Teaching Stupid question from the American colonies about grades :)

Well, this is a fascinating thread ......I don't understand any of it, beyond the first page, which answered the OP's question and then went-off into some foreign language🙂))

Well. I did see this quote "Music is no fun if you're always playing solo" and thoroughly disagree .....one of my more uncomfortable recent experiences was sitting-in with a very friendly local band.
They were short of a tenor sax, so asked me to give it a go, although I had only had my tenor for a few months, so that was a daunting start.
Then, once they started playing, I was 'lost' almost immediately, not being used to playing a few(seemingly irrelevant) notes, and then hoping to keep track of where the heck we had got-to, and when my turn would next come around.
I was completely 'at sea' and hated every minute of it....except the coffee break 🙁
I sold my tenor soon after, and am concentrating on trying to make a decent sound on my alto, for my own satisfaction, and to 'entertain' the neighbours 🙂
We are not all the same!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
their students could play the examination pieces and not much more.


Jim.

Isn't this true of any and every exam system in use in this country?
At age 10, my children spent a whole school year being taught how to get a good grade in their SATs, at age 14-16 they spend 2 years being taught how to get good grades in their GCSEs and promptly do the same again for 2 years for their A-levels. Isn't the rest of their life the bit that applies these skills to make an all round "person" be it musician, scientist, whatever.

Interestingly, my sax teacher has encouraged a couple of her teenage pupils to join our community band because she feels they will not proceed to grade 7 or beyond successfully without the experience of playing in such a group.
 
any good?
It's a good read. He's done quite a lot of analysis of for example very early recordings of pianos and violins (includnig late C19th wax cylinders. From this he deduces that string players don't play in ET. Pianos in his opinion pre 1920 were generally NOT tuned in genuine ET, but something akin to 1/6 coma mean tone. True ET came in during the 1920s when the way that piano tuners worked changed to the modern method using beats.

He's a bit messianic in places so keep an open mind.

The other book that has some interesting points in this area (but it's not a book about temperaments, it's a more general book) is called 'Lies my music teacher told me' by Eskelin

http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/search/r...&tag=lpo_ixdpamusukengl_book-21&index=blended
 
Buck,
It was meant to be amusing. My brother-in-law built me a mountain dulcimer, which for you pedants is not classed as a dulcimer but made it chromatic! Had an Schmidt autoharp but could never sound like Mother Maybelle unless the underpants instantly shrunk.

I was amused. I thought it your post was funny, and my reply was intended to be funny as well. It was supposed to be humor of the self-deprecating sort. I should have put a smiley on it. :thumb:
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,662
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom