As an experienced choral singer... there are no absolute answers as to where to take breaths. Some are easy and obvious, some are not. Some phrases are just too long to be realistically sung in one breath and you have to work out a solution. Bach is particularly challenging in that respect as his vocal lines are often very 'instrumental'.
In choirs, you can cheat as you can use what is known as staggered breathing where people on the same part breath in different places to give the sense of continuous sound. Not an option for one to a part.
In choirs, you can cheat as you can use what is known as staggered breathing where people on the same part breath in different places to give the sense of continuous sound. Not an option for one to a part.
