Intonation Student & Pro Saxes - Intonation & Fluctuating Temperature

It is actually the slower speed of sound in cold air and faster speed of sound in hot air that changes the pitch. It has nothing to do with the expansion or contraction of the metal. I used to think that as well. 🙂 Ferron's book also gives a chart showing the speed of sound at various temperatures.

15° C - 59° F sound travels 340 meters per second
20° C - 68° F sound travels at 343 meters per second
25° C - 77° F sound travels at 346 meters per second

In Benade's writing he gives 347 meters per second as a "good value" to use for the warm moist air at the upper end of a woodwind. That corresponds approximately with an air temperature of 25° C - 77° F. Of course for saxophone players who are "full of hot air" the speed of sound can be even faster. 😛

Air (in the sax tube) is expanding and contraction as well? "Cold" or "hot" metal affects the air stream"?
 
As the air gets warmer the molecules are farther apart and travel faster. The "soundwave(s)" inside a saxophone are not "airstreams" per se, they are oscillations of air molecules back and forth. This animation provides a good visualization of what takes place. AFAK all the temperature of the metal does is influence the temperature of the air inside the saxophone. Another good analogy is the wave in a lake created by a motorboat 200 yards off shore. The water around the boat doesn't travel. It stays where it is, It is only the "wave" that travels 200 yards to splash up on the beach.
 
Another good analogy is that when you throw a stone into a bucket of three-toed sloths the ripples spread outwards.
(ISIRTA approx. 50 years ago)

However as yet the discussion has been on the air temperature, what about the moisture content of the air at those temperatures affecting the speed of sound?
 
I know it effects it, I should have said what are the thoughts on the effect or lack of on saxophone intonation?
Also a good question. I don't know of any studies on that particular topic. I do know that in a "cold" instrument the player's breath warms the air in part of the instrument closest to the mouthpiece sooner. That could have a modest effect giving "short tube" notes a slightly higher pitch relative to "long tube" notes---at least until the entire instrument warms up.

An interesting topic that is somewhat related is that sound travels slower in an atmosphere that contains more CO2. It has been measured on oboe that at the end of a long phrase where the player has "exhaled" more CO2 into the instrument, the pitch goes flat. Sound travels much faster in helium so when a player takes a breath of helium (not advised) and blows into an instrument the pitch initially is much higher. It is the same principle that makes a person's voice sound like "Mickey Mouse".

 
Good question. The short answer is that increasing the humidity increases the speed of sound to a certain degree. For a more detailed answer see: Effect of Humidity on the Speed of Sound.
I know it effects it, I should have said what are the thoughts on the effect or lack of on saxophone intonation?
I would expect the air inside the sax to become saturated with water vapour from the player's lungs after a short time playing (Hence all the condensation inside the instrument and on the pads.). I doubt that the ambient humidity would have much of an effect on that. Maybe more of an effect in the bari than the sop.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,385
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom