Saxophones This Selmer looks genuine, but then again it doesn't...

I am no lawyer, but there must be a difference between "purchasing" and "fundraising in order to destroy a counterfeit object".
The fundraising would be in order to compensate the charity for their (percieved) losses.
And the destruction would be done either by the charity or by the person who gave it to the charity because they are so shocked to find out that this object is counterfeit.

The role of the cafe might be in exposing/discovering the fact that it is counterfeit and in the fundraising because we are so disapointed that the charity might miss some funding because of that.
That was the idea, but I'm out.
Forget I suggested it.
 
It's a very sad end really.

Unfortunately this is just one of the less obvious side effects of the counterfeit industry. A charity trying to raise funds in good faith, but falling on their backside and missing out on a fundraising opportunity.
 
Unfortunately this is just one of the less obvious side effects of the counterfeit industry.
Yes, there was no reason why they should know at the time the horn was donated. Unlike more well known counterfeit trademarls such as Gucci, Rolex.

I think it was a nice idea but I can understand David's reluctance to get involved
 
An unsalable item was donated to an organisation that can't sell it.
I wouldn’t say it is technically unsaleable. But for the sharp eyes of David it would have sold on eBay. They would no doubt get something for it from a pawnbroker.

It’s all down to whether they care about it being a fake Selmer. (Assuming we have now established it is)
 
Scratch the name off the bell and give it free of charge to a woodwind repair college or a repair apprentice. Then when they’ve finished with it a school could make use of it.
 
Interesting. Buying a fake isn't the same as handling stolen goods - which is just illegal.

According to

You’re not legally obliged to report someone selling fake goods, but it might stop other people accidentally buying fakes from them in future. but it might stop other people accidentally buying fakes from them in future.

So one could buy the item, have the money go to charity, engrave "FAKE but in a good cause" on it and legally sell it on.
 
Interesting. Buying a fake isn't the same as handling stolen goods - which is just illegal.

According to



So one could buy the item, have the money go to charity, engrave "FAKE but in a good cause" on it and legally sell it on.
As Pete advised, buying the sax means the seller/charity commits an offence punishable by a fine and up to ten years in prison.

It would need to be a gift from the current owner to the repair school or whoever. Once defaced, with no brand name, it could be sold on in the future.

I still have a problem with the chain of money going back to the criminals at the top. That's their fault AND that of whoever bought it originally, albeit in "ignorance."
 
As Pete advised, buying the sax means the seller/charity commits an offence punishable by a fine and up to ten years in prison.
Just to be clear, buying the sax is legal, it is only selling it that is not legal.

However in this case it was a gift anyway.

I think prosecution is rare unless it is a large operation selling multiple items.
 
As Pete advised, buying the sax means the seller/charity commits an offence punishable by a fine and up to ten years in prison.

It would need to be a gift from the current owner to the repair school or whoever. Once defaced, with no brand name, it could be sold on in the future.

I still have a problem with the chain of money going back to the criminals at the top. That's their fault AND that of whoever bought it originally, albeit in "ignorance."
Any further news on this?
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,573
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom