Jazz The great Artie

Mike, I am the first in line to back anyone in their beliefs. It just touched a nerve. Old fud's nerves are too close to the surface anyway. That's why I enjoy this site; to learn what young (real) musicians have on their minds. It helps to clear away the cobwebs in my little brain-attic, as Sherlock called it. You could well be right in your assessment of BG. I've just never looked at it except from my own view.

P.S. I hope you find some relief from the heat. I had to get out of my garden at about ten this morning. It was already 100 here in Milan, NM.
 
Mike, I am the first in line to back anyone in their beliefs. It just touched a nerve. Old fud's nerves are too close to the surface anyway. That's why I enjoy this site; to learn what young (real) musicians have on their minds. It helps to clear away the cobwebs in my little brain-attic, as Sherlock called it. You could well be right in your assessment of BG. I've just never looked at it except from my own view.

P.S. I hope you find some relief from the heat. I had to get out of my garden at about ten this morning. It was already 100 here in Milan, NM.
Cheers Al. It was simply my opinion, and meant to be nothing else.

It is hot as usual in Texas, but I have relocated (hopefully not permanently) to the Nashville area, where it is mostly in the 80s and very rainy right now.
 
Tuxedo Junction. I'm going to dig my 78's out of the cedar chest. Even if it's in there, I don't think the individual players were listed. Gives me a reason to look and dust off my elder sibling's records. Being the lone survivor made me over-protective of their goods perhaps; about time to air out the old stacks of wax (as the old D-jays used to say). I look forward to the excavation.
 
I was asked to elaborate upon my preferences and did so. No big surprise that not everyone agrees with me.

But it's good to have individual opinions. Maybe I should have commented, but I'm going back to listen to recordings from both and see if I can hear what you're saying.

I found the comment about playing the clarinet and playing the music interesting. Something similar was said about the lack of music in Herbert von Karajan's recordings, and when I saw it the penny dropped. Maybe it will with Goodman's and Shaw, maybe not.

But I'm always interested to hear others' thoughts about music and musicians, whether or not I agree.
 
For me, I sit down to listen to Shaw and put Goodman on for pottering because I need to be moving.

I play 40's style swing when I'm busking and the number of teenagers that come dancing past is uplifting. They seem to be surprised and embarassed as they catch the swing. There's several Lindy Hop clubs in my area that meet weekly to dance to and enjoy Swing not to mention the Big Bands. It's alive and well but underground. Waiting for a big comeback I hope
.
The difference between listening music and dancing music is ,one goes to the head and the other goes to the feet but both touch the soul.

http://youtu.be/fHP_liJNnmw

http://youtu.be/7LrpzUCe7Cs

Artie's solo is inspired but Benny's cooks.

Apples and oranges. Both good for you and full of Vitamin C.
 
not what I'd normally listen to, but boy could he play..!!
I didn't know anything about him until I saw that BBC documentary a few years ago and borrowed his autobiography, 'The Trouble With Cinderella' from the library.
the BBC documentary is on youtube - split up into 8 minute segments -
http://youtu.be/CnGAxyuezWY
http://youtu.be/XXT2K0Y_8c8
http://youtu.be/S4zIrf5gVmo
http://youtu.be/8tXzsv2-YD8
http://youtu.be/A2qfhxyba_o
http://youtu.be/QpTVDdpjZ8w
http://youtu.be/c9oCezYngaE

Had a chance to listen today. Thanks for posting:thumb:
 
But it's good to have individual opinions. Maybe I should have commented, but I'm going back to listen to recordings from both and see if I can hear what you're saying.

I found the comment about playing the clarinet and playing the music interesting. Something similar was said about the lack of music in Herbert von Karajan's recordings, and when I saw it the penny dropped. Maybe it will with Goodman's and Shaw, maybe not.

But I'm always interested to hear others' thoughts about music and musicians, whether or not I agree.

I have heard the same re. Herbie and his Band, as James Galway used to ref. to the Berlin Phil. The reason could be the policy of not employing women musicians. But thankfully that has changed.🙂
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,505
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom