Miscellaneous The Death of Melody

Punk rock had a "different" view in melody ... Back in the 70s .... That didn't stop people appreciating good melodies...
I was introduced to a contemporary band by a young colleague that has many followers although it's not mainstream. Their songs are purely melodic and simplistic. Most ideas are taken from the 60s 70s and 80s but hey ..... Kids love it... 12 million views on YouTube .... Melody LIVES

View: https://youtu.be/OZRYzH0Q0pU
 
I think that complaining about the poor quality of modern, especially popular, music is a normal sign of middle age. I believe there were lots of complaints at the time about the rubbish that a chap called Beethoven was churning out; Elvis Presley was both second-rate and shocking, and as for the Rolling Stones, well, words fail me!
 
The A section of One Note Samba is very melodic. According to this guy, while he seems to accept that melody doesn't exist without rhythm, a good melody has to have a lot of different notes and that obviously isn't so, it's a bit of a confused ramble really. Three notes are obviously plenty from his examples and as 1NS shows you can get away with one and rhythm and melody are indivisible with rhythm probably being the most important. With very little effort you can find improvisations in Rock or Jazz that have enough notes for anybody but you'd be hard pushed to find obvious melody in there because it's just a string of notes, even though the practitioners will often claim that melody is their main focus. Anyway his thesis is poor and I couldn't stand to watch to his following video as he's somebody who always irritates me anyway.
 
I just skimmed over the video but while I agree that the number of different notes is not in itself a definition of "melodiousness", I would have to agree that modern pop hits are increasingly moving away from being defined by melody.

Beyond that, you get into whole dissertations on the history of pop music, what is pop music, etc., etc., etc., and I don't have time for all that.
 
The central idea I got from the presentation is that the use of "expressive melodies" is on the decline. The repeated notes of the A section of One Note Samba is based upon a humorous lyric which is contrasted with the running notes that follow. They are enjoyable to listen to, but one could hardly label them an "expressive melody" like most of Jobim's other wonderful bossa novas. Everyone has a right to his/her own opinion on this topic and mine, of course, is in line with what is presented in the video which is why I posted it in the first place.
 
I suppose it all depends upon definitions, I would say that So What is an expressive melody, but if you mean a 'big' melodic statement that isn't it. But I agree with turf and, I suppose, the point the guy makes in the video that pop music mostly uses pared down melodic lines and that's for the obvious reason that it is for modern day dancing. The melody is subservient to the rhythm or just another element of it. I don't follow modern pop enough, or know enough about it, to know how extreme this has become but there's plenty of other stuff in the popular realm that still uses melody in a more expressive way.
 
Punk rock had a "different" view in melody ... Back in the 70s .... That didn't stop people appreciating good melodies...
I was introduced to a contemporary band by a young colleague that has many followers although it's not mainstream. Their songs are purely melodic and simplistic. Most ideas are taken from the 60s 70s and 80s but hey ..... Kids love it... 12 million views on YouTube .... Melody LIVES

View: https://youtu.be/OZRYzH0Q0pU
You see, tho...I consider this WAY more interesting, musically, than 90% of commercial or 'mainstream' pop/rock out there. It's got a bridge, it's got interesting chords inserted in there.
Tons of examples of this sorta stuff, and it certainly DOES live on....but it will tend to live at the fringes; IOW, folks will have to seek it out (which they do and which is great, but it ain't gonna be no Super Bowl halftime show material 😎 nor widely disseminated, commercially)...

I tend to view the vids criticizing the mind-numbing simplicity (I am using a euphemism there) of (most) commercial Pop to be quite spot-on, honestly.

Is there an element of generational subjectivity at play ? Perhaps, yes...but honestly when you start dissecting a lot of contemporary pop/rock/r&b genre 'hits'....there ain't a whole lot going on there other than some rehashing of ideas already worn to death....

As for the vid at the top of this thread, I would say it's a pretty good analysis/presentation
 
Tons of examples of this sorta stuff, and it certainly DOES live on....but it will tend to live at the fringes; IOW, folks will have to seek it out (which they do and which is great, but it ain't gonna be no Super Bowl halftime show material 😎 nor widely disseminated, commercially)...
Of course I read 'IOW' as 'Isle of Wight' and people there do live on the fringes and in the 1950's.
Google didn't offer any apparently appropriate alternatives except perhaps 'Idiots on wheels'.
 
The central idea I got from the presentation is that the use of "expressive melodies" is on the decline. The repeated notes of the A section of One Note Samba is based upon a humorous lyric which is contrasted with the running notes that follow. They are enjoyable to listen to, but one could hardly label them an "expressive melody" like most of Jobim's other wonderful bossa novas. Everyone has a right to his/her own opinion on this topic and mine, of course, is in line with what is presented in the video which is why I posted it in the first place.
He promised a solution in the following video, did you watch it and if so what's the answer?
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,056
Messages
578,171
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom