Saxophones TJ Signature Custom RAW vs RAW XS - do they sound different?

just out of science curiosity, I was thinking/reading about that a while ago...
Then, one day, swabbing out my sax after a practice, it occurred to me that, in action rather than the lab, the inside surface of the sax is probably dominated by water.
And, of course, sound travels about four times faster in water than in air.
 
And, of course, sound travels about four times faster in water than in air.
I'm more considering the interaction of air with surface. There are two pints of view. First, thermodynamics; how inelastic are collision of air molecules on the surface. Second something or other to do with laminar flow at the surface-air interface.

My point, above, is that the surface in question isn't so much brass or lacor as a fine film of condensed water.

Anyway. It all has a negligible affect on anything for a sax.... Unlike the impact of pads / resonators.
 
just out of science curiosity, I was thinking/reading about that a while ago...
Then, one day, swabbing out my sax after a practice, it occurred to me that, in action rather than the lab, the inside surface of the sax is probably dominated by water.
That probably varies from player to player and ambient conditions.

Both the Trevor James (88) and Theo Wanne Mantra saxophones have textured internal finishes to the neck, referred to as 'rifled' and 'reticulated' respectively. Perhaps it makes a difference, perhaps it's just marketing spin.
 
That probably varies from player to player and ambient conditions.
Sure.

Both the Trevor James (88) and Theo Wanne Mantra saxophones have textured internal finishes to the neck, referred to as 'rifled' and 'reticulated' respectively. Perhaps it makes a difference, perhaps it's just marketing spin.
Here's a back-of-the-envalope;
Most people agree that naked pads Vs resonators matter. Tone holes are, what?, 20% of the Internal surface or so?
So that gives a feel for how rough how much of the surface has to be to matter.

If a neck is significantly not smooth internally and that's 5% or so of surface... Sure, why not.

On the other hand, to a thermodynamic air molecule - brass, or epoxy aren't that different... Even less so when damp. Seems to me.
 
The TJSC RAW was updated years ago with some new mechanical feature wich i dont know the reason for (around f-pad). It adds some weight to an already heavy horn. I wish they got rid of that and the double arms on low C and C# together with the high F# key to save some weight instead. Dave Farly said in an interview that good quality brass has some weight and thats why they use it in their saxes. For the good sound. But the brass they use is very soft. The new neck is interesting, had one on loan to try with my RAW XS and it focused the sound of the horn and added some extra brightness but took away some of the creaminess of the old neck. What i like about these tenors are the response, great keywork and rich tone.

When I see comments such as “quality brass has some weight”, I am convinced that they not not a whit about the metal.

One might use thicker brass, but the density remains the same unless it is porous (highly unlikely).
 
When I see comments such as “quality brass has some weight”, I am convinced that they not not a whit about the metal.

One might use thicker brass, but the density remains the same unless it is porous (highly unlikely).
Maybe David Farley (the father of this particular sax) was out on thin ice (brass) when he said so? The interview
View: https://youtu.be/05ufdQTIU50
at 5:40 they are talking about the brass.
 
Last edited:
When I see comments such as “quality brass has some weight”, I am convinced that they not not a whit about the metal.

One might use thicker brass, but the density remains the same unless it is porous (highly unlikely).
Unless I've forgotten what I was taught sixty odd years ago, which is very likely, the different proportions of copper and zinc will result in brass of differing densities.
 
The difference between different brass types is close to negligible when we talk about the usual alloys used in saxophones. Move a bit down in the table and you will find different brass types specified. The usual "musical" brass seems to be 8.7 g/cm3:

Density of brass
Also, in order to make brass "have more weight" one would have to add more copper to the alloy.
Copper is the heavier but also the softer of the two metals. So the resulting alloy will be softer and more malleable.
 
David Farley said in the interview that they had tried 9 different alloy combinations until they found the right sounding metal. Ofcourse the material of the brass matters as well as the finish of the horn. Even a ligature makes a difference in sound but mostly in feel to the player.
 
David Farley said in the interview that they had tried 9 different alloy combinations until they found the right sounding metal. Ofcourse the material of the brass matters as well as the finish of the horn. Even a ligature makes a difference in sound but mostly in feel to the player.
It's really very simple...

Manufacturer X ascribes a tonal quality Y to a finish/material Z.
This would be fine and dandy if it weren't for the inconvenient problem that manufacturer A ascribes a tonal quality B to the finish/material Z. And manufacturer C claims something else entirely...and so on.
There's no consistency - and that in itself ought to be enough to tell most people that something smells a bit fishy.

Most folks with a modicum of commonsense will choose a horn based on its technical specifications and the way it handles/plays - with the material/finish being merely a cosmetic nicety. But manufacturers understand that there's a subset of folks out there who prefer to choose a horn based on...well, woo-woo. And because it's a tough, competitive marketplace out there it makes sound financial sense to lever any and all advantages in a bid to increase sales.
So they resort to woo-woo - because the players with nous aren't going to be swayed by it and will choose their horns in the usual fashion, but those who haven't yet worked out what's going on will swallow it up hook, line and sinker.
If someone 'believes' that they'll get tone Y from finish/material Z, the company that claims their horns provide that will likely steal a sale from the company that claims otherwise.

On the face of it, it all sounds very absurd - but here's the kicker. The difference between one horn and its apparently identical counterpart is entirely down to the setup. One key height here and another there is going to make a difference. Ditto one dimension here and another one there. And it's within that natural variability that there's room for manufacturers/retailers to say "You reckon the bronze horn sounds warmer? Well yeah, 'cos it's bronze. That'll be £4500 please. Would you like a Klangbogen to go with..?"

Kerrrchingggg!
 
Even a ligature makes a difference in sound but mostly in feel to the player.
It can make a huge difference, see here:

One of the screws had seized and sheared off. It felt tight but was just butting up to the seized bit. It was holding the reed but not properly.

  • If the ligature is a good fit for the mouthpiece and holding the reed properly it will work well and the saxophone will sound fas well as the player is capable of.
  • If the ligature is a bad fit and so not holding the reed well it will work badly and the instrument will probably sound worse than the player is capable of.
  • If there is no ligature the reed may fall off and it will not sound at all. This may be better or worse than the player is capable of.

Things can get more complex when the mouthpiece table is not flat. One ligature may work while another doesn't. However that is not due to the quality or "inherent sound " of the ligature, but due to perhaps its design accidentally makes up up for a table concavity (or even convexity)
 
Even tone tablets, heavy mass screws etc have an impact on the sound and response of a horn
0BE3E821-A751-4388-89C0-671833C60021.webp

This is the one you need, the holy grail of heavy mass screws.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,578
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom