You shouldn't need to go any softer on a C*. (I'm assuming it's an S80).
Try and identify what the problem is. Squeezing too much, blowing too hard would be a good starting point. It may also be that the Selmer has more resistance than the no-name supplied. In which case it to be expected and you should persevere and learn to play it.
I've an alto S80 C* at home as well as two soloists (D&E). All three are pretty resistant and also give the best tone on harder reeds. I've expeimented with some different reeds, and have settled on RJS on them, primarily for tone. The S80 doesn't get played. But the soloists do. I'm leaning towards the E with an RJS 2M because it blows more freely, although the D (Pillinger replica) sounds a little better on the same reed. I've found that with all of them the secret is to relax despite the highish pressure needed compared to my tenor PPT. Then out pop the lovely round tones... But tense up and it sounds baaaad. Not nice bad, but really bad.
Nicest sounding alto mouthpiece I've tried is a vintage Brilhart Tonalin W Pesonaline S5. But that's another story.