Saxophone beginners Taking a breath and songs

But if the language is unfamiliar, word boundaries can be had to spot
And can lead to some comical results, e.g. the song Happiness. I think it was Peter Sellers who came up with this one

[Edit: maybe confusing it with his line in a movie...)

Original Lyrics:

Happiness, happiness, the greatest gift that I possess
I thank the lord that I possess, more than my share of happiness


With breath in the wrong place (actually it's more of an incorrect accent and misheard lyric but I put it to you as a fine piece of pseudo risqué comedy)

A penis, a penis, the greatest gift that I possess
I thank the lord that I possess, more than my share of a penis
 
Last edited:
And can lead to some comical results, e.g. the song Happiness. I think it was Peter Sellers who came up with this one

[Edit: maybe confusing it with his line in a movie...)

Original Lyrics:

Happiness, happiness, the greatest gift that I possess
I thank the lord that I possess, more than my share of happiness


With breath in the wrong place (and misheard lyric)

A penis, a penis, the greatest gift that I possess
I thank the lord that I possess, more than my share of a penis
You should have seen Ken Dodd doing that on stage.
 
Here's what I am playing in It Don't Mean a Thing (Duke Ellington arr. Chuck Sayre). I'm in the background here and I think the low brass are carrying the melody, but the notes played line up with "...if it ain't got that swing." There are only nine more bars that follow, but the only breath marks indicated for me are at measures 61-64. All notes beginning at measure 5 are at ff in cut time. I love the descent from C# down to Bb and then the jump back up to D# so it can drop once more to C#.
It Dont Mean A Thing Breath Marks.webp
 
Here's what I am playing in It Don't Mean a Thing (Duke Ellington arr. Chuck Sayre). I'm in the background here and I think the low brass are carrying the melody, but the notes played line up with "...if it ain't got that swing." There are only nine more bars that follow, but the only breath marks indicated for me are at measures 61-64. All notes beginning at measure 5 are at ff in cut time. I love the descent from C# down to Bb and then the jump back up to D# so it can drop once more to C#.
That's an unusual case where the composer is using a breath mark to dictate note length.

In most cases it's used for phrasing. If there are no breath marks, use you own judgment or sync or stagger with your section mates according to the phrasing. If some other artist breaks in a different place, then it's up to you whether to follow their example or go your own way.
 
Here's what I am playing in It Don't Mean a Thing (Duke Ellington arr. Chuck Sayre). I'm in the background here and I think the low brass are carrying the melody, but the notes played line up with "...if it ain't got that swing." There are only nine more bars that follow, but the only breath marks indicated for me are at measures 61-64. All notes beginning at measure 5 are at ff in cut time. I love the descent from C# down to Bb and then the jump back up to D# so it can drop once more to C#.View attachment 23632
For what it's worth, I would NOT take a breath between each of those notes. Rather, I would interpret the notation as an intention to detach the notes from one another.
 
Here's what I am playing in It Don't Mean a Thing (Duke Ellington arr. Chuck Sayre). I'm in the background here and I think the low brass are carrying the melody, but the notes played line up with "...if it ain't got that swing." There are only nine more bars that follow, but the only breath marks indicated for me are at measures 61-64. All notes beginning at measure 5 are at ff in cut time. I love the descent from C# down to Bb and then the jump back up to D# so it can drop once more to C#.View attachment 23632
That makes no sense to breathe there, you would hyperventilate. If the arranger meant rot leave a small gap they should have written the note length they want.

That's an unusual case where the composer is using a breath mark to dictate note length.

Yes, if the arranger Chuck Sayre had just copied Ellington's score then I believe Ellington did use sometimes some odd shorthand notation for phrasing and note lengths.
 
Last edited:
#29-#31 have caused me to research this just a tad further. Wikipedia has an interesting take on it, and I quote it here:
(The bold italics are mine)

A breath mark or luftpause is a symbol used in musical notation. It directs the performer of the music passage to take a breath (for wind instruments and vocalists) or to make a slight pause (for non-wind instruments). This pause is normally intended to shorten the duration of the preceding note and not to alter the tempo; in this function it can be thought of as a grace rest. It is usually placed above the staff and at the ends of phrases. Its function is analogous to the comma in several written languages. Indeed, a common notation for the breath mark looks very similar to a written comma.

My guess is that either Ellington or Sayre places the breath marks to indicate that the notes should be shortened slightly more than what otherwise would be indicated without the notations.

This thread came to mind last evening while at rehearsal. I am happy to report that no musicians were harmed during the practice of this piece.
 
#29-#31 have caused me to research this just a tad further. Wikipedia has an interesting take on it, and I quote it here:
(The bold italics are mine)

A breath mark or luftpause is a symbol used in musical notation. It directs the performer of the music passage to take a breath (for wind instruments and vocalists) or to make a slight pause (for non-wind instruments). This pause is normally intended to shorten the duration of the preceding note and not to alter the tempo; in this function it can be thought of as a grace rest. It is usually placed above the staff and at the ends of phrases. Its function is analogous to the comma in several written languages. Indeed, a common notation for the breath mark looks very similar to a written comma.

My guess is that either Ellington or Sayre places the breath marks to indicate that the notes should be shortened slightly more than what otherwise would be indicated without the notations.

This thread came to mind last evening while at rehearsal. I am happy to report that no musicians were harmed during the practice of this piece.

Did your director or section leader take the time to discuss how to interpret the passage? That's the type of communication that should occur when introducing a new chart. If you are a new addition to the band, you should listen for like passages occurring in other sections to learn how the band is interpreting the phrase.
 
This is Mizmar's thread, and I don't want to stray from his pursuit. But to answer your question, I've not heard any mention of that specific issue. We have 14 songs to perform in four weeks with a maximum of four hours per week as an ensemble, so I can see how something that may affect only a small part of the whole could get overlooked. I will ask about it at our next rehearsal. I've been in the band since 2020.
 
Here's what I am playing in It Don't Mean a Thing (Duke Ellington arr. Chuck Sayre). I'm in the background here and I think the low brass are carrying the melody, but the notes played line up with "...if it ain't got that swing." There are only nine more bars that follow, but the only breath marks indicated for me are at measures 61-64. All notes beginning at measure 5 are at ff in cut time. I love the descent from C# down to Bb and then the jump back up to D# so it can drop once more to C#.View attachment 23632

IMHO (just as an amateur), up until bar 61, you have plenty of time (whole bars!) to breathe. I really don't understand the notation from bar 61 onwards. Rather than 'dynanamics' notation (as in bars 55-60) it suddenly switches to 'breath notation'. Depending on the tempo, all or most of the 'breath notations' are IMHO completely superfluous.

Even worse, given these superfluous breath notations, other 'dynamics' haven't been notated.

I can't think of any other 'suspect' than a (badly) computer-generated score.
 
Warning - ASCII “notation” following. I would have notated it with a combination dot (staccato) and legato mark. I’ve seen this before. The alternative is a dotted quarter with an eighth note rest, maybe with a legato mark over it.

Neither of these are obvious to inexperienced readers. The version given takes less ink…


.
_
O
|


I too would play that whole 4 bars in a single breath, those commas just indicate a space between the notes.
 
I solicited comments from our director regarding the recent issue. The results are below. I have italicized in bold, his words regarding the breath marks.
My apologies once again to Mizmar for occupying too much of this thread, as it has become about a very specific issue rather than his original question.

Hi John!
Your alto parts in this arrangement are simply a transposition of the orchestral arrangement which originally calls for French Horn, not alto sax. The purpose of the horns was to give the original trombone descending block chords solid beats on each half note with a swing accent into the whole note in measure 64. This chord actually to be played on the end of 4 in measure 63. Should sound like this: 61(do' do') 62(do' do')63(do' do-oo 64(-oo). The breath marks are there to remind players to exaggerate the jazz articulation interpreted by jazz player who understood how to SWING. The did this many times by listening and simply copying what they heard on the piano. Each individual is playing one pitch of a four-note chord. The pianist plays all of them and when their hand raises from the key the chord stops. That's creating space and is simply what this arranger is trying to copy. Feel free to share this!
 
The breath marks are there to remind players to exaggerate the jazz articulation interpreted by jazz player who understood how to SWING
I have no idea what he means in this context, can you explain.

it-dont-mean-a-thing-breath-marks-png.23632

Jazz articulation is to do with tonguing and I have never seen those comma or apostrophe marks to denote any kind of tonguing or other articulation.


This also seems to make no sense in the context:

with a swing accent into the whole note in measure 64
So there is a half-note D♮ slurred to the C# with no accents visible (swing or otherwise). I can understand how the commas could be used to denote a gap between the notes though (but it could probably be done in more conventional ways to be clearer)
 
Last edited:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,571
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom