Saxophones The Best Pro Vintage Martin's for the Money?

Messages
114
Location
Utah
Level
Mediocre
I really love my 1962 Martin Alto. It has a really great sound, and I would like to venture into getting a Martin Tenor as well. I have a mint condition Yamaha YTS-52, that I purchased new and love the intonation and sound; and my Mark VII Tenor is a bit bright. I'd like a Tenor with a bit darker sound often found in vintage horns. I know the Magna Tenors are well regarded, but my budget is under $1,000 US. Throughout the Martin vintage pro horn generations, what is recommended? Thank you in advance!
 
From my experience for that budget a HC2 Lion and Crown tenor. I had a Medalist from 1961 cost me $500 and was a fantastic sax but got damaged in a move last year.
 
The so-called "committee 1 and 2" models, would be my bet. Solid nickel alloy keywork, refined design, great sound, and unjustified paranoia about soldered tone holes that helps to drive down the market value.
 
and unjustified paranoia about soldered tone holes that helps to drive down the market value.
Its not really paranoia, more a possible issue that's worth being aware of. Out of four Martins I've owned, two had issues with old soldered toneholes having leaks. It can be fixed by filling with superglue gel but the best fix is obviously to resolder.
 
Last edited:
I think Martin Handcraft (Committee and Comm II) and The Martin XXX are rather bright saxes (timbre). Just because the low tones comes nice and easy, it doesn't mean a sax is on the darker side!

Martin Handcraft Imperial is a good sax. reached the market in 1933. Differnt voice compared to the Committee saxes. Can be a good jazz horn?

I play a Handcraft (Committee) # 128 XXX (1938). Back in 1938 Martin made the HC Committee (I) and HC Comm II paralell. My HC Commitee (I) is closer to Comm II than and early Handcraft (Committee). So changes were made.

"The Martin" saxes are different soundwise. A bigger and less pointed tone.

"The Martin Magna" is based on "The Martin" model with one exeption, "The Martin Magna Baritone" to low A. The were no "The Martin Magna Baritone" to low A, just to low Bb.

My best Martin is the 1938 HC tenor. A little bit better than my 1959 Magna. I bought the HC 1938 renovated and ready to play. The renovation was made by one of guys at Tenor Madness. Me and my friend did the renovation on my Magna! We are talking about saxes that were made for 85 and 65 years ago. How a renovation is made is more important than what is engraved or stamped on the sax!!!

Thin pads (4 mm or thinner) and low key heights are important on these saxes. I've seen too many Martin saxes with too thick pads over the years.

Martin soft soldered tone holes. I have never had any problem with the tone holes. Maybe it's because I just bought well kept saxes and stayed away from attick horns.
 
I really love my 1962 Martin Alto. It has a really great sound, and I would like to venture into getting a Martin Tenor as well. I have a mint condition Yamaha YTS-52, that I purchased new and love the intonation and sound; and my Mark VII Tenor is a bit bright. I'd like a Tenor with a bit darker sound often found in vintage horns. I know the Magna Tenors are well regarded, but my budget is under $1,000 US. Throughout the Martin vintage pro horn generations, what is recommended? Thank you in advance!
A Martin Tenor, play condition, for under $1g ?

There are no other choices besides the Indiana, the Medalist, and the late Imperials.

Nix the last one, it is an Indiana with clunkier keywork and a thinner-sounding neck.

The Medalist is an Indiana.

These were the second-shelf models, but that doesn't much matter if your wallet is your wallet.

Any same-side bellkey Handcraft or Comm 1, 2, 3 in Tenor form is gonna be over $1g in serviced, good-playing shape

So there's your horn.

Good horns, very good.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,378
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom