Tech/maintenance Tight keys on Soprano Saxophone

Thysen Naidoo

New Member
Messages
3
Location
South Africa
Hi everyone,

I just bought a soprano saxophone but the keys were loose and for some reason when I put it on, the keys become tight and you can't press it. It's the G#, C#, B and Bb keys. Any assistance will be great. I'm not sure if im putting the keys on correctly.
 
We don’t really have enough information. Even with images this might be difficult to troubleshoot via the forum so you may need to show it to a repairer or at least an experienced player.

If it was damaged in transit this could be anything from something simple such as a screw fallen out (and you put it back too tightly) to some serious damage to the whole instrument, which would require returning it to the seller.

But some photos and more information/description may help as we have some good techs here who will do their best to diagnose.
 
Last edited:
A common cause of keys not working at first is when there are packing materials such as rubber wedges still in place. These are meant to stop things moving in transit.

Doesn’t seem like that would be the case if the keys were originally loose but worth checking.
 
I cannot honestly believe that anyone would ship a saxophone , dismounted in a " self assembly KIT" since most people in the world, unless they afre experienced saxophone mechanics would be able to fix it (and those people wouldn't ask us (!) how to fix this.

They must be TRAVEL CORKS


this video should explain how to remove the " travel corks", generally they are removed from any shop if this has gone through a shop

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PkTV8_BRKb0
 
Hi everyone,

I just bought a soprano saxophone but the keys were loose and for some reason when I put it on, the keys become tight and you can't press it. It's the G#, C#, B and Bb keys. Any assistance will be great. I'm not sure if im putting the keys on correctly.
The only thing that makes sense to me is that there is something under the foot of the G# touch that prevents it from going down. This, in turn, would prevent the C#, B, and Bb from going down as well.
 
It's the G#, C#, B and Bb keys. Any assistance will be great. I'm not sure if im putting the keys on correctly.

Ok, so I've been reading your post carefully and obviously you must have done something wrong with those keys.

That's the left pinky table and if not assembled correctly I'm not surprised if it doesn't operate as it should. There are some linkage between those keys and they can easily interfere with a proper action.

There are springs too that play a role in all this. Are they mounted properly?

The springs are there to either keep a key open by default (B & Bb) or closed (C# & G#).

It's not madly complicated, but it takes being used to. :confused:

It is best to discuss that with someone who knows how it is supposed to work.

Any tech or experienced player you can talk to locally?
 
I don't really follow, but my best guess is you've tightened all of the adjustment screws on those keys so that the keys no longer move. Those are not meant to be tight but are meant to set the correct height so that all the keys work together properly. I think you're going to have to get a professional to fix it since you don't have a concept of how the mechanisms of a saxophone work.
 
I'd like the OP to come back and explain again more clearly what the problem actually is.

This "in medias res" business that is so common especially amongst the young gets a bit tired. You don't have to go all the way back to "Gentlemen, this is a saxophone" but at least tell us what the hell you're talking about.

[I just bought a soprano saxophone but the keys were loose] - yeah, you're supposed to be able to actuate them...

[ and for some reason when I put it on] - so it's a curved soprano and you're hanging it from a strap?

[, the keys become tight and you can't press it. It's the G#, C#, B and Bb keys] - so your fingers quit working? The key action which normally requires no more than a couple ounces of pressure suddenly requires 50 pounds of force to make a key move? What are you talking about?

[. Any assistance will be great. I'm not sure if im putting the keys on correctly]. - Usually the manufacturer puts the keys on the horn. What are you talking about?
 
at least tell us what the hell you're talking about.
It may be worth remembering that not everyone here has English as a first language.

I think we can help once we understand what the issue is so it’s worth being patient and assume someone is doing their best as we have the rule that posts must be in English.

Let’s try to get some useful international communication going on. (If that is what the communication problem is here)
 
Last edited:
All day long I deal with written communciations from people whose first language isn't English. They understand that they might not be using the correct vocabulary so they'll write things like "the abc doesn't seem to be tall enough (I mean, the part that's to the left of the XYZ in this picture)" so the meaning is clear.

OP, please try again. Photos can be very helpful. No one here understands what the problem is, so we can't help you to solve it.
 
Ok, so I've been reading your post carefully and obviously you must have done something wrong with those keys.

That's the left pinky table and if not assembled correctly I'm not surprised if it doesn't operate as it should. There are some linkage between those keys and they can easily interfere with a proper action.

There are springs too that play a role in all this. Are they mounted properly?

The springs are there to either keep a key open by default (B & Bb) or closed (C# & G#).

It's not madly complicated, but it takes being used to. :confused:

It is best to discuss that with someone who knows how it is supposed to work.

Any tech or experienced player you can talk to locally?
Hi I've spoken to tech here, and I think I have to send it in. When I bought the sax the keys were off the sax but when I put the keys back it sort of made it tight where you can't even press it. We


The tech said that he will set it up. Hopefully, it's nothings nothing to major.

Thank you for your assistance
 
The tech said that he will set it up. Hopefully, it's nothings nothing to major.
Thanks for the update.

I have to say it is extremely rare for anyone to buy an unassembled saxophone. I think this is why people are so incredulous and confused about what you posted.

It would be like buying an unassembled car.

A competent mechanic with all the tools could do it but not a beginner.

Even then it's complex because very often at the factory some parts may come off the production line and be imperfect. At there factory it's easy for the assembler to just bin that part and use one that fits. However nobody would know that until they try to assemble it so just buying the body and all the bits means there could well be some parts that just won't fit.

Anyway best of luck and hope your tech solves it.

I have fond memories of some really great South Africa musicians and friends worked with - Dudu Pukwana (alto saxophone) , Lucky Ranku (tenor) Julian Bahula and Brian Abrhams (drums)
 
Sorry for being a bit curious, but were all the keys off? Or just the one you mentioned?

I do have a puzzle named sax on my bench, but I am responsible for it being in that state! 😛 Now, I have rarely left one dis-assembled for so long. I took it apart in 2020 during the lock down, spent some time removing the lacquer and polishing the bare parts. Then I got busy again and it's still waiting for my renewed attention! Poor thing. :confused:

I hope you will soon have your soprano in good playing condition. Soprano is nice. Not the easiest, maybe, but fun to play. Enjoy.

By the way. What is it? Make & model?
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,074
Messages
578,636
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom