Sheet Music Tomplay or Musescore

Messages
904
Location
Manchester (UK)
Level
Opt. Intermediate
I've downloaded Tomplay and had a play with it, the backing tracks add to the playing experience. The scrolling helps with my tempo.

However, I've since seen Musescore, which seems similar.

Pro's and con's of either?

Or are they just reinventing the wheel and stick with my printed sheet music?
 
Hmm choices huh....I can't read music quick enough to play what I want I guess it's the right way....I did like tomplay but play over a hall and don't always have the net...What I do which is probably slower than learning to read tbf is to buy the score from music notes and mark it myself, transpose if needed. Transfer the lyrics onto word and write the notes on, either use you tube to MP3 to extract the song or buy the track from karaoke version....I end up with this...Play it for a while with backing track adjust and put onto mobile sheets..Its long winded but works for faster songs that I can't read music for..
 

Attachments

  • img161.webp
    img161.webp
    34.6 KB · : 410
Depends on what you want to achieve.

I'm pretty tech savvy, but I'm not convinced that some of these hand-holding tools are a "good thing". My objective is to be more musical and there are no shortcuts for that.

I - and lots of others - find having the scores in an app on a tablet convenient. Things like mobilesheets include a metronom and you can include backing or demo tracks so it's all in one place. For me, that's enough for dots. Playing by ear and memory are also important and something like iRealPro or bandinabox provide backings, rhythm guides etc.
Oh, and something to record your self

I struggle, like you, with tempo. So I work on a tune. Playing with the demo, with the backing, with iReal.... It takes time!
 
I can read music (or at least the notes) but where I struggle is tempo & rhythm.

If I have an idea what the song is, it's recognisable to others, but probably isn't correct, exaggerated when playing with the backing track.
Over and over again with the backing track...it comes...i'm having lessons too, hopefully I will catch up and do it all from scores...its a long road..but fun..
 
where I struggle is tempo & rhythm
you are not alone. There's a reason the thread below is pinned to the top of a forum!!

 
I just took a quick look at Tomplay, Musescore and EddieScript. All seem like they have very different purposes.

Tomplay is geared toward play-alongs and has a library of tunes with backing tracks. If that's what you're after, seems like a great product. But the "Pink Panther" demo did not impress me. It looked like notation from a midi source. The actual tune consists of swing eighths, yet those were written as dotted-eighth and sixteenth notes, needlessly complex and inaccurate, like a bad transcription of an improvised solo.

Musescore is simply a computer based composition tool. The library of tunes is entirely written by other users. It's not meant to be an educational or accompaniment tool. I see it being used mainly for composition. If you need such a tool, Cakewalk is far, far better, and also free. Paid tools like Sibelius are better still.

EddieScript works great for Eddie, but has very limited value as a compositon or play-along tool. There's no way to represent rhythms, key signatures, time signatures, dynamics, articulation, chords, harmony, etc. I tried EddieScript on Donna Lee and ended up with incomprehensible alphabet soup. Even the posted example seems incorrect. In the very first line, I hear a minor 3rd in the recording, yet, it's written as a major 3rd. However, every single written score I could find also gets this wrong. Did the King sing it wrong or did the copyists get it wrong?
 
I just took a quick look at Tomplay, Musescore and EddieScript. All seem like they have very different purposes.

Tomplay is geared toward play-alongs and has a library of tunes with backing tracks. If that's what you're after, seems like a great product. But the "Pink Panther" demo did not impress me. It looked like notation from a midi source. The actual tune consists of swing eighths, yet those were written as dotted-eighth and sixteenth notes, needlessly complex and inaccurate, like a bad transcription of an improvised solo.

Musescore is simply a computer based composition tool. The library of tunes is entirely written by other users. It's not meant to be an educational or accompaniment tool. I see it being used mainly for composition. If you need such a tool, Cakewalk is far, far better, and also free. Paid tools like Sibelius are better still.

EddieScript works great for Eddie, but has very limited value as a compositon or play-along tool. There's no way to represent rhythms, key signatures, time signatures, dynamics, articulation, chords, harmony, etc. I tried EddieScript on Donna Lee and ended up with incomprehensible alphabet soup. Even the posted example seems incorrect. In the very first line, I hear a minor 3rd in the recording, yet, it's written as a major 3rd. However, every single written score I could find also gets this wrong. Did the King sing it wrong or did the copyists get it wrong?
Ill have to sort out my shovel @lydian as it appears youre in the que for a dig..TBF that ws a 1st draft a few of the notes arent quite right...but it will be adjusted to fit the tune, not done yet...reading and playing from scores is commendable i bow down to your knowledge and commitment.. However people i know who have played for a long time do it that way for gigs, its not "eddiescript" as you so comically call it...trouble is with learning music it takes a lifetime. By no means am i saying its not worth it i am continuing lessons...however theres more than one way to learn and start the basics having fun...if more adult learners could blow a tune quickly maybe fewer would give up..its a very anal opinion and costly excercise to follow the right path..Maybe everyone doesn't have the oppurtunity..
 
It depends on what you are looking for. As @lydian says, Tomplay and Musescore are designed for different tasks.

Musescore is for writing music, I use it quite a lot, and it's good, but if you already have a printed score, then I can't see how Musescore will help you.

Tomplay seems to be a tool for providing backings to play along with. I haven't tried it. Two widely-used alternatives are iRealPro and Band In A Box. BIAB can create good backing tracks, but it is very expensive.
 
Ill have to sort out my shovel @lydian as it appears youre in the que for a dig..TBF that ws a 1st draft a few of the notes arent quite right...but it will be adjusted to fit the tune, not done yet...reading and playing from scores is commendable i bow down to your knowledge and commitment.. However people i know who have played for a long time do it that way for gigs, its not "eddiescript" as you so comically call it...trouble is with learning music it takes a lifetime. By no means am i saying its not worth it i am continuing lessons...however theres more than one way to learn and start the basics having fun...if more adult learners could blow a tune quickly maybe fewer would give up..its a very anal opinion and costly excercise to follow the right path..Maybe everyone doesn't have the oppurtunity..
I totally get where you're coming from. Just trying to point out, in a somewhat humorous way, that the letter note method has major limitations. I also pointed out that lots of professional arrangers also got that tune wrong since they wrote that note as a major 2nd which isn't even remotely correct. You were actually closer to being correct than they were.

Kids in band class learn to read music in a week. It's a very worthwhile and attainable goal, even for an adult beginner. I encourage you to print out some blank staff paper and attempt to write the notation for the next tune you learn. Even if the rhythms are out of reach, getting used to reading the dots instead of letters will pay off in the long run.
 
Hi @lydian hope I didn' come accross as defensive..... I know your right and i was being genuine when I praised your commitment...theres no doubt letters with a backing track works for a lot of people..Personally I want to learn theory too. Its a lot longer haul as an adult, other commitments for time and cash....
 
I had a subscription to Tomplay given to me as a birthday present. I wasnt that impressed with it at first but as time has gone by they have improved their choice of backing tracks, and many of the tracks are pretty good, although some are a bit dodgy. Its definitely worth having if you just want a nice backing track to have a blast along with.
 
Hi @lydian hope I didn' come accross as defensive..... I know your right and i was being genuine when I praised your commitment...theres no doubt letters with a backing track works for a lot of people..Personally I want to learn theory too. Its a lot longer haul as an adult, other commitments for time and cash....
I was fortunate to have good music instruction in school as a kid, which is where I first learned to read music. However, I've picked up many more instruments as an adult, and had to learn to read all over again, learning to associate the dots with the notes for a particular instrument. I always do it a very cheap, quick and effortless way that has never failed. I just get the beginning band book written for children. It works beautifully for adults as well because it introduces one note at a time, then has lots of reading practice using familiar tunes. Work your way through such a book, and in a couple of weeks you'll be reading.
 
they’re for very different purposes. Tomplay is purely for backing / accompaniment (you can’t change scores). MuseScore is for composing and arranging. It will play back what you’ve arranged (or downloaded from MuseScore.com), the onboard instrument sounds are a bit naff.

I use MuseScore on a daily basis for arranging and adjusting and annotating scores.

I think Tomplay is more what you’re after OP.
 
I play sax to relax, enjoy, and entertain those around me. TomPlay backing tracks are great to play to, different difficulty levels and allow improvisation as you like. You will enjoy exploring. I have a personal play list well over 3 hours and new tracks each week. Strongly recommend.
 
I had my first lesson in a long time on Monday, and I'm temporarily banned from playing melodies, whilst working on my technique.

I was playing with my bottom lip rolled over my teeth, where now I'm not to, and the tone is improved. Long tones, lots and lots of Long tones, and scales.

When I learnt at school, scales were boring, and it was never explained to me the importance of learning them.

So I can read music, play a melody, but its very static... the theory being I can improve the tone, and get to a point where I can anticipate the music, and improvise a little.

Feels like a step backwards, but perseverance and a long term benefit.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,702
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom