Tech/maintenance Tenon leak and tone?

cappers

Senior Member
Messages
1,514
Location
Sussex, UK
I've not had any particular issues with certain notes or general tone (apart forms the obvious learner errors) but after a repair of a small leak from the neck of my tenor it sounds different.

I can't exactly determine how, it just seems brighter, fuller, sharper, clearer....? Would a small neck tenon leak affect the overall sound or just certain notes? I don't know if it's confirmation bias but the neck is fixed and horn sounds different (and better).

I've noticed a lot of moisture trapped between the neck insert and the receiver on my YTS-25.
The neck has always been a tight fit but takes a lot of screw turns to nip it up and then it could be moved but I was wary of over tightening it. My YAS-25, pop the neck in and one turn to tighten.

Had a lesson today and asked my teacher/technician to look at it and he agreed it was wrong. Took it to the workshop, put the neck in some mandrel contraption and commented it wasn't true, did something involving turning a wheel moulding the neck insert and checking the fit a few times, then declared it OK. Popped it into the receiver with a tight but good fit, a turn of the screw and done. After the lesson the neck insert was totally dry 🙂

Thank you.
 
Would a small neck tenon leak affect the overall sound or just certain notes? I don't know if it's confirmation bias but the neck is fixed and horn sounds different (and better).
IMO, any leak can affect one's playing. Think of the octave key as a controlled "leak" that allows one to easily break into the upper octave. So, yes, any leak can affect things. And, it can make certain notes harder to play than others.

A leak can cause one to think that something else is wrong, like their reed, mouthpiece, embouchure, etc. When repaired these issues disappear.

My recently repaired and serviced 1980's Selmer Bundy II alto just back from the repair shop is now a joy to play, blows easy throughout the entire range.

So, your having the neck issue fixed resolved an issue. You probably already know this, but I usually put a light coat of cork grease on the neck tenon and on the tightening screw threads, so they slide in and tighten, untighten easily.
 
So, yes, any leak can affect things. And, it can make certain notes harder to play than others.

A leak can cause one to think that something else is wrong, like their reed, mouthpiece, embouchure, etc. When repaired these issues disappear.
Thanks @ghostler
As I said I didn't seem to have any difficulty with any notes and didn't hear anything amiss.

When I saw the amount of moisture on the tenon I thought if water can get there so can air. It was often moist where the neck met the tenon.

It doesn't seem different or easier to play now, it just sounds clearer (?).
 
Yes, getting rid of leaks often lets a horn respond better and may seem brighter.

So, your having the neck issue fixed resolved an issue. You probably already know this, but I usually put a light coat of cork grease on the neck tenon and on the tightening screw threads, so they slide in and tighten, untighten easily.

Grease on screws threads is fine, not recommended on the tenon. Grease on the tenon tends to attract dust and makes a mess; lubricating the tenon interface also means less friction to keep the neck from rotating and leads to overtightening the screw, which often results in stretching the receiver or breaking the screw.
 
I've not had any particular issues with certain notes or general tone (apart forms the obvious learner errors) but after a repair of a small leak from the neck of my tenor it sounds different.

I can't exactly determine how, it just seems brighter, fuller, sharper, clearer....? Would a small neck tenon leak affect the overall sound or just certain notes? I don't know if it's confirmation bias but the neck is fixed and horn sounds different (and better).
Every saxophone has micro leaks, some leak less, some more. These leaks affects different things.

volume as leaks reduce the efficiency to move air.

fullness of sound on both ends of the harmonics. The fundamental is louder and the higher overtones are easier to play.

The start of a note requires less energy without leaks, so fast notes with only embouchure become easier.

In short happiness is a good closing saxophone.
 
I can't exactly determine how, it just seems brighter, fuller, sharper, clearer....? Would a small neck tenon leak affect the overall sound or just certain notes? I don't know if it's confirmation bias but the neck is fixed and horn sounds different (and better).
Yep, it would have an effect. How much depends on where the leak is and how large it is.
In the case of a leak through the tenon joint there may be some resistance as the air finds its path through the joint. This tends to lead to a slight instability throughout the horn. Experienced players may not even notice it, others may find that certain notes become tricky - such as A and/or low/mid D. Bell notes will typically lose a bit of punch.

A large leak through the joint - often as a result of an out-of-round receiver or a split around the strain relief slot - can have very obvious effects for all players, though most of them would tend to attribute the problem to pad leaks.

The nastiest leak in this area is a pinhole leak though the soldered joint where the receiver is fitted to the body. It's pretty much a straight-through path for the air and you'd be very lucky indeed if you saw any evidence that anything was wrong.
It's a little bit like the problem you often get with soldered-on toneholes; the leak often only shows up when you sloosh some naphtha over it.
Such a leak typically knackers the A and leads to motorboating down at the lower end.
It usually occurs as a result of the solder breaking down through selective galvanic corrosion - but in some cases, particularly on Ultra-Cheap horns, it can be down to poor soldering. The same can be true of where the crook is fitted to the tenon sleeve.

The usual comment I get from players after I've tightened up a tenon joint is that the horn feels 'more alive'.
And that's about right really.
 
.............

The usual comment I get from players after I've tightened up a tenon joint is that the horn feels 'more alive'.
And that's about right really.
'More alive'....Yes! That's what it feels like now, not that I noticed a problem before or if I did I put it down to pilot error.
Thank you.

P.S. @Stephen Howard - I just nabbed a copy of your Haynes sax repair manual on eBay. Silly money but not as much as some I've seen. Collectors' item now!
 
P.S. @Stephen Howard - I just nabbed a copy of your Haynes sax repair manual on eBay. Silly money but not as much as some I've seen. Collectors' item now!
Every year or so I re-read two books on saxophone. Larry Teal’s The Art of Saxophone Playing and the Stephen Howard’s Haynes manual. These two books stand out as beacons of common sense in a world of suspect mythological advice.
 
Waiting for SH's manual to arrive and have LT's TAoSP. The latter is a goldmine for me, a nugget every time I read a chapter.
I doubt I'll do much of what's in the Haynes manual, but knowing how to maintain and COA it will be useful.
My limited mechanical skills were learned on old land Rovers, the parts are a lot bigger and rather less delicate than those on a sax.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,318
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom