Playing the saxophone The #1 problem in learning jazz phrasing, in my opinion.

Messages
513
Location
rome
You practiced scales and chords, but you can't create good phrases in improvisation? Why? After years of teaching experience, in various music schools and recently in the Conservatory, in this video I have exposed what is probably the mistake that is most often made in the approach to improvisation.
I hope this video can clarify this topic and can help people save time and being more productive.
Leave a comment to let me know your opinion. These videos on my channel are meant to engage discussions between saxophonists.
Have a good week end.

View: https://youtu.be/Ujl6jT49gJU?si=k_xpovqx0prZojCS
 
Agree 100%.
In my experience it’s the most difficult aspect of playing to explain as many people can’t hear that level of detail and the slight nuances are very difficult to master.

There are more types of articulation in jazz than classical. Some of the tonguing techniques in jazz - ghosting, muted/dead tonguing - would be labelled as poor articulation in classical music.

For me, an authentic jazz articulation originates with the ability to legato tongue really well. From here, mastering basic jazz ‘reverse tonguing’ is easy.

The muted, ‘dead’ tonguing (maybe more of a brass player’s terminology) is another thing - keeping (muffled/muted) sound going whilst the tongue stays on the reed, or for some; half of the reed (off to one side) is very difficult.
 
Excellent melodic playing (both Dexter and you) and a very enjoyable video. I really think that the "language" comparison works, down to phrases, sentences, accent, volume, repetition for effect, question and answer, dialogue with the other musicians. And for jazz, spontaneous making of speech, not just reciting what is on the page or what has been memorised.

One aspect that I have noticed with developing jazz improvisors is that they (we) often play a two bar chunk and then another and then another and ........ They don't leave much space and there is little sense of variation or development. Imagine if someone making a speech spoke only in sentences all of the same length, left no spaces and didn't vary their pitch, volume or energy. BORING for the listener.

Rhys
 
Last edited:
Ciao Fabrizio. Very cool video.
Just observe our kids. They learn to speak without learning the rules. Without reading anything. Just their ears, and progressively building all the links in their mind between what they hear, and the meaning.
Music is not that different.

PS: Dex, and his album Go. Top favorites of mine. You can't go wrong.
 
Good video Fabrizio and nice playing. This is from Three o'clock in the morning? Gordon makes a good joke at the start of his solo, the phrase is the same as the sound that a grandfather clock makes when the hour changes, same as in my grandparent's house. 🙂
 
Agree 100%.
In my experience it’s the most difficult aspect of playing to explain as many people can’t hear that level of detail and the slight nuances are very difficult to master.

There are more types of articulation in jazz than classical. Some of the tonguing techniques in jazz - ghosting, muted/dead tonguing - would be labelled as poor articulation in classical music.

For me, an authentic jazz articulation originates with the ability to legato tongue really well. From here, mastering basic jazz ‘reverse tonguing’ is easy.

The muted, ‘dead’ tonguing (maybe more of a brass player’s terminology) is another thing - keeping (muffled/muted) sound going whilst the tongue stays on the reed, or for some; half of the reed (off to one side) is very difficult.
You are right, articulation is very important. The main point in trascribing us that if you want to pull phrases down from the record you must listen to it many many times. And so you start hearing something that you didn't at first. The more you listen the more you discover many subtleties in accents, vibrato, articulation, bends and so on...
 
@dexdex exactly, we all started with imitation. It's a survival mechanism. Many people spend many hours in shedding and few time listening.
Of course you need both, but learning chords, scales, ecc without listening to the records is just learning rules without learning language

@rhysonsax you are right. If all phrases are stacked you can't distinguish one from the other.

@wakyct yes it's three o' clock in the morning from go. Timeless masterpiece. Dexter's playing is full of jokes as you noticed. What a player! His sound in the 60s is maybe my favourite tenor sound in history.
 
I did learn most improvisation skills by copying existing phrases, or even complete solos, 1 of them being Second Balcony Jump from Dex's Go album. The notes, but also the articulations, the timing, etc...
Long before I could name and detail specific chords, I could hear blues structures and variations, as well as typical jazz chord sequences. Second Balcony Jump is like a dictionary about how and what to play over Rhythm Changes. Without learning a single chord name.
I remember a bandmate handing me a copy of the Aebersold II-V-I book, and I go "what's II-V-I ?". He sings the first phrase of "Tune-Up*, and I go "OK, makes sense".
Of course, once you move away from the typical "American Songbook" standards, the need to dig into chords becomes more vital.
 
Last edited:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,525
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom