Introduction Switch from clarinet to sax

Lockjaw

Member
Messages
63
Hi everyone

I'm currently teaching my 10 yo daughter clarinet, she's doing well, taking grade 3 shortly.

At some point she'd like to switch to sax as it has more use in the music she listens to (pop & r'n'b). I'd ideally like her to go further before switching, but keeping her motivation is more important.

When is a good time to switch, and if so to what sax? My Yamaha 62 alto is too heavy for her.

So the options are probably 1) get a lighter alto e.g. the Trevor James alphasax (the one with missing keys to save weight). I don't want to be snobby about it, probably it's good for a complete beginner but my daughter is already used to the little finger & side keys on the clari. Or 2) go for the soprano. Which sounds better but the prevailing wisdom seems to be it's not a beginner's instrument.

Any advice?
 
Welcome Simon and young Miss Hingley from my farm here in Surrey.
I shall leave it to the more informed minds to proffer advice but it might be more appropriate to change your forename to Eddie. One of the great.
 
Hi Lockjaw and welcome to the Breakfastroom.

I would get her on saxophone NOW!!!

Alto would be better than soprano because of band/ensemble playing potential and possible easier for beginners also.

I'm not a big fan of Trevor James. I'm surprised a Yamaha is too heavy - does she already know how to hold it, if not that could be the problem.

I know small 8 year olds who have no problem holding any alto.
 
I'm tall, but at 10 most of my girlfriends were playing the alto, and I started on tenor!

I agree with Pete, start now and try one of the harness neckstraps that are on the market - they claim to reduce the weight by 50% - that should help quite a bit. Here's a link to Neotech website - http://tinyurl.com/56hr39. She'll have a lot more fun playing the sax I guarantee you 🙂 If she's already doing well on clarinet, the ability to double on another instrument "doubles" your playing opportunities 😉
 
Hi Simon from another Simon here in rainy Daventry!

My son was in a similar situation he was coming up to grade 4 on clarinet and wanted to switch to saxophone, but he wanted a soprano. I managed to talk him out of it for the time being and got him a new Yamaha YSL250 clarinet. Soprano is not the easiest beast to tame as a first sax. I have said to him that he can go onto either alto or tenor after grade 5.

Also great name, Eddie Davis was and is one of my favourite tenor men.

Simon
 
No, a proper welcome to you from Swansea, overlooking the sea, and absolute miles from any sax shops (though there is one in Abergavenny that sells Bauhaus Walsteins amongst others). as they say "online and upwards!"

Kind regards and warm greetings!
Tom 8)
 
Hi Simon,

Welcome to the Breakfast Room from a fellow 62 series Yamaha alto owner, from Downunder - I recently purchased a Lockjaw DVD Live At Montreux Norman Granz Series. Good stuff.

They're a good friendly crowd here.

Regards,
Greg Strange.

P.S. Tom, you certainly have an impressive range of musical instruments - adding any more to the collection?
 
If I had ever learned to play clarinet, which unfortunately I never did, then I would go straight out and buy myself a bass clarinet, instantly transporting myself from old fashioned traddy to the vanguard of cutting edge contemporary music!! Just a thought.
 
I must admit the bass clarinet is a really cool tool!

They're still a bit on the pricey side right now though, even student models demand about 6 big ones!

which is hardly impulse purchase territory. 🙁

I guess the fingering must be similar to normal clarinet though no doubt someone here could enlighten me on that one.

Simon
 
Hi Simon

From memory (a long time ago) fingering pretty much the same as a normal clarinet. Maybe one or 2 more keys at the bottom, can't remember.

But as you say, very cool! I never tried miking one though, don't know if there's the same issues as with a standard clari (2 mikes needed for a reasonably flat response).

What stuff do you play by the way? I'm just up the A5 in Cannock but usually gig in Birmingham.

Simon
 
Maybe an Amati 33 AAS can be an alternative. The keys are designed for small hands. Better than most PRC made studentsaxes.

Thomas

http://www.amati.cz/english/production/instruments/Files/aas/aas_33.htm
 
Lockjaw wrote:
Hi Simon

From memory (a long time ago) fingering pretty much the same as a normal clarinet. Maybe one or 2 more keys at the bottom, can't remember.

But as you say, very cool! I never tried miking one though, don't know if there's the same issues as with a standard clari (2 mikes needed for a reasonably flat response).

What stuff do you play by the way? I'm just up the A5 in Cannock but usually gig in Birmingham.

Simon

I'm, as they say euthemistically, between bands right now(second start on a young family), but was in a covers band doing all the usual stuff, blues, commitments, rock and roll, current, stones etc.

Although a group of us are getting together this weekend, see Sax Kitten thread, looking forward to that.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,060
Messages
578,342
Members
8,128
Latest member
Roger Atlas
Back
Top Bottom