Saxophones Tell me about the tenor

PaulC

Member
Messages
84
Location
Canada
I'm thinking that the different ergonomics of a tenor may be more suited to me and my particular issues compared to my alto.

I'm sure it's heavier and obviously larger, but I'm thinking if I use a harness it might work out better with my troubled hands.

Alas, my messing around with the clarinet was short lived with my hand troubles.

Am I nuts?
 
You´re nuts. Only crazy people want to play tenor.

Might not be as big a difference as you think. It´s bigger and the hands are further apart, but the position and movement of the hand itself isn´t vastly different.
 
Only crazy people want to play tenor.
And, truly crazy people own more than one? 😉 (Just joshing, I have 2.) 😀
I'm thinking that the different ergonomics of a tenor may be more suited to me and my particular issues compared to my alto. I'm sure it's heavier and obviously larger, but I'm thinking if I use a harness it might work out better with my troubled hands.
You may be able to find something in front or to the side of your chair for the bottom crook (elbow) of the tenor to rest upon, raise it to comfortable playing height. When I suffered a disk herniation in my lower back, I couldn't let the weight hang from the neck. Been a while, but I found a way to prop it up without it hanging on me. This is from my wheeled walker that I could sit in. It took a few gyrations and experimentation (coffee table, stepping stool, hassock, boxes, etc.) before I got it to work for me.

Good luck! :thumb:
 
thinking if I use a harness it might work out better with my troubled hands.
It may help to say what your hand troubles are. I don’t get on with harnesses but they can help with neck and possibly back issues, but would not have much impact on hand problems.

If you are holding the instrument (alto or tenor) correctly there should be no weight on the hands at all.

If you have a physiotherapist, a good plan may be to go to them with a tenor and an alto and see what they think.
 
The harness is good for me. Helped me with neck and back problem, as Pete Thomas already pointed out. . I began to play in a more relaxed way when I started to play with harness. To hang something around my neck holds me back.

Just a few excercises I can do to keep my hands and fingers in good shape. I've been working with my hands through the years and it's a little bit depressing when the power and motion is fading out. I can try to compensate with excercises and to use my hands hands in other ways. Typing on a computer or smartphone is not helping much.

I like singing saxplayers; King Curtis, Jr Walker , Red Prysock ...... and so on. All tenor specailists. Never heard a soprano specilists who can sing well.
 
My hand problems stem from a lack of dexterity and pain. Clarinet is a no go, alto is better but I am thinking tenor might be the solution.

Plus most of my favorite players play tenor.

As for the harness, I have back and neck problems so I am thinking that the harness is the way to go.
 
I have various back and neck problems too. Be aware that physical conditioning and posture can help provide relief in some instances. If you are bent forward - even while wearing a harness - the forces on your lower back are still much the same. Sitting upright, in addition to stronger core muscles, can actually redistribute the load.
 
I developed problems with my back and neck and tried all sorts of harnesses to no avail. They each seemed to bring other problems without doing much for the main ones. You might find the Jazzlab Sax Holder works for you, I would research it and see what you think. It certainly takes away the weight.


In the end my solution was exercise to build up strength in both my neck and my core muscles. It takes a while but worked for me.
I’m not sure that switching to tenor will help, it won’t give much more room to manoeuvre and will be heavier.
 
Are you taking the weight on your hands or gripping too tight?

Try playing without using your thumbs. Adjust the sling and neck so that you can blow a C# no hands. Keeping your thumbs idle, place your fingers on the buttons and play there. It's not a practical way to play. However it's an exercise that will let you know how little input your hands need to make.

Another solution may be a sax seat. There are various designs.

 
My hand problems stem from a lack of dexterity and pain. Clarinet is a no go, alto is better but I am thinking tenor might be the solution.

Plus most of my favorite players play tenor.

As for the harness, I have back and neck problems so I am thinking that the harness is the way to go.
If most of your favourite players play tenor, then you should definitely play the tenor!
I started on tenor because that's the sound I liked the most. I have added a bari and a soprano to my stable. I think I won't be adding an alto because I don't like the sound of an alto.

I have bought a harness at the beginning, and I still use the same one. It puts the weight on my shoulders instead of my neck, and for me it works very well. mine is this kind: Sax harness - Man
 
I worked out a swap for a tenor.

What a revelation!

The sound is so great. It does seem to need a little more air than the alto, especially for the lower register, but it didn't take long to adjust.

After a little divine intervention I decided to try a synthetic reed. I really like it, and it doesn't have the problems of cane.

As for the ergonomics, they are much better.

I'm digging the tenor so far.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,059
Messages
578,326
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom