Dear Tenor Viol,
your approach is correct if you see grades as a 'way' and not as a 'goal'.
But often children (and mostly parents) see grades as an achievement for their child. And that gives a very partial view on music, perpetuated by the fact that mediocre musicians with good grades will become teachers themselves.
Since you play viol too, I am sure you experienced the debate about intonation of a perfect fifth: the good boy will tell that you have to play that C/G in tune with the piano, since those are the only C/G. The bad boy (or the knowledgeable one) will just play a non tempered fifth, since there is no piano and you are playing early music and piano wasn't even invented at the time.
A teaching system that curbs your mental flexibility can affect all your future musical development.
You're introducing a very complex subject here, i.e. temperament. As an early music specialist and adult learner on a Renaissance/Baroque instrument and as someone with what is probably an above-average amount of music theory, I am probably more aware of this area than many people are. :shocked: I am a long way short of being an expert in this area, what I know I've picked up from books and from speaking to various early music tutors.
I don't know what is taught in the upper echelons such as diploma or licentiate level, but I don't think much attention is paid to temperament until music degree/conservatoire level (i.e. Royal Academy, RCM, RNCM etc) - maybe someone more knowledgeable on this could throw some light on the subject?
Good/experienced players of woodwind/brass/strings will learn to temper intervals to improve the tuning (i.e 'temper' various intervals, especially thirds/fifths). However, if you are playing with an equal temperament instrument such as a piano or other keyboard, then you have no choice but to tune to that.
What would be more useful is more awareness of this subject which even many experienced musicians are unaware of. If your sole performance experience as a musician is working alongside an ET keyboard, you are not going to have much awareness of this. People who mostly hear ET tuning will think that an ET major third is in tune, because it is what they are used to hearing. Whereas, it is in fact rather sharp and should be narrowed...;}
For fun, I did a barber shop singing day a few years ago: you really learn about harmonic tuning doing that.

I have a monthly lesson on my viol. I am just now getting to the point where I am sufficiently aware that going from an open F string to a C third fret on the A string may not be in tune. I currently tune the viol in ET but I am beginning to think about moving to an alternative - Velotti is popular with viol players, as is 1/6 coma mean tone. As this involves cutting the frets off my instrument and tying on new frets and tuning them it is not a minor operation: I'd also need an appropriate tuner (Korg make one for £100)
I think the important thing is to get people on the musical journey - we can add and improve these things as they develop their skills.
Some reading in these sort of areas:
- Lies my music teacher told me, Gerald Eskelin, Stage 3 Publishing
- How equal temperament ruined harmony, Ross W Duffin, *
- Tuning and temperaments a historical survey, J Murray Barbour, Dover **
- Lutes, Viols and Temperaments, Mark Lindley, Cambridge University Press **
- Play the Viol, Alison Crum, Oxford University Press ***
** not light reading!
*** This is the modern 'standard' tutor for the viol, includes sections on tuning and temperaments. Alison is a member of the Rose Consort of Viols and is London based
Last edited by a moderator:


