Playing the saxophone Tenor Player learning Alto

Don't kid yourself, there isn't a substitute for long tones and harmonics practice. You want a good alto tone? Listen to some good alto players and do some tone matching!

Suggest you read the thread instead of just pitching out an opinion. OP was, as an experienced tenor player, looking for some help/feedback on the alto setup he's just got. This type of comment is unhelpful and inappropriate.
 
Kevgermany, what an interesting opinion you have. As any serious musician would be able to see, I am in fact giving him invaluable advice on how to produce a good tone on the saxophone. If you yourself had in fact originally read the post by Antman, you would see that he describes himself as a Semi-Professional Tenor Saxophone player.

From this, we can actually draw several conclusions.

1.) Antman is not a full time musician, therefore we can clearly assume he has not spent any serious time studying the horn as a professional musician would.

2.) Being a Tenor Saxophone player and asking for help on producing a respectable Alto Sound, he is obviously not experienced in playing and producing a sound on an Alto Saxophone.

Kevgermany, I seriously question your abilities as a musician if you cannot see the benefits in my comments. A common mistake in amateur musicians is that they are too preoccupied with set-up and gear that they are in serious danger of over-looking some of the fundamentals that serious musicians spend time on, which would solve a lot of his problems.

As Antman clearly says in his original post....

"and am having problems getting a nice tone/sweet-spot. The sax is muffled in the mid-range area

Is there a method I need to practice on the armature or is the issue somewhere else.[?]

Thanks."


Please observe that the original problem was that "the saxophone is muffled in the mid-range area and asks for a solution in the form of a question, being;

"IS THERE A METHOD I NEED TO PRACTICE ON THE ARMATURE OR IS THE ISSUE SOMEWHERE ELSE.[?]

Many so called "saxophonists" on this thread began to reply with information about mouthpiece sizes and different brands, as well as the possibility of having a leak. Not ONE of these mentioned the necessity of long tones and harmonics practice in the development of an excellent tone.

No, Kevgermany, this comment was neither opinion, unhelpful nor inappropriate. It was pure fact that if Antman is having problems with tonal production and projection on his Alto Saxophone, then as a Semi-Professional Tenor Saxophone Player he should spend some time doing a fundamental exercise to help develop tonal production and projection.

Perhaps you should rethink your so called authority the next time you decide to post.
 
Dear Birdhead90

You obviously have skills and talents that I lack, as you've made clear in other posts. I wouldn't be so presumptious as to claim expertise in any area of sax playing or performing. It's always good when someone with real knowledge joins the forum and is prepared to put time in sharing their experience and helping out others who're struggling along the road of taking their love of music further and learning to play an instrument. And I thank you for this.

Please be aware that your intuition is spot on. I'm here to help with the admin, chat as one does in a cafe and generally have a good time talking saxes and music. Think of me as a janitor - or one of JK Rowling's squibs. I dabble, but am well aware of my own limitations as an aspirant sax player.

But as you're here to help, so you must also be here to learn, for true learning comes from helping others along their road in life. May I humbly suggest you study the works of Dale Carnegie? I checked, but sadly they don't appear as one of your achievements listed on your cv. A good starting point would be 'How to Win Friends and Influence People' first pubilshed in 1936, but clearly still as relevant today as it was then - just like the works of other greats, such as Dickens, Beethoven, Liszt, The Bronte Sisters and Enid Blyton. You may even find that one of his courses is available in a centre near you.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,571
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom