Saxophones The CaféSaxophone saxophone

Do I get it right ? Is this project on hold, or even abandoned ?
I’ve always dreamt of a horn that doubles as coffee machine. Yeah, en français, coffee and café is the same word.
 
Do I get it right ? Is this project on hold, or even abandoned ?
Yes. The difficulties in sustaining the project I mentioned a couple of years ago still remain. This was due to both Covid and Brexit. I was discussing a couple of options. One was finishing/QC being in the UK the other was that assembly/QC was going to happen in Europe. Either way some parts were going to be sourced from the EU as opposed to being your typical China import. That kind of model could have worked for a larger outfit, but being non-profit it would be very difficult for the Cafe. I haven't ruled it out and there is a possibility we could still do it in a different way
 
Either way some parts were going to be sourced from the EU as opposed to being your typical China import.

If one is providing the specifications and running the QC for those parts, can one be an atypical import manufacturer, sourcing stuff but keeping the standards high?

My understanding is that both the JEAN PAUL and BETTER SAX companies are striving to leverage China imported parts cost advantage while keeping eyes on QC for parts and finished goods.
 
If one is providing the specifications and running the QC for those parts, can one be an atypical import manufacturer, sourcing stuff but keeping the standards high?

My understanding is that both the JEAN PAUL and BETTER SAX companies are striving to leverage China imported parts cost advantage while keeping eyes on QC for parts and finished goods.
Small companies that attempt this are up against a lot of odds because of the costs.The cost of even slight improvements can involve a 300% or 400% markup required to stay afloat.

There some options:

  • Import just the parts and assemble.
  • Import a whole instrument, take it apart then reassemble.

Both processes have advantages/disadvantages and often require post-import manufacture of some keywork.

You might think that it's a good idea to find a specific "factory" in China that you know make decent instruments for one of the larger (online or physical) stores. But then you find because they are ordering in much greater bulk they get the preference re: QC at source.

In the end I had decided to possibly radically redesign the keywork possibly from carbon fibre (was in discussion with two possible manufacturers in the UK and one in the EU).
 
Last edited:
Just picture these scenarios:

  • You design a much improved auxF key/action
  • Send design to factory
  • Prototype comes back and is great
  • Make order
  • Discover the same aux F suddenly appears on other brands.
There is nothing you can do to stop this as the is no IP protection available for this.

  • You order a "small" batch of 20 instruments.
  • 12 of them have a tuning issue.
  • Contact factory who say they will refund replace once they are returned.
  • Find out how much it costs to send a small shipment of 12 tenors to China
  • Give up

  • Find a dirt cheap but very decent instrument at trade show you can sell as a "student" model
  • First batch arrives and is great.
  • 2nd batch arrives and the design has changed. Why? because the big warehouse store asked for that change and the factory did it because they are the big boy pants client.
  • Give up
 
Last edited:
Small companies that attempt this are up against a lot of odds because of the costs.The cost of even slight improvements can involve a 300% or 400% markup required to stay afloat.

There some options:

  • Import just the parts and assemble.
  • Import a whole instrument, take it apart then reassemble.

Both processes have advantages/disadvantages and often require post-import manufacture of some keywork.

You might think that it's a good idea to find a specific "factory" in China that you know make decent instruments for one of the larger (online or physical) stores. But then you find because they are ordering in much greater bulk they get the preference re: QC at source.

In the end I had decided to possibly radically redesign the keywork possibly from carbon fibre (was in discussion with two possible manufacturers in the UK and one in the EU).
In the time of my short membership, I've gone from trying to incorporate cheap imports into a music instruments project for engagement to feeling skeptical that there is any hope in The Swamp. They simply don't have enough pressure / incentive / care to up the QC necessary for saxophones, in my perception.

Thank you for being so open about your research. Fascinating and helping us to understand the challenges involved.

I'll be honest with you. I wouldn't have advised Jay or anyone to extend into full instruments. MPs, lessons, swag. But not saxophones. Just so many details and the delicate nature of saxophones...NO. Maybe his exclusive with Sweetwater (big in US) will provide the scale to ensure QC.

ALSO
thank for the forum! Tons to learn.
 
I've found, over the last two years of making my pads, that trying to deal with Chinese manufacturers is a nightmare. They either can't make what you want or try to get you to buy something different which they can make or have on the shelf.

In the end I went to an American magnet manufacturer who understands what I need. Guess where their factory is!
 
To make a saxophone in UK shouldn't be impossible? Peter Jessen made his tenors in Copenhagen with help from Switzerland (keys).


IMG_3725.webp
 
To make a saxophone in UK shouldn't be impossible?
Yes it is of course possible. As in any manufacturing it can often be impractical to source all parts from one country though but to legally say "Made in England" it would need a substantial part actually made in England. I had quite a ew chats with Alastair Hanson about this as they make clarinets in England
 
In the time of my short membership

I wouldn't have advised Jay or anyone to extend into full instruments.
And yet Jay seems to be having a fine old time with his brand - mouthpiece, reeds, horn, website...

But then he has a lifetime as player, tec, reviewer etc. - even pops up here from time to time - and leverage his contacts, YouTube etc.

And, vis-a-vis your "for music engagement" Issue, at low cost... The world sorted this years ago; the recorder.

View: https://youtu.be/JQlVWOC_hvo


Job done.
 
Last edited:
And yet Jay seems to be having a fine old time with his brand - mouthpiece, reeds, horn, website...

But then he has a lifetime as player, tec, reviewer etc. - even pops up here from time to time - and leverage his contacts, YouTube etc.

And, vis-a-vis your "for music engagement" Issue, at low cost... The world sorted this years ago; the recorder.

View: https://youtu.be/JQlVWOC_hvo


Job done.

I surrender.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,071
Messages
578,538
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom