Saxophone beginners third overtone of low B?

The theory behind it has to do with the saxophone cone. If the mouthpiece isn't far enough on and the cone gets to long, the sax will play the octave and all the following overtones sharp, more than 2 cents. Many players in fact play in a mouthpiece position like this and adjust with the embouchure. If your first and second overtone are OK with the root, everything is OK, just stop thinking about it.
It's FAR more effective to play long tube notes overblown an octave and compare to the short fingering of the same note. Good choices for this are B, C, C#, and long D vs. palm key D fingering, no octave key, sounding in the staff.

If the short fingering is flat compared to the long fingering, the mouthpiece is too far out for the scale (the positions of the tone holes). If the short fingering is sharp compared to the long fingering, the mouthpiece is too far in for the scale.
 
What’s wrong with tuning to a normal note using a normal fingering? Takes about 2 seconds and you’re done. And it doesn’t annoy your bandmates.

My 2 cents.
The point of double checking with an octave overtone is that you also get an idea if the horn is in tune "with itself"

See: Beginner - third overtone of low B?
 
The point of double checking with an octave overtone is that you also get an idea if the horn is in tune "with itself"

See: Beginner - third overtone of low B?

Which presumably would be a once-off activity. Once satisfied that the horn isn't a bad one and you are familiar with its tendencies, you only need to tune up to a single note.

Rhys
 
Which presumably would be a once-off activity. Once satisfied that the horn isn't a bad one and you are familiar with its tendencies, you only need to tune up to a single note.

Rhys
Yes indeed. I realised that after I posted, but waited for someone such as yourself to helpfully point it out.
 
But that F # overtone is sharp. Why tune to a bad note when there are 11 other good notes?
Perhaps I wasn't clear when I described how I tune. I tune to low F# on the alto sax (A concert) by adjusting the mouthpiece placement on the cork. I usually lip the note first to perfectly match the "tuner" and if I have to lip down, I pull the mouthpiece out a bit, if I have to lip up I push the mouthpiece in a bit. (This is called matching pitch.)That is the note I tune first and then check the octave both with and without the octave key. Then I compare that pitch to the equivalent harmonic of the "long tube" fingering of low B natural. I don't tune using that "long" fingering, but I have learned to check it's harmonic to see if my lip pressure and voicing is giving me the best "harmonicity" for that note. Besides, I don't care to quibble over a difference of 2 cents since that is equal to approximately .5 hz. 🙂
 
Last edited:
I guess tuning to one note is the best answer in a beginner thread, although it may not really answer the OP‘s question.

The effects of mouthpiece volume and position on effective tone hole position on the one hand and cone shape and overblowing behaviour on the other hand are partly opposing each other and partly summing up. I think it is quite interesting and helps understand why some horn-mouthpiece combinations give some funny results in terms of intonation.

It can be complicated though and with a modern horn and moderately shaped mouthpiece it’s probably unnecessarily complicated to even think about these things…
 
I guess I'm just old school. When I was a kid in band, the clarinet or oboe would play a Bb or an A, and everybody would try to match that pitch. Worked pretty well back then. While the brass cycled through a few partials, the woodwinds didn't play any overtones or alternate fingerings. In fact, I didn't even know overtones on sax were a thing until I was an adult.
 
Since I am a proponent of matching the short and long tube notes, I’ll just say the following.

Beginning players often play with too tight an embouchure. It’s quite common, especially if breath support hasn’t been quite developed yet. Doing the “slur” from low B-first overtone to standard fingering B2 forces one to use a “low note embouchure” and players with a too tight embouchure will now find that the standard fingering note is flat, relative to the long tube note. So they push in the mouthpiece. It’s a trick you play on yourself to get your chops right.

Once you’ve adjusted the mouthpiece as above, adjust your embouchure and air to play in tune with others (or your backing track) with the mouthpiece at that point.

Side benefit of doing this is a little practice with overtones, which may help with tone production in general.

Tuning with a single note is great, I remember the last time I had to do that. It was at a rehearsal for a show in 1983. The conductor was a recent hire, and he read in the music director’s handbook that you should tune up the band prior to rehearsal, especially at 1 in the afternoon, as everone knows that musicians are generally degenerate animals and are probably all high or at least hung over. Otherwise, I haven’t tuned up since school - the first couple of bars will usually settle any discrepancies. If the lead trumpet is, in fact, high or hung over, he or she might play a little sharp and we all have to push in an eighth of an inch, but otherwise I keep my mouthpiece in the same position most of the time.
 
Which they pretty much all are, unless you're trying to play a high pitch horn in a low pitch ensemble or
I agree, modern instruments, even the cheap ones, do tend to be in tune.

But my post was also about checking the other variables, which @skeller047 has also mentioned (probably articulated it better than I did). Assuming that octave harmonics are in tune It's useful when in doubt as a double check that your embouchure is not not the cause of wide or narrow octaves. Also when testing a new mouthpiece that may have very different internal geometry to what you normally play.

I guess I'm just old school. When I was a kid in band, the clarinet or oboe would play a Bb or an A,... the woodwinds didn't play any overtones or alternate fingerings.
I agree totally, the idea about matching harmonics is for personal practice and testing, not for general tuning up with a band. Incidentally I also never tune to a note before performing or rehearsing. I just tune as I go along based on what my ears tell me is happening around me.

My good friend Mr Anecdote just tapped me on the shoulder to remind me of a session when I was young.

I had to hold a long F# while the strings changed chord from D to Ab7. The producer told me to do another take because my not went out of tune. 2nd take just as bad. Then I realised the strings were changing pitch as they switched from the F# of the D chord to the G♭ of the A♭7.

I learned a valuable lesson then to always listen and not just assume because I start off in tune I will stay in tune.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,597
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom