Playing the saxophone The end of the road

If you don't feel confident improvising/noodling at a gig then... don't. Focus one what you're good at. People will still appreciate a good tune played nicely, whether there's improv or not. I don't understand why you feel it always needs to be there at the beginning/end of a song? It just doesn't.

If you want to work on improvising then you can still have a go in your practice time, but you don't need to put it in your gigs until youre comfortable with it. If I'm reading it correctly you are choosing the setlist, providing the backing tracks etc...so it's entirely up to you if and when you stick any improvised solos in?
 
Focus one what you're good at. People will still appreciate a good tune played nicely, whether there's improv or not.
And I forgot to say, regarding the imposter syndrome comments - if you can do the above (and you can, you posted some recordings a while ago) then don't forget you've got more musical ability than most people. Sometimes we all have to remind ourselves that we can still entertain ourselves and others without being Brecker.
 
Here's my interpretation of Eddie's situation.
-Ed is playing from arrangements, with vocal line from an online store, with Karaoke backing tracks.
- The arrangements - basically verses and chorus - don't have any instrumentals, fills, frills, embellishments, intros etc. that other instruments provide on reference recording (like the Ken Dodd song above)
- Although these non sung parts might be composed or well known or carefully prepared; because they're not on Ed's arrangements -> file under improvised.

There are other ways to develop these missing bits (apart from improvising them each time) - Transpose or compose your own; I suspect that Ed doesn't feel confident in his skills to do that...

No?
Bang on
 
Is ad lib improvising? I really don't know ..... I use to play riffs, fillings, solos very close to what I have learned by ear/written down? I change the recorded solos, riffs, filling so it fits me. Is that improvising or is it just exposing that I can't play the solo as it was recorded/performed? I play a backing track of song (no saxophone) called "It Came Out Of the Sky" (John Fogerty). I want to play the guitar riffs/fillings ( between the text lines on my sax instead of the electric guitar. In the same style as the guitar. I also removed/delete the guitar solos so I can play the solos more in a sax style.

"Pete & Pete", you know a lot more about music and saxplaying than me so I just want to hear your opinons.

View: https://youtu.be/21yZoYQKrL4?si=zxrtCf_bBDv9iMHy
Yes, "ad libitum" - ad lib - is frequently used in printed music, and can in practical terms mean anything from

- choose when to stop (repeat ad lib)
- play freely and with expression

basically, improvise. Do your own thing.

As I said, I see many people with a backing track leaving the "orchestral bits" to the tape and doing nothing. This is fine. If you want to add stuff, this is also fine. It's your show. You can either noodle over the top, play full-blown solo improv, or play along with the lead line.

What Eddie is really saying, I think is that he has an ideal of his role which includes stuff he can't do. So he's thinking about not taking the gig. Thing is, the punters won't realise/care/understand about anything like that.
 
Yes, "ad libitum" - ad lib - is frequently used in printed music, and can in practical terms mean anything from

- choose when to stop (repeat ad lib)
- play freely and with expression

basically, improvise. Do your own thing.

As I said, I see many people with a backing track leaving the "orchestral bits" to the tape and doing nothing. This is fine. If you want to add stuff, this is also fine. It's your show. You can either noodle over the top, play full-blown solo improv, or play along with the lead line.

What Eddie is really saying, I think is that he has an ideal of his role which includes stuff he can't do. So he's thinking about not taking the gig. Thing is, the punters won't realise/care/understand about anything like that.
Thanks.
 
Here's my interpretation of Eddie's situation.
-Ed is playing from arrangements, with vocal line from an online store, with Karaoke backing tracks.
- The arrangements - basically verses and chorus - don't have any instrumentals, fills, frills, embellishments, intros etc. that other instruments provide on reference recording (like the Ken Dodd song above)
- Although these non sung parts might be composed or well known or carefully prepared; because they're not on Ed's arrangements -> file under improvised.

There are other ways to develop these missing bits (apart from improvising them each time) - Transpose or compose your own; I suspect that Ed doesn't feel confident in his skills to do that...

No?
I use "custom backing tracks" I can change key and delete instruments and vocals. "Som jag behagar" is that "Ad Lib" (you know some swedish)?
 
Bang on
Good. Right. Then.

Maybe your best bet is to "compose" or arrange your missing bits on paper. Written notes/note names.
If necessary, scissors and sticky tape your bits into your scores.

Nothing complicated. Anyone commenting on this thread has a better clue than me, but, 2¢: stuff like:
Listen many times to a (one) recording.
Use any of and only the notes from the song. You can use whole phrases. You can use the rhythmic shape of a phrase in the song, but change the notes using arpeggios from the key or pentatonics etc.
Pay attention to the last note in any section you write. For a fill, eg between verses, end your bit on the note (in the key) just below the first note in the verse.
The last note of the outro can be the root of the key. Or the 3rd or 5th to be "jazzy".

I 100% think you can do that. +/- backup from the Cafe
 
The only reason Eddie is feeling compelled to play over intro/outro is that there’s no one else on stage to watch. That’s the nature of this type of gig though.
On British Pop Idol’s Got X Talent Factor they don’t sing over intros etc
I know a classical opera singer that sings to backing tracks - she doesn’t do anything over the orchestral bits.
Don’t make decisions about your own playing based upon what you think others might be thinking. If you can’t abide your own playing then do something about it.
I once had a member of the audience say that I was the best player they’d ever heard. I replied that I was happy to give them a long list of people to listen to.
Unless it’s a gig or a theatre show, mostly music is now just an add-on/background music. If there’s food and a bar you’ll do well to come 4th (bar, food, mates, bloke with sax in the corner).
 
The only reason Eddie is feeling compelled to play over intro/outro is that there’s no one else on stage to watch
It actually makes little sense for a solo player to play over the intro, whether it's improvising or something prepared, just a singer doesn't sing over an intro. That's (almost) the point of an intro.
 
It actually makes little sense for a solo player to play over the intro, whether it's improvising or something prepared, just a singer doesn't sing over an intro. That's (almost) the point of an intro.
Its just hard standing there doing nothing while a 60 sec instrumental goes on. I try to engage with the audience and have a sip of lager at this point lol..same with the outros, i could clip them i guess, seems like the easy option tho
 
Its just hard standing there doing nothing while a 60 sec instrumental goes on. I try to engage with the audience and have a sip of lager at this point lol..same with the outros, i could clip them i guess, seems like the easy option tho
Yes I’d edit them. The slant of having 1 minute intros for a “pop” audience went out in the ‘70’s.
 
Thing is, a show evolves and you develop it. If you’re the centre of attention then you might talk over the intros - “who remembers this one?”, “what were you doing when this song came out?” Etc etc.
We become better players and better front men.
 
Its just hard standing there doing nothing while a 60 sec instrumental goes on. I try to engage with the audience and have a sip of lager at this point lol..same with the outros, i could clip them i guess, seems like the easy option tho
I think that most of the makers of backing tracks have never played a solo gig in their life. A one minute intro is ridiculous. Most early pop songs had got through an intro, verse, chorus and a 2nd intro by then.
 
Its just hard standing there doing nothing while a 60 sec instrumental goes on.
In that case do something during the 60 seconds, or cut it down a bit. It's all part of being on stage in front of people, you need to think about how you appear to your audience as you are doing a performance in this kind of situation so you need to perform.

Try playing a percussion instrument - I often used to take some bongos or tamborine to a gig and play simple rhythms. So many things are better than just improvising (or noodling as someone said) fjust for something to do during an intro.
 
Put your horn down.
In the key of C minor, starting on the tonic or 5th, hum/sing an original melody.
Accidentals are okay.
A keyboard might be helpful.
Write it down and post it here.

We're moving beyond the melodic walking bass. 😎
 
Thing is, a show evolves and you develop it. If you’re the centre of attention then you might talk over the intros - “who remembers this one?”, “what were you doing when this song came out?” Etc etc.
We become better players and better front men.
Speaking of front men, with the Holloman AFB Chapel Worship Band in Alamogordo, NM's main park in 2011. We had an hour slot around 10 in the morning on a Summer Saturday. They had some kind of city-wide fiesta going on. I was on alto sax at the time.

Our female keyboardist bandleader started a soft background intro on a slow ballad, with drums and electric bass. I entered in with a little "doodling" similar to what one would hear a flute doing. We didn't practice it this way, but we were rushed to set up on stage, then downbeat.

Singer entered where she was supposed to, job went well. That little unrehearsed touch helped kick off things well.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,062
Messages
578,405
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom