David Farley said in the interview that they had tried 9 different alloy combinations until they found the right sounding metal. Ofcourse the material of the brass matters as well as the finish of the horn. Even a ligature makes a difference in sound but mostly in feel to the player.
It's really very simple...
Manufacturer X ascribes a tonal quality Y to a finish/material Z.
This would be fine and dandy if it weren't for the inconvenient problem that manufacturer A ascribes a tonal quality B to the finish/material Z. And manufacturer C claims something else entirely...and so on.
There's no consistency - and that in itself ought to be enough to tell most people that something smells a bit fishy.
Most folks with a modicum of commonsense will choose a horn based on its technical specifications and the way it handles/plays - with the material/finish being merely a cosmetic nicety. But manufacturers understand that there's a subset of folks out there who prefer to choose a horn based on...well, woo-woo. And because it's a tough, competitive marketplace out there it makes sound financial sense to lever any and all advantages in a bid to increase sales.
So they resort to woo-woo - because the players with nous aren't going to be swayed by it and will choose their horns in the usual fashion, but those who haven't yet worked out what's going on will swallow it up hook, line and sinker.
If someone 'believes' that they'll get tone Y from finish/material Z, the company that claims their horns provide that will likely steal a sale from the company that claims otherwise.
On the face of it, it all sounds very absurd - but here's the kicker. The difference between one horn and its apparently identical counterpart is entirely down to the setup. One key height here and another there is going to make a difference. Ditto one dimension here and another one there. And it's within that natural variability that there's room for manufacturers/retailers to say "You reckon the bronze horn sounds warmer? Well yeah, 'cos it's bronze. That'll be £4500 please. Would you like a Klangbogen to go with..?"
Kerrrchingggg!