Saxophones This Selmer looks genuine, but then again it doesn't...

Nor had I noticed this part of the listing...

Screenshot 2023-05-13 at 23.39.47.png



A reminder of the legislation (note the up to ten year prison sentence)...


I can only imagine Howie didn't realise it was supposed to be a MkVI (he must have played one surely?) and didn't inspect the sax to check what it was. I'm sure he'll be horrified to discover he's passed on a fake.

How did he come by it I wonder?

😳
 
Last edited:
Hi David,
I’ve just had a look at the listing. It doesn’t say anywhere that it is a Selmer. It does come in a Selmer case but I don’t state anywhere that it is a Selmer.
I can only imagine Howie didn't realise it was supposed to be a MkVI

They don’t actually have to say Selmer in the ad text to be liable for passing off a counterfeit as a genuine instrument, because the trademark logo is in the photos which represent the item.

Assuming it is a counterfeit, the sale is illegal whichever way you look at it.

Unless of course it actually is a MKVI that has been refinished, altered keywork, and re-engraved and then advertised as a Prelude.
 
Last edited:
From the seller:

"Hi David,
Thank you for this.
I have spoken with my team this morning and a contact at a local music establishment.
Truth be told we don’t know anything about the Sax and we’re selling it to raise money for our hospice in good faith.
Howie gave it to us informing us that it was worth around £300-£400, or at least that is what he paid for it.
We didn’t list it as a brand as we simply didn’t know if it was or not. However, as pointed out above it does have ‘brand’ markings on it.
Therefore we are going to remove the listing and go back to the drawing board.
Thank you for your help in this matter."
 
I'm just thinking... I'd be happy to donate £10 to this cancer charity, seeing as they won't be selling this sax.

If I suggested to the seller we'd raise some money here to purchase and then destroy the sax on video (I'm thinking road roller) would anyone else be prepared to donate?

I've donated monthly to cancer research for years. My mother died age 54 from lung cancer so I've seen first hand the harrowing effects of cancer (and smoking).

@Pete Thomas - would this be allowed, and should I start a new thread linking to this one?

PS. I've suggested this to the seller to see if it's a possibility.
 
Last edited:
My partner is currently recovering from lymphoma hence my thoughts on the name of this charity. But it is clear that they do genuine and important fund raising for their local area and are pretty successful in doing so.
 
I'm just thinking... I'd be happy to donate £10 to this cancer charity, seeing as they won't be selling this sax.

If I suggested to the seller we'd raise some money here to purchase and then destroy the sax on video (I'm thinking road roller) would anyone else be prepared to donate?

I've donated monthly to cancer research for years. My mother died age 54 from lung cancer so I've seen first hand the harrowing effects of cancer (and smoking).

@Pete Thomas - would this be allowed, and should I start a new thread linking to this one?

PS. I've suggested this to the seller to see if it's a possibility.
Good suggestion!
If they would destroy it by using a road roller, they could frame it and sell it as a work of art.... 😎

I would be tempted to contribute some money for this, but there might be some difficulties from excange rate and other costs that would complicate this.
 
Wouldn’t it be better for us all to donate , purchase the sax have the selmer name removed and then pass it onto a music charity where less fortunate kids get to play a saxophone
 
Wouldn’t it be better for us all to donate , purchase the sax have the selmer name removed and then pass it onto a music charity where less fortunate kids get to play a saxophone
...get to play a saxophone shaped object.

It might put them off? Unless one of our esteemed techs would like to breathe over it... for charity?

I say flatten it. Get the local press in, get a plant company to provide the road roller (advertising for them), might even make local TV...

"...the charity nor the donor had any idea is was a fake and once alerted they withdrew it from sale. Other musicians, hearing about the story and disliking the selling of counterfeit saxophones, chipped in to make good the charity's shortfall had the saxophone been genuine and sold."

BUT... the seller needs to get on board first. He may have other ideas. Howie may be taking it back to whoever sold him a dud... we don't know.
 
"...the charity nor the donor had any idea is was a fake and once alerted they withdrew it from sale. Other musicians, hearing about the story and disliking the selling of counterfeit saxophones, chipped in to make good the charity's shortfall had the saxophone been genuine and sold."
I have some reservations,

You need to word this very carefully. It could backfire given that I imagine many people will just see it as wanton destruction if they don’t have the same views about counterfeit items. Especially if they are unaware of or don’t believe in the links with organised crime.
 
I have some reservations,

You need to word this very carefully. It could backfire given that I imagine many people will just see it as wanton destruction if they don’t have the same views about counterfeit items. Especially if they are unaware of or don’t believe in the links with organised crime.
I understand. Perhaps it should just "disappear"?

I don't like the idea of removing the Selmer logo and keeping it alive, to my mind that somehow perpetuates the distasteful origins.

No response from the seller so it's probably a non-starter anyhow.
 
Wouldn’t it be better for us all to donate , purchase the sax have the selmer name removed and then pass it onto a music charity where less fortunate kids get to play a saxophone
Going down this route would still constitute a financial transaction and sale of counterfeit goods
 
It's been gifted to the charity. The charity can dispose of it for no consideration i.e. bin it. Donations can be separate.
Above you said we'd raise some money here to purchase

It is now less clear to me what this is all about. Raising money needs to have a very transparent aim and before there is any Cafe involvement or possible mention in publicity, we need to know what the intention is, how any funds are described and used, and how any wording on publicity that involves the Cafe is phrased.
 
Above you said we'd raise some money here to purchase

It is now less clear to me what this is all about. Raising money needs to have a very transparent aim and before there is any Cafe involvement or possible mention in publicity, we need to know what the intention is, how any funds are described and used, and how any wording on publicity that involves the Cafe is phrased.
It's not illegal to buy it, but it would incriminate the seller/charity strictly speaking.
Let's just forget the whole idea eh?
I'll carry on donating...
 
I am no lawyer, but there must be a difference between "purchasing" and "fundraising in order to destroy a counterfeit object".
The fundraising would be in order to compensate the charity for their (percieved) losses.
And the destruction would be done either by the charity or by the person who gave it to the charity because they are so shocked to find out that this object is counterfeit.

The role of the cafe might be in exposing/discovering the fact that it is counterfeit and in the fundraising because we are so disapointed that the charity might miss some funding because of that.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,574
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom