Saxophones TJ Signature Custom RAW vs RAW XS - do they sound different?

Fit that to a bari and the only sound that you will get is thud as the player and sax hit the floor.
0BE3E821-A751-4388-89C0-671833C60021.webp
 
Last edited:
I believe in mass. A heavy mothpiece is better for me than a light one. My Rovner is 169 g, an unknown CZ 105 g, Berg Larsen 100 g, Dukoff 93 g, std plastic (like Yamaha) 35 g.

My Rovner have minimal table. So a heavy mouthpiece with minimal table is the way to go?

tmppcs.JPG
 
I believe in mass. A heavy mothpiece is better for me than a light one. My Rovner is 169 g, an unknown CZ 105 g, Berg Larsen 100 g, Dukoff 93 g, std plastic (like Yamaha) 35 g.

My Rovner have minimal table. So a heavy mouthpiece with minimal table is the way to go?

View attachment 22839
If that was the case for the majority of players then why do most alto players use HR mouthpieces rather than metal?
 
If that was the case for the majority of players then why do most alto players use HR mouthpieces rather

It's really very simple...

Manufacturer X ascribes a tonal quality Y to a finish/material Z.
This would be fine and dandy if it weren't for the inconvenient problem that manufacturer A ascribes a tonal quality B to the finish/material Z. And manufacturer C claims something else entirely...and so on.
There's no consistency - and that in itself ought to be enough to tell most people that something smells a bit fishy.

Most folks with a modicum of commonsense will choose a horn based on its technical specifications and the way it handles/plays - with the material/finish being merely a cosmetic nicety. But manufacturers understand that there's a subset of folks out there who prefer to choose a horn based on...well, woo-woo. And because it's a tough, competitive marketplace out there it makes sound financial sense to lever any and all advantages in a bid to increase sales.
So they resort to woo-woo - because the players with nous aren't going to be swayed by it and will choose their horns in the usual fashion, but those who haven't yet worked out what's going on will swallow it up hook, line and sinker.
If someone 'believes' that they'll get tone Y from finish/material Z, the company that claims their horns provide that will likely steal a sale from the company that claims otherwise.

On the face of it, it all sounds very absurd - but here's the kicker. The difference between one horn and its apparently identical counterpart is entirely down to the setup. One key height here and another there is going to make a difference. Ditto one dimension here and another one there. And it's within that natural variability that there's room for manufacturers/retailers to say "You reckon the bronze horn sounds warmer? Well yeah, 'cos it's bronze. That'll be £4500 please. Would you like a Klangbogen to go with..?"

Kerrrchingggg!
I agree that there is so much snake oil in the saxophone business and these heavy mass screws etc are mostly gimmick, mostly.. They do change the tone slightly but more so the feel of the horn and without being able to back up my belief with scientific evidence i cannot prove my point but its ok, the small differences between finishes is there to my ear and thats what matters. A lacquered sig.cust plays different to its unlacquered siblings and part of it is ofcourse different tolerances etc etc and part of it the finish of the sax.
 
If that was the case for the majority of players then why do most alto players use HR mouthpieces rather than metal?
I don't know.. What is your opinion about a heavy mpc vs a light mpc? Most guys says is a gimmick. But how do they come to that conclusion? I can't say anything about heavy screws or "klangbogen" because I've never tried.
 
I agree that there is so much snake oil in the saxophone business and these heavy mass screws etc are mostly gimmick, mostly.. They do change the tone slightly but more so the feel of the horn and without being able to back up my belief with scientific evidence i cannot prove my point but its ok, the small differences between finishes is there to my ear and thats what matters. A lacquered sig.cust plays different to its unlacquered siblings and part of it is ofcourse different tolerances etc etc and part of it the finish of the sax.
Thing is, you make the caveat "without being able to back up my belief" and then go on to make an apparently factual statement vis lacquered/unlacquered horns.
Folks are gonna call you out on that - and rightly so.

In my own practical experience, and having had the benefit of working on very many TJ Signature Custom horns - as well as playing them myself - is that they really are quite individual horns. I have yet to find any pattern whatsoever that correlates to the finish. It matches my experience with working with multiples of horns from other brands. The day I can find a correlation, I'll say so...because it's really no skin off my nose.

Perhaps most telling is that I've dealt with a number Sig.Cust. horns that have gone green (wet players, and all that) and in the process of dealing with the verdigris the finish has been largely lost. It has never made any difference to the response of the horn.
 
Thing is, you make the caveat "without being able to back up my belief" and then go on to make an apparently factual statement vis lacquered/unlacquered horns.
Folks are gonna call you out on that - and rightly so.

In my own practical experience, and having had the benefit of working on very many TJ Signature Custom horns - as well as playing them myself - is that they really are quite individual horns. I have yet to find any pattern whatsoever that correlates to the finish. It matches my experience with working with multiples of horns from other brands. The day I can find a correlation, I'll say so...because it's really no skin off my nose.

Perhaps most telling is that I've dealt with a number Sig.Cust. horns that have gone green (wet players, and all that) and in the process of dealing with the verdigris the finish has been largely lost. It has never made any difference to the response of the horn.
Yeah I know I stick out my nose here stating such things but I am convinced. For sure you have played a lot more instruments than me but i have played a plenty and a lot of tenor time during my career. You believe that different brass gives different sounds? Sorry for my English, I am a swedish guy.

By the way, whats your input on the "soft" brass of the TJSC? Any problems with time getting out of adjustment?
 
People ask for scientific evidence.

A few years ago I did a very simple experiment by attaching a weight to my mouthpiece. I played long tones and compared the Fourier transforms of the waveforms with and without the weight attached. I could not hear a difference, but there was a noticeable difference in the ratio of odd to even harmonics in the Fourier transforms. So the extra weight did make a scientifically measurable difference.

Disclosure: I actually own a Klangbogen. Both I and my teacher think it makes a difference to the sound, but much less than the difference between two mouthpieces.
 
Yeah I know I stick out my nose here stating such things but I am convinced. For sure you have played a lot more instruments than me but i have played a plenty and a lot of tenor time during my career. You believe that different brass gives different sounds? Sorry for my English, I am a swedish guy.

By the way, whats your input on the "soft" brass of the TJSC? Any problems with time getting out of adjustment?
No, I don't believe that different brass gives different sounds. Neither practical experience nor the available data tells me otherwise.

Thing is, it's easy to convince yourself that it does simply by not understanding the inherent variability in seeming identical horns - and by a less-than-rigorous testing process. Bung in some cognitive bias and there you go.

I've not noticed any tendency of the RAW to go out of adjustment. Mine are as stable as my Yamahas ever were - and I don't find I'm inundated with regulation work on such horns over and above the usual wear and tear issues.
 
Mass stabilize energy. A heavy saxophone mouthpiece, extra weight on the ligature, heavy screws ....... . Maybe the thick wall and thick soldered on tone holes on a Martin stabilize the tone? Martin saxes are known fore their even scales.
 
People ask for scientific evidence.

A few years ago I did a very simple experiment by attaching a weight to my mouthpiece. I played long tones and compared the Fourier transforms of the waveforms with and without the weight attached. I could not hear a difference, but there was a noticeable difference in the ratio of odd to even harmonics in the Fourier transforms. So the extra weight did make a scientifically measurable difference.

Disclosure: I actually own a Klangbogen. Both I and my teacher think it makes a difference to the sound, but much less than the difference between two mouthpieces.
A good few years ago Pete and I attached a sliding lead weight to the crook brace on his 10M. Didn't make a difference, no matter what position it was in.

That's not to say that there wasn't a measurable difference - but that's a far cry from a discernable one...and therein lies the rub.
 
Disclosure: I actually own a Klangbogen. Both I and my teacher think it makes a difference to the sound, but much less than the difference between two mouthpieces.
A mouthpiece is designed to make tone/sound different. If a mouthpiece maker makes a copy of a Rovner mouthpiece in a lighter and thinner material, the tone/sound would probably be the same.

Here is a clip with a steady tractor as a rhythm section. The heavy flywheel on this old tractor helps up to give a solid ground.
View: https://youtu.be/FqatMdB5vu4
 
Mass stabilize energy. A heavy saxophone mouthpiece, extra weight on the ligature, heavy screws ....... . Maybe the thick wall and thick soldered on tone holes on a Martin stabilize the tone? Martin saxes are known fore their even scales.
If we take the assumption that more mass implies a certain tonal response, we should be able to see it borne out in the figures.

Let's take the Martin alto - say the original Handcraft or the Comm. III. They both weigh in at 2.38kg. This is our benchmark - any horn that weighs less than this should be less stable, less even-toned.

There's the Conn 6M - an equally-regarded vintage horn with a 'big' sound? Weighs in at 2.21kg.
OK, so it's not much difference Let's add more mass and see what we get.
The Yamaha Purple Logo hits 2.47 and couldn't be more different tonally than the previous examples.
How about even more mass? Well, there's the TJ RAW at 2.57 and the Yani 991 at 2.54 - and the Chinese Altone at a massive 2.6. The difference in mass between them is less than the difference between the Martins and the Conn, so it follows that there ought to be some similarities. But there clearly aren't.

Let's try less mass again then. The venerable Selmer MkVI comes in at 2.3kg...and here's the real nail in the coffin of the mass/tone correlation - it weighs exactly the same as the Yamaha 21.

If you want a correlation you have to look to internal dimensions. That's where the difference is.
 
If a mouthpiece maker makes a copy of a Rovner mouthpiece in a lighter and thinner material, the tone/sound would probably be the same.
It depends on the design. If it's a high baffle I'd say there would be no difference. If it's a low baffle and thin material then I believe there can be some kind of vibration at the very tip which can act partially like a double reed. But it would all depend on the material as well. And it may only make a small difference at certain dynamic levels.

I know there have been tests done that show there is no difference, but these were only done on a high baffler mouthpiece/s I think.

But once it is thick enough for there to be no significant vibration then there would be no difference in sound IMO.

However we are getting way off topic, this is about TJ saxophones.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,580
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom