancies or nostalgic. My repertoire is 90% american song book from before I was born. I'm sure some find them dull and have little or no interest in them.
I share your pain of an honest or attempted humourous comment being taken the wrong way.
Even at this late stage in my life I still find my foot in my mouth. Can't not comment though.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,433
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom